POEMS ON SEVERAL OCCASIONS.
WITH A DISSERTATION UPON The Roman POETS.
By Mr. ADDISON.
LONDON: Printed for E. CURLL in Fleet-street. 1719.
PREFACE.
NOW the Translations of Mr. Addison's POEMS appear together, it may not be improper to make a few Observations on Modern Latin Poetry, and in particular the following Compositions.
Since the general Disuse and Corruption of the Latin Tongue, there are not many Attempts in Poetry in that Language that retain the Purity and [Page vi] Graces of the Augustan-Age. The Italians, by the Encouragement of the House of MEDICIS, first began the Study and Imitation of the best Roman Poets; and about the Time of Leo the X th, there appeared a great Number of fine Genius's, who endeavour'd to shake off the Barbarity, and polish the Rust of an ignorant Age. The Event very near answer'd their Expectations, and the Muses seem'd to be re-instated in their old Land of Inheritance. The Reader may see a Collection of their best Pieces in a Volume intitul'd Poetae Italici; but among all of them Vida is the most pure and elegant, tho' some are offended at the perpetual Imitation of his Darling VIRGIL. The French have nothing considerable that I have [Page vii] seen in this way, but Rapin, whose Poems every where discover a Roman Colouring; and as he does not follow VIRGIL'S Expression so nearly as Vida, he is more agreeable to the Judicious. Vida with an easy Felicity adapts VIRGIL'S Words to every Subject, Rapin chuses rather to imitate his manner of Expression than borrow his very Phrases: So that we may say of these Two, as Mr. Dryden does of Fletcher's and Johnson's copying Shakespear:
The Dutch themselves have some no mean Latin Poems, as is evident from the Works of Grotius and Heinsius. [Page viii] Buchanan is the just boast of the Scots Nation: He was a perfect Master of the Latin Tongue, knew all its Strength and Beauties, and very happily transfus'd them into his own Poems. That neglected Piece of his De Sphaerâ is upon so nice and difficult a Subject as fine and noble a Poem as ever was wrote; tho' I don't know by what Fate, the Modern Criticks are never pleas'd to mention it to his Honour. I beg their Pardons for calling them Criticks, a Name too glorious for these Borrowers of others Opinions, who live upon the Plunder of Scaliger and Rapin without consulting the Originals; where, if they have happen'd to praise any thing, these Gentlemen take all upon trust, and [Page ix] are Strangers to every Fault and Excellence they have omitted to Blame or Commend.
As to our own Nation, the Occasional Copies in the Ʋniversity Collections, are the best Poems we have; the chief of which are publish'd in the Musae Anglicanae, tho' I have read a great many more which deserve an equal Honour. Out of these we have singled the Poems of Mr. Addison, as the most shining Ornaments of that Work, and given the unlearned Reader the Pleasure of admiring them in his Native Language. I will not say that it is absolutely necessary to be a good Latin Poet in order to become a good English One, but I [Page x] am sure that he who imitates the Antients in their own Language will slide more easily into their way of Thinking, adapt their Graces by Degrees, and beautifully transplant them into his Mother-Tongue; and these are no vulgar Beauties in an English Poem. I could mention how successfully this was done by Milton formerly, and in our Times by Mr. Addison, if it did not draw me into too great a length of Preface, which more properly belongs to the following Pieces.
Most of these, tho' very perfect in their kinds, I am apt to believe were design'd as Trials of a great Genius, after the modest manner of [Page xi] the Antients, who began to sport and play in Essays of their Poetical Strength before they attempted Subjects of a greater Dignity. To speak of them in general, I observe that the Language is Pure, Elegant, and Sounding; the Versification easy and numerous, happily adapted to the different Subjects it describes, free from the affected Turns, Puerile Levities, and other Flatnesses, which betray a false Taste, and Defect of Judgment. The Critick every where accompanies the Poet, and even here a discerning Eye might have seen the Promises of a CAMPAIGN and a CATO.
[Page xii] The Battel of the Pygmies and Cranes, The Puppet-Show, and The Bowling-Green, are of the Mock-Heroic kind, the Subjects mean and trivial, seemingly incapable of Poetical Ornaments, but are rais'd to the Heroic, by a splendid Boldness of Expression, a Pomp of Verse, by Metaphors, Allusions, and Similitudes drawn from Things of a higher Class, and such as are suited by Nature to convey Ideas of Greatness and Magnificence to the Mind. VIRGIL, in his Georgicks, is the great Master in this way, with this Difference only, that his is a serious Geandeur, this a Mimic one, his produces Admiration, this Laughter.
[Page xiii] The Resurrection is a noble Piece, drawn after the Painter with a masterly Hand. As it has been spoken to by the Translator, I leave the Reader to his Observations.
The Barometer is a fine Philosophical Poem, describing the Effects of the Air on that wonderful Instrument with great Exactness, as well as in the most beautiful Poetry. The Odes to Dr. Burnett and Dr. Hannes are written in the true Spirit of HORACE, and are only equall'd among the Moderns by those excellent ones of the Latter.
