A TREATISE of Self-judging, In order to the Worthy receiving the LORDS SUPPER.
1 COR. 11.31.
For if we would judge our selves, we should not be judged.
FRom the 17
th verse to the end of the Chapter,
Some general observations from S
t
Pauls Discourse about the Lords Supper. we may see
Paul like a shining and burning light, with that
Urim and
Thummim upon him, as some expound it; light by his doctrinall information;
[Page 2] burning, by his severe and sharp reprehension.
[...], in a very terrible manner, as
Chrysostome; and all this, wholly about the Sacrament of the Lords Supper. Now although it would be too much, to analize and take notice of all the particulars, in this his Discourse about the Lords Supper, yet I shall touch upon some general observations, and so bring you to the text. First therefore take notice of the suddain and speedy degeneracy of this Church of
Corinth, from Christs first institution about the Sacrament: who would thinke that this
[Page 3] Church being a garden of
Pauls own planting, and he yet alive, that it should be thus over-grown with weeds? As
Paul of Doctrinalls, to the Church of
Galatia, so here of practicalls, I wonder you are so soon removed from him that called you,
Gal. 1.6. You see a false Apostle, an heretical teacher could do more on a suddain to pervert souls, then the Apostle in many years to establish them. That which other painfull Ministers have with much difficulty bin a building many years, they can suddenly destroy. We may say of many Churches since Christs
[Page 4] time, how is it that they have fallen off from that primitive purity and godly order, which was observed by the Apostles.
2. Observe the devil and his instruments busied in the corrupting of this ordinance of the Lords Supper, above any else.
Peter Martyr observeth well, that there was not such corruption about Baptism, as about this ordinance. Its true in after ages the corruptions both doctrinal and practical, were very great about both the Sacraments, but he began first with the Lords Supper, as being that which is the highest Church-grace and favour.
[Page 5]3. The corruption about this ordinance was occasioned by an humane institution, their
[...], Their love-feasts, which
Jude mentioneth, saying, some were spots in their feasts of charity,
Jude 12. whither they were at first instituted in imitation of the Jewes, or as some, of the Gentiles, who used to have their feasts after their s
[...] crifices, is doubted. The intent was to nourish and keep up love amongst one another. Its judged by most, and
Paul seemeth to make it probable, that they were before the Lords Supper, though
Chrysostome, and others, make
[Page 6] them after:
Maldonate and other Jesuits, will by no means understand the Eucharist by the Lords Supper, but are peremptory, that neither Scripture, or the Fathers ever gave it such a name. But
Causabon doth well chastise this impudency of theirs. For why should the Apostle bring in the solemn institution of the Lords Supper at first, if their divisions and prophanes did not relate to that, though occasioned by their love-feasts, whether the Apostle doth absolutely condemne the very use of the love-feasts, as being an humane institution added to the Sacrament,
[Page 7] or the abuse onely is likewise doubted. It is enough for us, to see how unhappy these prooved in the issue, for they fell into divisions & factions, hereby making as it were so many parties: and withall, the poore were despised, and the rich they grew intemperate; and in these distempers they dared to proceed to this ordinance; for this it is, the Apostle though he had praised them in the beginning of the Chapter for keeping his order, yet here he could not do it, some holy order they kept, but not all.
4
Obs: That that Sacrament
[Page 8] which was appointed by Christ, not only as a seale of communion with him, but of believers amongst themselves, was now abused, through the many schismes and divisions that were amongst them, and made an occasion of discord and strife; and is not this sadly to be laid to our hearts, that there are more breaches and rents about this ordinance, which yet is for communion, then any po nt in religion; how many doctrinall controversies, how many disciplinary controversies, all tending to break love and union, by the symboles
[Page 9] and seales of union, what dispute about the order, about the communicants, about the benefits, the Sacraments being by some made Idols, as in Popery, which caused a learned man to wish the word
Sacrament had bin laid aside, people cōceiving some hidden vertue in the bread and wine by that name; and by othe
[...]s despised, as by those who s
[...]y they are above ordinances, when yet we are to doe this in remembrance of Christ, till his coming, if we were sure Christ were to come the next day, yet we might receive this ordinance immediatly before.