[Page xiv] The Peace of Reswick is here plac'd last, but first in the Original, in which the Author seems to have exerted all his Powers, to make it shine above his other Compositions. It is, indeed, a Master-Piece, the Images are chosen with a nice Judgment, work'd up with a Delicacy of Imagination, and plac'd in the strongest Light. Every thing strikes at the first View, and yet will bear the strictest Eye to re-examine it. The Descriptions being both just and surprizing, put the Mind upon the full stretch as they are preparing, and exceed the boldest Expectations when finish'd. Upon this occasion I can't help remarking, that the Art of [Page xv] War being so much chang'd since the Roman Times, it must be a difficult Task to find Words in that Language to express even the common Ideas of a Modern Battel; but to do it in all its terrible Scenes of new Inventions was reserv'd for the Pen of Mr. Addison.
The Translators, I hope, need not make any excuse to the Reader, tho' they will want an Apology to the Author, whose Excellencies their Copies but faintly imitate. All that I can say in our Defence, is, that some of them have fell into much worse Hands before, who have mangled his Sense, and debas'd his Poetry, by a cold, unspirited Translation. Thus [Page xvi] if he does some Kindness in a moral way, who takes off part of an Injury, tho' he can't redress the Whole, we may hope at least to be forgiven who have corrected many Abuses cast on Mr. Addison by former Authors, tho' we could not in all things do him the Justice he deserves.
Ad Insignissimum Virum D. THO. BURNETTUM, Sacrae Theoriae Telluris Autorem.
AN ODE To the Learned Dr. Thomas Burnett, AUTHOR of The Theory of the EARTH.
AD D.D. HANNES, INSIGNISSIMUM MEDICUM & POETAM.
AN ODE TO Dr. HANNES, An Eminent PHYSICIAN and POET.
ΠΥΓΜΑΙΟ-ΓΕΡΑΝΟ-ΜΑΧΙΑ, SIVE, PRAELIUM INTER PYGMAEOS & GRUES commissum.
THE BATTEL OF THE PYGMIES and CRANES.
BAROMETRI DESCRIPTIO.
THE BAROMETER: OR, WEATHER-GLASS.
MACHINAE GESTICULANTES.
THE PUPPET-SHOW.
THE RESURRECTION: A POEM.
The FOURTH EDITION.
THE PREFACE.
THE following Lines are esteemed by the best Judges to be the finest Sketch of the Resurrection, that any Age or Language has produced: Nor do their only Excellence consist in being an accurate Poem; but also in being an exact Copy of the Painter's Original upon the Altar in Magdalen College; but so much improved with [Page 82] all the strongest Figures and most lively Embellishments of a Poetical Description, that the Reader receives a double Satisfaction in seeing the two Sister-Arts so useful to each other, in borrowing mutual Helps, and mutual Advantages.
It is, indeed, wonderful to find in the narrow Compass of so few Pages all the most dreadful Circumstances of that last terrible Crisis of Time: The Poem is a beautiful and succinct Epitome of all that has or can ever be said on that important Subject; the very Text, which the ingenious Mr. Young has so largely and elegantly paraphras'd upon, in his excellent Poem on the LAST DAY.
[Page 83] Mr. Addison is to be distinguish'd thro' all his Performances both Latin and English (and in his Latin, particularly in the following one, and that on the Peace of Reswick,) by the Strength of his Images, and by a forcible and unaffected Vivacity of Expression, which none of our Moderns have attain'd to in so much Perfection; and which is very rarely to be met with even in any of the Antients since Virgil and Horace.
Having mention'd Mr. Addison, I cannot avoid congratulating my Country on his Preferment to one of her greatest Civil Employments; nor forbear observing how happy we are in a KING, who has shown the [Page 84] World that he will distribute his Favours amongst those only, whom Merit and Virtue shall recommend to his Service.
With what uncommon Lustre must that Man appear to Posterity, who is not only the best Writer, and most candid Patron of the Age he lives in; but also the finest Gentleman, the sincerest Friend, the most affectionate Husband, the most accomplish'd Statesman, and the most exemplary Christian? Under every one of these Views Mr. Addison gains the Esteem and Admiration even of the bitterest Enemies to that Cause which he so warmly espouses, of the most furious Partisans, and the most prejudic'd of Mankind.
[Page 85] I must forbear to enlarge any farther on the Character of that truly great and good Man, lest I draw upon my self the Imputation of a Flatterer, by relating what all the World (except himself only) will allow to be the severest Truth.
I shall make no Excuse for offering the following Poem to the World in an English DRESS, and under all the Disadvantages of an imperfect Translation. I have often read it in the Original with the greatest Pleasure and Satisfaction; and I hope it will need no Apology to be willing to communicate so useful and sublime an Entertainment, [Page 86] in the best manner I can, to those of my Fellow-Subjects who are not qualify'd to read it in the Latin Original.
RESURRECTIO DELINEATA Ad Altare Coll. Magd. Oxon.
THE RESURRECTION: A POEM.
SPHAERISTERIUM.
THE BOWLING-GREEN.
PAX GULIELMI AUSPICIIS Europae reddita, 1697.
HONORATISSIMO VIRO CAROLO MONTAGUE ARMIGERO, SCACCHARII CANCELLARIO, AERARII PRAEFECTO, REGI à SECRETIORIBUS CONSILIIS, &c.
CUM tanta auribus tuis obstrepat vatum nequissimorum turba, nihil est cur queraris aliquid inusitatum tibi contigisse, ubi praeclarum hoc argumentum meis etiam numeris violatum conspexeris. Quantum virtute bellicâ praestent Britanni, recens ex rebus gestis testatur gloria; quàm verò in humanioribus Pacis studiis non emineamus, indicio sunt quos nuper in lucem emisimus versiculi. Quòd si CONGREVIUS ille tuus divino, quo solet, furore correptus materiam hanc non exornâsset, vix [Page 124] tanti esset ipsa Pax, ut illâ laetaremur tot perditissunis Poëtis tam miserè decantatâ. At, dum alios insector, mei ipsius oblitus fuisse videor, qui haud minores forsan ex Latinis tibi molestias allaturus sum, quàm quas illi ex vernaculis suis carminibus attulerunt; nisi quòd inter ipsos cruciatus lenimentum aliquod dolori tribuat tormenti varietas. Nec quidem unquam adduci possem, ut poëma patrio sermone conscriptum oculis tuis subjicerem, qui ab istis conatibus caeteros omnes scribendo non minùs deterres, quàm favendo excitaveris.
THE PEACE OF RESWICK.
To the Honourable Charles Montague, Esq Chancellor of the Exchequer, First Lord-Commissioner of the TREASURY, and Privy-Councellor to the KING.
SINCE your Ears are continually pester'd by a wretched Set of Poets, you have no Reason to complain of any new Misfortunes [Page 136] happening to you, when you shall find the following noble Subject debas'd by my Numbers. The Honour they have lately acquir'd by their Conquests, plainly shews how much the English excell all others in the Art of War; but how unequally low we are in the politer Studies of Peace, is evident from the Verses we have lately publish'd. * If your Darling CONGREVE had not exerted his Divine Poetical Fury, with his usual Happiness, in the adorning of this Subject, [Page 137] the PEACE it self had been hardly worth our Joy, since it has been so miserably celebrated by so many vile Poetasters. But while I am blaming others, I may seem forgetful of my self, who perhaps may give you as much trouble in my Latin Compositions, as they have before done in their English, unless the Variety of the Torment may bring some Mitigation to the Pain you are to suffer. For my part, I never could prevail upon my self to offer you a POEM written in our Native Tongue, since you your self deter all others by [Page 138] your own Compositions from such an Attempt, as much as you excite them by your Favour and Humanity. I am,
THE PEACE OF RESWICK.
THE TABLE.
-
- AD Insignissimum Virum D. THO. BURNETTUM, Sacrae Theoriae Telluris Autorem. Page 7
- To the Learned Doctor Thomas Burnett, Author of The Theory of the Earth. Page 9
-
- Ad D.D. HANNES, Insignissimum Medicum & Poetam. Page 17
- To Dr. Hannes, an eminent Physician and Poet. Page 19
-
- ΠΥΓΜΑΙΟ-ΓΕΡΑΝΟ-ΜΑΧΙΑ, sive Praelium inter Pygmaeos & Grues commissum. Page 25
- The Battel of the Pygmies and Cranes. Page 31
-
- BAROMETRI Descriptio. Page 51
- The Barometer: Or, Weather-Glass. Page 55
-
[Page]
- Machinae Gesticulantes. Page 63
- The Puppet-Show. Page 67
-
- RESURRECTIO delineata ad Altare Coll. Magd. Oxon. Page 87
- The Resurrection. Page 95
-
- SPHAERISTERIUM. Page 109
- The Bowling-Green. Page 113
-
- Pax GULIELMI Auspiciis Europae reddita, 1697. Page 125
- The Peace of Reswick. Page 139
AUTHORS Names.
- I. Virgil.
- II. Lucretius.
- III. Ovid.
- IV. Statius.
- V. Lucan.
- VI. Claudian.
- VII. Horace.
- VIII. Juvenal.
- IX. Plautus.
- X. Terence.
- XI. Seneca.
- XII. Martial.
- XIII. Catullus.
- XIV. Tibullus.
- XV. Propertius.
A DISSERTATION Upon the most celebrated Roman POETS.
Written originally in LATIN BY Joseph Addison, Esq
Made ENGLISH by CHRISTOPHER HAYES, Esq
LONDON, Printed for E. CURLL in Fleet-street. MDCCXVIII.
DISSERTATIO DE INSIGNIORIBUS ROMANORUM POETIS.
OMNIUM in re Poetica maxime inclaruerunt Romani, & Romanorum VIRGILIUS: Optimae quaeque Regulae huic Arti [Page 2] inservientes non tam Criticorum Praeceptis quam MARONIS exemplo sunt depromendae: Ut ideo de reliquis Heroici Carminis Scriptoribus, recte statuamus Virtutes & Vitia quae apud singulos occurrunt, lectioni conferamus Virgilianae; qui, si ullibi defecerit Bucolicis, nonnunquam puriorem immiscuit Styli elegantiam quam quae Pastoribus conveniat, & saepe grandior sonat Carminum Majestas quam quae tenui avenae consona videatur: Apud quemlibet Georgicorum librum inimitabili quadam Sermonis Elegantia Res rusticae explicantur, sed ultimus de Apum Natura valde praeter caeteros animum delectat; ubi dum [Page 3] in tenui Argumento procedit Poema, solennem quandam Sententiarum & Verborum Pompam studiose affectet Poeta; Apum ideo Opera Cyclopum assimulat Laboribus, nec majori Carminum tumultu AENEAE & TURNI recitat Certamina, quam hasce Insectorum Turmas inter sese depraeliantes. Ubique exiguàe Reipublicae Duces, Populi, Studia, Mores, & tenue illud Imperium quod intra Alvearii Angustias exercetur, venusta nescio qua Carminis Magnificentia exprimuntur: Quin hoc certe in toto Opere praecipue occurrit admirandum, quomodo dum Plantationis, Pastionis, & Agriculturae curas [Page 4] exequitur Poeta, omissis usitatioribus loquendi formulis, materiae tam incultae locutionem Poeticam accommodaret, quomodo ignobiliori depressus Argumento nunquam ad Stylum Plebeium Orationem demiserat; sed tanta undique apparet Locutionum vis, ut multi (quamvis temere) Georgicos etiam Aeneidi praetulisse non dubitarint; sed in hoc Opere, per Argumentum, non licuit alias Poeseωs Partes praestitisse quam Styli & Descriptionum Elegantiam. Quod ad utrumque attinet, illud sibi proprium semper vendicat MARONIS Pagina, ut quicquid exprimat mira quadam Dulcedine animum ingrediatur, & [Page 5] quod describat melius quam si Oculis subjiciatur, tanquam praesens intueamur.