[Page 10] The Socinians & Remonstran
[...]s doe debase them; The latter say, the whole doctrine of the reformed Church about the Sacraments, is
nobis valde suspecta, is greatly suspect
[...]d of falshood by us; and the former say, its only a commemoration of Christs death, so that there is no grace or benefit anew received; ev
[...] say they, as in the com
[...]oration of the Angels Passover in the Pa
[...]chall Lamb, there was no new deliverance vouchsafed: but the very institution of such Elements, bread and wine, argue they a
[...]e spirituall Alimony to the true receiver, onely
[Page 11] these sad divisions hinder the blessed fruit thereof.
Obs: 5. That the Apostle in reformation of this abuse, goe h to the o
[...]igin
[...]ll institution, he declareth what he had received of Christ,
viz. immediately, for
Paul was not a
[...] the institution of it, and indeed to reforme, is properly to bring a thing to its first forme or originall; we account what the Church did about the Sacraments when it came out of Popery, was reformation, though the Papists call it deformation; That which is reformat
[...]on to one, is confusion to another. Therefore the onely way
[Page 12] to decide this is not custome, multitude, or as
Stapleton, Ecclesiasticall tradition, for that is as corrupt as any thing else, but divine institution, as
Cyprian, Vide, surgat altum nostrum recte, unde ordo & origo surrexit, let our actions arise from the same fountaine that institutions themselves d d,
Elisha powred salt in the spring, when the streames were bitter; and about the Sacrament it is to be obse
[...] ved, that whereas many persons are so importunate for antiquity and old customes in other things, when we can from Scripture and the Ancients for
[Page 13] two or three hundred yeares after Christ, shew plainly how carefull they were that no ignorant and prophane person should be admitted to this ordinance, then they w
[...]ll not hearken or yeild obedience: bring Antiquity for any superstition, or needlesse custome, they are glad of it, but when for purity and godly order, they cannot digest it.
Obs: 6. That God did very severely punish these
Corinthians for their disorder about the Lords Supper;
For this cause (saith
Paul, ver. 30.)
many are sick, weake, and dye. There was a common mortali ie,
[Page 14] (if not the plague) amongst them.
Paul indeed could by the guidance of Gods Spirit know that was the particular cause, and although we have not such certain knowledge, yet we may with
Peter Martyr reckon publick calamities upon a Land, as warre, famine, & plague, with other pestilential diseases to this sin, as part. Certainly, we do not consider, that this Sacrament-sin is so highly provoking of God, when we doe not attribute our miseries to this, at least, as one cause among the rest; and Gods judgments for this are the more to be observed, because in the
[Page 15] New Testament this is the onely instance we have of a publick generall judgment. Indeed
Ananias and
Saphira were stricken dead for lying against the holy Ghost, and
Elymas blind, but here many, some whereof were godly and holy, were sick, and others cut off with untimely deaths.
[...] seemeth to be an allusion concerning Gods order about the paschal Lamb, which whosoever did transgresse, was to be cut off.
7. The Apostle therefore to prevent all such abuses for the future, doth so forcibly informe about the unworthy receiving
[Page 16] of this ordinance, That it hath left some impression upon all Churches, to keep off those that are dogs and swine, not to give this bread and pearle to such, let them be Episcopall, (some of them at least) Presbyteriall, or Congregationall.
Hooker in his
Posthumus bookes of Ecclesiasticall Poli
[...], sixth Booke,
pag. 57. doth affirme, that by the Church of
England, Every noto
[...]ious offender was to be kept from that ordinance, and (which is remarkable) that all Ministers had equally power to do it.