In Styli puritate proxime accedit LUCRETIUS, cujus Dictio, si obsoletae aliquando Verborum Antiquitati, & Numeris pene solutis agnoscas, illorum Palato qui Romane sapiunt, persuavis videatur. In Descriptionibus tamen CLAUDIANO secundus debetur Honos, qui amoenas Rerum Imagines ubique venustissima contexuit Oratione, in hoc solummodo vitiosus, quod fusius quam par est semper expatietur, eosdem Versus diversis exponat Loquendi Modis; in hac Arte sese [Page 6] maxime profecisse satis noverat CLAUDIANUS, de quacunque enim re satagit, assidue semper quaerit quae describenda sunt, imo plurima sumpsit Argumenta quae tota in Descriptionibus occupantur, ut videre est in Praefationibus, in Idylliis, in Libris de Raptu PROSERPINAE, de PHAENICE, HISTRICE, TORPEDINE, & plerisque Epigrammatum.
OVIDIUS (ut erat Aulici Ingenii Homo) terso quidem & polito Carmine res exhibuit amatorias, in caeteris tamen Operibus istiusmodi occurrit Sermo quali in Triviis uti solent: Ille enim Ingenio suo confisus [Page 7] de operosiori Dictione elaboranda parum erat satis solicitus: In Libro tamen Metamorphoseωs varias optime depinxit Animalium Mutationes, dum prior paulatim exuitur Forma & nova superinducitur.
Utrumque hoc quod jam tractamus Poetis Officium non raro optime praestitit PAPINIUS, LUCANUS neutrum, cujus Dictio quanquam multum sonat inflata, nulla tamen Phraseorum aut Epithetorum Venustate animatur, sed Orationi magis solutae convenit quam Poeticae, imo certe tali plerunque utitur Verborum delectu, [Page 8] qualem vel Liber dedignetur Sermo. Et quanquam in Descriptionibus saepissime versatur, & in hujusmodi diverticula nunquam non excurrit, raro tamen, ut debet, Opus absolvit: Jam vero quod ad STATIUM attinet; plurima certe composuit summis Poetarum invidenda, sed inter magnas Virtutes maxima occurrunt Vitia; in Dictione enim Verba nimis admittit sesquipedalia, nullaque de Argumento habita ratione vana numeris miscet Tonitrua: Nec minus in Descriptionibus peccat; nimio enim calori indulgens, dum totis viribus excellere conatur, ultra Finem tendit opus, et in tumorem excrescit; in utrumque [Page 9] hujusmodi vitium aliquando incidit CLAUDIANUS. Jam vero quoniam de VIRGILII Aeneidis Argumento varii multa scripserunt & praeclara, pauca solummodo de STATII & LUCANI Carminibus sunt advertenda; utpote quae Latinorum omnium sola Epica haberi debent. De LUCANO id saepe in Disputationem venit, an Historia qua constat Pharsalicum Poema, idoneum sit Heroici Carminis Argumentum. Vera ideo Heroicae Poeseωs Natura inquirenda est, quam apud Librum de Dignitate & Augmentis Scientiarum his Verbis optime exhibuit VERULAMIUS nostras. Ex quo satis patet veram [Page 10] Historiam cum Epico Poemate male convenire; & proinde LUCANUM quoad Argumentum maxime defecisse. Quinque in illius Poemate maxime emicant Heroes, CAESAR, POMPEIUS, BRUTUS, CATO, & CICERO: Omnes sane tam Vita insignes quam Morte luctuosi; quorum Virtutes (quantum licuit per humanam Naturam) Perfectioni istae Heroicae, quam reliqui Poetae Ducibus suis falso tribuerunt, proxime accesserant. LUCANUS CAESARI undique oblatrat, POMPEII Partes ambitiose fovet, sed BRUTI & CATONIS Encomia, ob Stoicum (credo) illud Ingenium, quod cum his habuit commune, [Page 11] maxime celebrat: Et plurima certe quae LUCANO objicias Philosophiae hujuscemodi sunt referenda: Inde immodicus iste Ingenii tumor, & ambitiosa Sententiarum ostentatio, quam cum illa Hominum turba semper habet in Deliciis; inde quae magna sunt, quam quae bona sunt, maluit praeferre. Hinc etiam in eximia illa Poeseωs Virtute Passionibus excitandis ipse (qui omnes Philosophiae Affectus tanquam illicitos existimavit) male successerat, cujus Vitii unicum tantum (ut taceam caetera) Argumentum proferam: Postquam in Pugna Pharsalica CAESAR de Pompeio Victoriam reportaverit, LUCANUS maxime [Page 12] debuit, si aliquid ab ipsa Historia alienum protulisset, lugubri quodam Carmine immeritam doluisse POMPEII sortem; quippe in toto Opere summo habuit honore; vel saltem ipsum POMPEIUM (ut ingens patuit Doloris Argumentum) aut de amissa Romae Libertate, aut de Amicorum Mortibus, aut de propriis querentem Infortuniis, introduxisse oportuit. Poeta tamen ab omni hujusmodi Dolore tam longe abest, ut POMPEIUM, obnixe hortaretur, postquam victus a Bello decesserat, ut CAESARIS Victoris sui commiserescat, quia nempe CAESAR non sine Scelere Victoria potitus est;
Quis tulerit Poetam tam ridicule philosophantem? quasi vero POMPEIUS Senex, Exul, Miser, Triumumphatus, ob Victorem suum quamvis scelestum Commiserationem quandam conciperet: Illum quidem maxime Stoice sapuisse oporterat, [Page 14] qui omnibus hisce Fortunae Donis spoliatus, tantam in nuda Virtute poneret Felicitatem. Sed nullus Poetarum nisi VIRGILIUS hujusmodi afficiat Dolore: Alii plerunque dum moerorem aliquem Lectoribus inducerent, in illo peccant, quod nimia Prolixitate sese in questus effundant, nec unquam satis Lachrymarum exhaustum esse sentiant, vel Ingenium, quod maxime possint, Versibus infundendo, faciunt ut magis Carmina miremur, quam materiam lugeamus. De utroque cavit VIRGILIUS, qui mera semper Simplicitate luctuosa ut in se sunt exhibuit; & leviter quicquid dolet perstrinxerat: ‘"Lamentationes [Page 15] enim, inquit CICERO, debent esse breves & concisae, quia Lachryma subito exarescit, & difficile est Auditorem aut Lectorem in summo illo animi affectu tenere."’ Ut vero ad STATIUM redeamus, illi quidem Spiritus non raro feliciter assurgit, cui dum temperare nequit, nescio quas projicit Ampullas, & vana Carminibus addit Numerorum Terriculamenta. THEBAIDIS quidem Argumentum Ingenii sui Truculentiae, sed non Heroico Poemati satis aptum videatur: ETEOCLES enim, POLYNICES, & TYDEUS, quorum gesta hoc Carmine celebrantur, nihil habent eorum, si [Page 16] unicam Fortitudinem demas, quae conveniunt Heroibus: Imo in toto Poemate nulla nisi Scelerum, qualia sunt Parricidii, Perfidiae, Immanitatis, Odiorum proferuntur Exemplaria; dum in omnibus fere quos suo Carmine induxit VIRGILIUS praeclara quaedam illucescunt, & in ipso AENEA summam Pietatem erga Does, Natum, Conjugem, Amicos, & Parentem, Oculis semper habemus subjectam. Epitheta plerunque STATIANA multum sonant metaphorice, dum inanimatis illa tribuuntur quae Animalibus conveniunt. In Verbis tamen nec raro sine maxima Elegantia Metaphoras consectatur CLAUDIANUS; VIRGILIUS [Page 17] in utrisque parcissimus; STATIUS plurimas rerum similitudines composuit, multum saepe de VIRGILII Ingenio referentes, in qua arte melius successerat LUCANUS, si aliquid unquam mediocre admiserat; sed dum VIRGILIUS ad Apes, ad Formicas, & istiusmodi Natura ludicra descendit, nihil unquam nisi Quercum fulminatam, Terrae Exitium, aut Mundi Conflagrationem ebuccinat LUCANUS. Et hisce tandem, quorum alii non operae Pretium duxerunt meminisse, de Heroicis Scriptoribus breviter perstrictis; de Satyricis restat dicendum; quorum omnium JUVENALIS & HORATIUS Palmam [Page 18] dubiam quidem fecerunt: Inter Literatos enim multum discrepat, utrum mordax illa Ingenii acerbitas, qua suam armavit paginam JUVENALIS, an potius HORATII festivae Irrisiones, magis Satyrae conveniant: Ut vero de utroque rectius statuatur, pauca prius sunt advertenda. Ob infamem vitae suae lasciviam, etiam nunc temporis, male audit HORATIUS; Virtutem tamen semper rigide coluit JUVENALIS: Ille in absolutissima AUGUSTI Aula versatus est, hic in pessima DOMITIANI Tempora incidisset: Proinde ut ad sua & Saeculi utriusque Ingenia Opera [Page 19] accommodarent Poetae, HORATIUS totus in ludicro exercetur Argumento, nec Morum Licentiam, sed indecoras quasdam Aulicorum Ineptias plerunque insectatur; non ideo abfuisset quin irridetur, si aliqua Styli severitate ad leviuscula hujusmodi castiganda se accinxisset: Gravissima tamen in Temporibus suis reprehendit JUVENALIS, & de Vitiis ubique queritur quae vel pudeat recitare, & isti sane Materiae, summa Mentis Indignatio, Orationis Ardor, & Ingenii Acrimonia, rectissime aptari videantur. Quamvis ubi ad Jocularia Animum demittit, non raro Satyris [Page 20] Festivitatem fundit HORATIANAM. Uterque ideo (modo diversum consulas Argumentum) suo quidem Genere perfectissimus emicuit; in quo Ridiculum Acri melius, in hoc Acre Ridiculo. Reliqua certe HORATII Opera, Admiratione potius sunt digna quam Encomiis, nec majora solum Vituperatione, sed etiam Laude. Jam vero quod ad Dramaticos attinet, PLAUTI & TERENTII Argumenta, Sales, Elegantiae ubique adeo vulgantur, ut nihil de novo possit adjici: De SENECA vero tam diverse sentiunt, ut alii inter summos Tragicorum, alii infra Infimum annumerent: [Page 21] Illi quidem Ingenium valde magnum, Oratio elegans & concisa, abundat Sententiis plerunque acutis, Stoicam semper Philosophiam, quam amplexus est, redolentibus. Unde omnibus fere, qui Artem Dramaticam parum sapiunt, semper est in Deliciis; si tamen ad hanc respicias, Tragoediae ubique plurimum laborant, & istud