The Socinians do highly presse the casting out of
[Page 17] all evill persons, and condemne the Evangelicall Churches for remissnesse therein: yea,
Erastus one of the first that troubled the Church about the admission of persons to the Sacrament, doth yet often professe that he onely understands such sinners to be admitted, as publickly repent of their sinnes, and promise amendment. He maketh it a great injury done to him, as if his opinion were that all who name themselves
Christians, yea though neither willing, nor thinking to depart from their evill wayes, were to be admitmitted, therefore professeth
[Page 18] he so disputeth of these points, as that he would have the custome of their Church observed,
Erast. Contr: Thes. lib. 6.
cap. 2. And he speaketh expressly against the promiscuous admission of all, without any examination. It is an injury and a calumny, he saith, to charge that opinion on him,
lib. 6.
pag. 34. Certainly, these thunderbolts of
Paul have made deep impressions upon mens hearts, though otherwise not willing to be affected with much strictnesse herein.
8. We may observe, it is a blessed and happy thing that
Paul did thus
[Page 19] by the Spirit of God inlarge himselfe about the institution of this ordinance; for although three Evangelists relate the institution of it, (
John onely omitting it) yet
Paul instead of a fourth Evangelist, doth with much inlargement make mention of it; for who could have gathered such conclusions as
Paul did from the meer institution, had not the Spirit of God immediatly guided him, so that these very sins of the
Corinthians, we may as the ancient
Adams sin, call them
felices culpae; for their corruptions gave occasion to
Paul for such a large and pithy
[Page 20] amplification about it.
And therefore as it was a mercy to the Church, that many heresies arose, even in the Apostles daies, which made them speake so distinctly and clearely against them, as about Justification by the works of the Law,
&c. Yea the doubtings of the Apostles in many particulars, is the cause why we doe not doubt now about the same things. Which made one say,
Plus debeo Thomae dubitanti, quam Petro credenti, I owe more to
Thomas doubting, then
Peter believing. As (I say) the event of such heresies or doubts was in mercy to
[Page 21] the Church, so disorders and corruption in the Discipline of the Church, did provoke the Apostle to speake so much about this ordinance as he doth. And it was
Casaubons good wish, that men had been more industrious to bring in the Primitive good order in Church-discipline, then subtilly to dispute without Scripture-light in many controversal points, this would have bin more acceptable to God,
Exer. 16.
pag. 396.
Lastly; Observe amongst the many arguments for our right approaching, this in my text is none of the meanest, wherein we may consider.
First, the duty supposed, with the object of it, if we would judge our selves, what the word
[...], doth imply, will appear in the doctrine
Grotius thinketh this place may not unfitly be expoūded of their publick Church-censures, as if the Apostles meaning were, if you had godly discipline, & this were faithfully put in order, this would prevent Gods judgments; for he thinketh by the severall factions that were, the discipline of the Church lay prostrate; but I will go in the most generall interpretation of it, and so the words may be considered, either in the
[Page 23]
Thesi, as a Theologicall Aphorisme, That self-judging, will prevent Gods judging of us in all cases; or else in
Hypothesi, in the particular, as it doth relate to the Sacrament. Hence
Erasmus renders it in the past sence, If we had judged our selves, we had not been judged of the Lord. I shall take in both these considerations.
Secondly, There is the benefit proposed, or discovered upon our self-judging, we should not be judged. The Apostle speaketh here of believers as well as wicked men, yea chiefly of believers, because he addeth, vers. 32.
[Page 24]
When we are judged, we are chasten
[...]d of the Lord, that we may not be condemned with the world. The world and the godly are directly opposite; here are then three doctrines in this text, as the naturall offspring of it.
First,
That self-judging, preventeth Gods judging.
Secondly,
God doth judge even his own people for their sins.
Thirdly,
The sins which God judgeth them for, are not only morall, grosse sins, but their ordinance-sins, their Sacrament-sins, committed against positive institutions. For the first;
He that judgeth himself,
[Page 25] taketh the way to prevent Gods judging of him. What our Saviour saies of judging of others,
Mat. 7.1.