vitii (ut reliqua praetermittam) SENECAE peculiare videatur, ut quoscunque inducat Interlocutores, nulla, ad Personas quas sustinet, habita ratione, eundem semper unicuique tribuat loquendi modum: Omnes severiora spirant Philosophiae Dogmata, & quae Stoae [Page 22] magis conveniant quam Theatro. Eadem semper Styli Magnificentia superbiunt Rex, & Nuncius: Imo ipsam Nutricem (plurima enim tam acute profert) Stoicorum Praeceptis non mediocriter imbutam sentias. Inter Epigrammatistas potissimum emicuerunt MARTIALIS & CLAUDIANUS; Ille semper in extremo Poemate Ingenii subjecit acumen, & saepe similia insequitur Verborum Tintinnabula; Hic per totum Epigramma suum dispergit Salem, & venustissima ubique utitur Latinitatis Elegantia. Caeterum tamen Poetarum Vulgus, de istiusmodi mediocribus sunt, quos nec Dii nec [Page 23] Homines concesserunt; & quamvis una aut altera apud affectatas CATULLI Oratiunculas, TIBULLI aut PROPERTII inhonestam paginam, & Carmina incuriosa, illucescat Virtus, non tamen est Operae Pretium Gemmas inter Stercora eruere.
A DISSERTATION Upon the most celebrated Roman POETS.
Made English from the Latin Original BY CHRISTOPHER HAYES, Esq
LONDON, Printed in the Year 1718.
A DISSERTATION Upon the most celebrated Roman POETS.
OF all the Nations in the World, the Romans have most excell'd in the Art of Poetry, and even among the Romans VIRGIL has been the most deservedly celebrated; [Page 28] from whom the justest Rules of this Art are rather to be taken, than from the dry Precepts of the Criticks. To the End therefore that we may the more truly ascertain the Beauties and Faults which occur among the rest of the Writers of Heroic Poetry, let us compare them with the Style of VIRGIL; who, if he be in any Thing deficient, it is when he has sometimes in his Eclogues mingled such a Purity of Style, as is not entirely agreeable with the Dialect of Shepherds; and frequently the Dignity of his Verse seems no Way consonant to the Rural Pipe. In every Book of his Georgicks, he [Page 29] treats of Country Affairs with an inimitable Elegancy of Style; but, above all, we are most delighted with his last Book, Of the Nature of BEES; where, in a Poem on so inconsiderable a Subject, our Author purposely affects a peculiarly solemn and pompous Style. In this Piece he compares the Labours of the BEES to those of the Cyclops; and in the same lofty Numbers recounts the Skirmishes of these little Insects among themselves, as he does the Rencounters of AENEAS and TURNUS. All along, the Generals of this small Republick, the Populace, the Factions, the Customs and Forms of Government [Page 30] exercis'd within the narrow Limits of the Bee-hive, are describ'd with an inexpressible Beauty and Magnificence. Throughout the whole Work, what mostly raises our Admiration, is, that in the Persuit of his Discourse on Planting, Grazing, and Agriculture, (waving the common Forms of Speech) he suits his Poetick Diction to so unpolite a Theme; how, seemingly depress'd with the Meanness of his Subject, he never sinks into a Plebeian Style; but the Force and Energy of his Expression are so conspicuous, that many, too rashly indeed, have not scrupled to prefer the Georgicks to the Aeneid: [Page 31] But in a Work of this Nature, no other Parts of Poetry could be display'd, except an Elegance of Style and Description: In both these Ways VIRGIL has this peculiar to himself, that he captivates the Soul with his wonderful Sweetness, and his Descriptions are as lively, as if we had the Object plac'd before our Eyes.
In the Purity of his Style next follows LUCRETIUS, whose Diction, allowing for his Obsoleteness, and Numbers almost Prosaick, may challenge a Share of Praise in those who have any Taste of the Roman Eloquence: For Descriptions [Page 32] however, the second Post of Honour is due to CLAUDIAN, who has throughout, in a most beautiful Style, interwoven his agreeable Images; faulty in this alone, that he expatiates upon his Subjects beyond all Decency, and frequently gives us the same Thoughts, diversify'd only in Expression. In this Art CLAUDIAN well knew the Progress he had made, for on whatsoever Topick he is engag'd, he diligently searches out Matter for Description, nay most of the Subjects he has wrote upon are wholly such, as may be seen in his Prefaces, his Eclogues, his Books of the Rape of PROSERPINE, [Page 33] his Phoenix, his Porcupine, his Cramp-Fish, and most of his EPIGRAMS.
OVID (like a true Courtier as he was) describes the Affairs of Love in neat and polite Verse. In the rest of his Works we meet with the more vulgar Way of Expression; for trusting to a good Genius, he was little solicitous about forming a more elaborate Style; but yet in his Metamorphoses, he has painted in the greatest Perfection the various Changes of all Creatures, and his Transformations succeed one another with a most surprizing Celerity.
[Page 34] STATIUS has frequently discharg'd both these Requisites of a Poet we just now observ'd; LUCAN neither, whose Diction, altho' very bombast, is not enliven'd either by beautiful Phrases or Epithets, but comes nearer Prose than Poetry; nay, there is in him commonly such a mean Choice of Words, as is sometimes even beneath Prose it self: And altho' he abounds in Descriptions, and is always making Excursions of that Kind, yet he seldom finishes his Work as he ought, or brings his Thoughts to any Justness of Conclusion.
[Page 35] But now as to STATIUS, he has given us Compositions worthy of the Envy of the best Poets: But with all his Beauties he has greater Faults; for in his Expression he makes too much Use of Gigantick Words, and, not considering his Subject, mingles useless Thunder in his Numbers: Nor is he less faulty in his Descriptions, for, encouraging too great a Heat, while he attempts to excel, he shoots beyond his Mark, and swells unnaturally. Of both which Extreams CLAUDIAN is too often guilty.
[Page 36] And now, since there have been many Pieces written, and those of Note, on the Subject of VIRGIL'S Aeneis, (and less Notice is taken of the Poetry of STATIUS and LUCAN) to whose Productions only the Latines allow the Title of Epick Poetry. As to LUCAN, it has been often disputed whether his Pharsalia be a proper Subject for an Heroick Poem. For the Decision of this Point, we must enquire into the true Nature of Heroick Poetry, which our Countryman the Lord BACON has admirably describ'd in his Treatise of The Advancement of Learning. From [Page 37] whence it is sufficiently manifest, that History and Epic Poetry are by no means proper Companions; and therefore that LUCAN has very much fail'd in his principal Subject: The five Heroes who make the greatest Figure in his Poem, are CAESAR, POMPEY, BRUTUS, CATO, and CICERO; each of them indeed as distinguishable in their Lives, as they were lamented at their Deaths; Men whose Virtues, allowing for the Frailties of human Nature, came nearest to that Pitch of Heroick Perfection which other Poets have falsely attributed to their Heroes. LUCAN every where rails at CAESAR, and [Page 38] passionately espouses POMPEY'S Interest, but most of all celebrates the Characters of BRUTUS and CATO for that Spirit of Stoicism, which he had equally imbib'd with them: And indeed most of the Faults objected to LUCAN, are rather to be imputed to this Kind of Philosophy. From whence sprung that boundless Vein of Wit, and that peculiar Affectation of a lofty Style, which, like that Sect of Men, he always delighted in, and therefore gives the Preference rather to great, than good Actions: And upon this Account, in raising the Passions, (that most excellent Part of Poetry) he succeeded but [Page 39] ill, because upon the Principles of his Philosophy, the Passions themselves were accounted as absolutely unlawful. To confirm this, (passing by many others) I will produce but one Instance: After CAESAR had obtain'd the Victory over POMPEY in the Battle of Pharsalia, LUCAN certainly (if he had enlarg'd on any Circumstance foreign to his Story) should, upon so remarkable an Occasion, have brought in POMPEY lamenting his unhappy Fate in the most mournful Strain; especially since he pays so high a Deference to him throughout his whole Work; or at least (as there was an open Field for Grief) he [Page 40] should have introduc'd POMPEY, either complaining of Rome's lost Liberty, the Death of his Friends, or his own Misfortunes. But LUCAN is so far from raising the Passions to this just Heighth, that he warmly advises POMPEY (when vanquish'd he retires from the Field of Action) to commiserate the Condition of his Conqueror CAESAR, because he had not won the Day but by unjustifiable Methods.
Who can bear to hear the Poet philosophizing in this ridiculous [Page 42] Manner? As if POMPEY, a Man in Years, an Exile, Miserable, and Vanquish'd, should have any Concern upon him for the Crimes of his Conqueror: He ought to have been very much stoiciz'd indeed, who, despoil'd of all the Goods of Fortune, could place the Sum of his Felicity in meer naked Virtue. But none of the Poets have touch'd this Passion of Grief like VIRGIL. The Generality of other Writers, when they attempt to move their Readers, offend in this Point, that they are too prolix in spinning out their Complaints, and think their Flood of Tears inexhaustible; or else, while they labour to express [Page 43] the Greatness of their Genius, in the Profuseness of their Verse, rather raise our Admiration at the Flowing of their Numbers, than excite our Pity in the Catastrophe of their Story. VIRGIL has carefully avoided both these Extreams, and dresses his Images of Sorrow in their native Simplicity; and whoever he makes to grieve, he always does it with a quick and tender Compassion: For according to CICERO, our Expressions of Grief ought to be short and concise, because our Tears quickly dry up, and it is unnatural to detain either an Auditor or a Reader in too long a Suspension of Grief.