Judge not lest ye be judged, is clean contrary here: Judge your selves, and that severely, impartially, else God will judge you: You see there must be judging, if you do not judge your selves here, God will judge hereafter; if here be not a judgement of discussion, in hell there will be a judgement of condemnation. This self-judging it is the marrow, and soul of all Christianity; for want of this it is that there are so many hypocrites and Apostates in
[Page 26] Religion; for want of this, that there are so many Pharisaicall, and self-righteous men; If this duty were more practised, there would be more truth and sincerity in the waies of godliness: so that in this very thing the prophane and the godly man part; the Pharisee and the true believer are divided; the hypo
[...]rite and the true Saint differ: they may both pray, they may both abound in gifts and inlargements, they may both be frequent in the Ordinances, but the one judgeth himself, and the other doth not, or cannot, or dare not, he is afraid to
[Page 27] search into himself; so that this is a duty required of us in our whole life, but especially upon some extraordinary occasions, as here in this
Sacramentall Administration. Had
Jehu judged himself, had
Judas judged himself, they had not been such scandals in Religion.
But let us rip up, as it were, and discover this great and weighty duty of self-judging; and herein we are to know, that many things are
antecedent to it, some things
constituent of it, some things
concomitant of it, and some things
consequent from it; and all these manifested, will
[Page 28] make us able to judge of this self-judging.
What things are antecedent to self-judging.To the Antecedent or introductory things we referre these particulars.
1. A man must erect a tribunal and barre, as it were, in his own heart, and assume to himself a superiority and dominion as it were, over himself, for thus all judgement is exercised; he that is a Judge in that act is a superiour: Now in man, we may consider him as inlightned in his conscience by the word, and herein supplying Gods place: So that conscience is not only a witness, but a Judge, and that is the reason why a
[Page 29] man may not do any thing against conscience, though otherwise, he is indeed bound to lay aside his errour, but he must not contradict it, because it is a Judge in Gods room; he may and must many times go against his affections, his will, his inclinations, but never against his conscience. The very Heathen could say,
[...],
Conscience is a God to every man: it is in Gods room; yet because it is an inferiour judge, subject to errour, when it appeareth God the superiour Judge doth countermand the contrary, then that ceaseth and hath no
[Page 30] further authority.
Rom. 2. The Apostle speaking of the Heathens, said,
their consciences did accuse, or excuse; here was judging then, and that by some superiority. Now this is much to be observed, because naturally we are unwilling to set up such a Court in our breast, we think we shall bring our selves under too much slavery; we cannot then, though but a little while, turn aside into any vain thoughts, or any loose practises, but we must be summoned to this court presently; men would be uncontrolled in their lusts, and therefore to assume a
[Page 31] superiority over a mans self, to make a mans self the delinquent, the offender, to shew no pity, no compassion to his sinnes, this is very difficult. No wonder men do not love Church-Discipline, for they cannot abide heart-discipline, soul order; they do not love to set up a spiritual court the
[...]e to arraign themselves, their convinced selves, against their delinquent selves, their inlightned selves, against their corrupt selves; yet this must be, where se
[...]f-judging is: As long as thou art afraid to leave thy lusts, or sin keeps thee in slavery, thou wilt never
[Page 32] erect a court in thy own heart to condemn them.
2. The second thing antecedent is knowledge and understanding, for if thou set up such a court in thy breast, and there be no Scripture wisdom to guide thee, here will be much false judgement: how many times doth the true believer bear false witness against himself, condemn himself falsly for an hypocrite, for a castaway, for one left by God: and on the other side, doth not the pharisaical man clear himself, say all is well, acquit himself because his waies are clean in his own eyes; and all this is, because
[Page 33] there is not that heavenly light to guide us in this self-judging. Now there is a twofold knowledge must go before we can pass any true sentence about our selves. First, A knowledge of our selves; that which the very Heathens have admitted as a fundamentall truth, and a divine Oracle,
E coelo descendit; but we see neither Heathens, no nor such as reade and know the Scripture, can perform this, while unregenerated
Rom. 7.
Paul did wholly mistake himself;
Nicodemus did not know himself; for this knowledge must be of our state by nature, in the first
[Page 34] place, that is a mystery: How many hereticks deny any such natural pollution, whereas the greatest part of our evil lieth in this.