[Page 44] But to return to STATIUS, his Spirit is indeed lofty and aspiring, to which while he gives too great a Loose, he runs into Bombast, and to his Poetry often adds useless sounding Words. The Subject of his Thebais seems indeed suited to the Barbarity of his Genius, but is beneath the Dignity of an Heroic Poem. For neither ETEOCLES, POLYNICES, nor TYDEUS, whose Actions are recorded in this Poem, have any Thing in them, except their Valour, agreeable to Heroes: Nay, throughout the whole Piece there are no Examples produc'd, unless of Persons infamous for the [Page 45] most flagitious Enormities, such as Parricide, Treachery, Cruelty, and Revenge; while, on the contrary, every Thing Praise-worthy shines bright in VIRGIL'S Heroes, and in the Person of AENEAS we have plac'd before our Eyes an Instance of consummate Piety towards the GODS, his Son, his Wife, his Friends, and his Father. The Epithets of STATIUS are generally forc'd and very metaphorical, while such Properties are ascrib'd to Inanimates, as really only belong to Animals. In the Choice of his Words, and frequently in his Metaphors, he is follow'd by CLAUDIAN with the utmost Elegance; [Page 46] VIRGIL is sparing in both these Particulars; STATIUS abounds much with Similitudes, in which he seems to imitate VIRGIL; but in this Instance LUCAN had had better Success, if he had hit upon the proper Medium: But while VIRGIL stoops down to the humble Subjects of Bees, Ants, and other such like delightful Themes of Nature; on the other Hand, LUCAN bellows out nothing but Stories of Oaks split by Lightning, Earthquakes, and the World's Conflagration. Let this, in short, suffice observable concerning the Writers of Heroic Poetry, in itself new, and never before taken Notice of.
[Page 47] Something now remains to be said of the Satyrists, among whom whether JUVENAL or HORACE have most Right to the Bays, it is difficult to determine; for it has been long a Dispute among the Learned, whether that Keenness and Bitterness of Expression with which JUVENAL has arm'd his Satires, or HORACE'S more jocose Lampoons are most agreeable to the End of SATIRE. Now that we may give a clearer Decision on this Head, a few Things must be premis'd. HORACE bears to this Day, an ill Character for the Looseness of his Conduct in Life. JUVENAL [Page 48] was a rigid Practiser of Virtue. The one was conversant in the most perfectly polite Court of AUGUSTUS; the other liv'd in the Dregs of DOMITIAN'S Time; and therefore both these Poets accommodated their Writings to the Manners of the different Ages they liv'd in: For HORACE is entirely upon the ludicrous, and persues not so much the Licentiousness of the Times, as the ridiculous Fopperies of some particular Courtiers; for had he attempted to correct these Trifles with Severity, he had not miss'd of being laugh'd at: But JUVENAL lashes the grossest Crimes prevalent in his Time, and complains [Page 49] of Enormities which he was asham'd to mention, and nothing less than the highest Resentment of Soul, Ardency of Expression, and Sharpness of Speech, could be an equal Match to Crimes so notorious; tho' whenever he descends to be jocose, we frequently meet with the Pleasantry of HORACE. Both of them, allowing for the different Manner of their Writing, are perfect Masters in their several Ways; in the one shines the Ridicule, in the other the Severe. The rest of HORACE'S Pieces are so admirable, that they exceed our highest Encomiums, and are not only beyond our Dislike, but above our Praise.
[Page 50] As to what concerns the Dramatick Poets, PLAUTUS and TERENCE bear away the Bell, whose Plots, Turns, and Elegancy of Style, are so well known, that nothing new can be said upon them.
As to SENECA, Mankind have had different Opinions of him; some have rank'd him with the best Tragoedians, others have sunk him below the worst. He certainly had a great Genius, an elegant and concise Way of Expression; he abounds with smart Turns, which always savour much of that Stoicism of which he was a Follower, upon [Page 51] which Account he has always been esteem'd by those who have had little or no Taste of Dramatick Poetry; but then if we consider him as such, his Tragedies are throughout too elaborate; and this, to pass by his other Faults, seems peculiarly SENECA'S, that he makes all his Actors (without any Regard to the Characters they bear) talk in the same Strain; all of them inculcate rigid philosophical Dogmata, and such Morality as is rather fit for the Schools of the Stoicks, than the Roman Theatre: For with him the King and the Slave strut in the same Buskin; nay, you may perceive the Nurse herself deeply [Page 52] ting'd with the Principles of Stoicism.
Among the Epigrammatists, MARTIAL and CLAUDIAN have bore the greatest Reputation; the first, for the severe Point in the Close of his Epigrams, and the peculiar Jingle of his Words. The other, for dispersing the Poignancy of his Wit throughout his Epigrams, and that in the most beautiful Latin Phrase.
The rest of the Herd of the Latin Poets creep so low in their Numbers, that they are beneath the Notice either of GODS or Men: And tho' we may now and then [Page 53] discover in the affected Harangues of CATULLUS, and the obscene Poetry of TIBULLUS and PROPERTIUS, some not disagreeable Pieces, yet it is not worth our while to rake the Dunghills for the Sake of the JEWELLS.
ERRATA.
Pag. 5 Lin. 16 read eosdemque. p. 13 l. 12 r. oportuerat.
POSTSCRIPT.
The Passage of the Lord * BACON, which seems to be referr'd to by Mr. ADDISON, in the 9th Page of the foregoing DISSERTATION.
Thus translated, in the English Edition, by Dr. RAWLEY.