Job and
David did go from actual sins to this of their nature, as the spring of all their evil, and for which they ought most to humble themselves; and when we throughly know this wretched and damnable estate of our nature, then able we are to know our sins past and present, especially our dearest sins, our own iniquities: So that by this it appeareth, that much spiritual skill, and heavenly wisdom is required to this self-judging,
[Page 35] because there must be so much self-knowing. Alas wilt thou go to judge thy heart, that knowest not the depths, or the deceitfulnesse of it! Did not
David, though a godly man,
Psal. 19. who had much illumination & sanctification, cry out,
Who can understand his errours? cleanse me from secret sins; that corruption I do not know, I cannot discover. If therefore thou wilt set upon this duty, get more knowledge of thy self, let in more light into thy brest, else there will many serpentine lusts lie crawling in thy heart, that thou wilt never discover: If a
[Page 36] godly man hardly know himself, how can a wicked man, who is wholly blinded with self-love. Secondly, There must be a knowl
[...]ge of the rule, the law, by which we are to judge our selves; as there must be light within, so without; as we must try spirits and doctrines by the word, so our hearts and actions by it, otherwise we shall foully mistake: it is of great consequence what rule you judge your selves by. The Scripture it may be condemneth that as loathsom, as abominable, which is glorious in thy eyes: The Scripture will tell thee that is no
[Page 37] grace, no godliness, which thou thinkest will carry thee to heaven. Most men judge of themselves by false rules; why is morality, why are duties, gifts, opinions, made grace to some men, resting upon them? but because they judge not by the rule; you must then be acquainted with Gods Word, apply that to thy heart, to thy life, to thy words: you must not bring the rule to you, making the Scripture for thy life, as heretiques do for their opinions, wrest it, possessing thy self first with such thoughts, & apprehending the Scripture
[...]very where
[Page 38] speaking to that purpose: So neither multitude, or the custom of others is a rule to judge our selves by, yea on the contrary we are to say,
Argumentum pessimi turba, the multitude is an argument of evil; and
nunquid mali feci, what evil have I done, when all commend me. What do you more than others, said our Saviour,
Matth. 5.47. but above all things we must not be a rule and a law to our selves, to make our own wils the Bible to walk by, and our own hearts the Scripture. The Scriptu
[...]e speaks notably, 2
Cor. 10.12.
They measured themselves
[Page 39] by themselves, they never looked upon better then themselves. Amongst blind men and deaf men, they that have any use of those senses, though much imperfect, are admired; so that in this self-judging it is dangerous to make our own hearts the accuser and the judge, for then all will be well. This makes the Church of
Rome incurable, that she will acknowledge no other judge but her self. Thus when we judge of our selves by our own inlargements, impulses, revelations, as the Illuminists and others do, these can never judge righteous
[Page 40] judgement. Tradition on the Popish side, and Revelations on the other side, have made the Scriptures authority void: but if thou wouldst judge right, keep to this rule.
3. There is required antecedently to this self-judging, composednesse and quietnesse of spirit: The heart must cast out all distracting turbulent workings of soul, else it is no waies able to judge it self: A man cannot see his face in the water that is stirred and moved up and down. Therefore the Psalmist saith,
Psal 4.4.
Commune with your heart upon your bed and be still. How
[Page 41] can that man, who is alwaies in a throng of businesse, in a croud of distracting thoughts, ever be able to passe sentence upon himself. Therefore remove all disquietness, all disturbances of soul; be as if there were nothing in the world, but God and thy own soul together, as
Abraham left his beast and other things at the bottom of the hill, and went up to God alone. It's
Aristotles rule,
Anima sedendo and
quiescendo fit sapiens, A quiet sedate frame of soul, is like wiping the dust off the glasse to see our faces more clearly. In the Canon Law the very sitting
[Page 42] is made requisite to the validity of t
[...]e sentence; that if the Judge do not
sedendo pronounce judgement, it is void, because it implyeth he is in some passion and commotion when he riseth up, or stirreth himself many waies.
4. There must not only be a quiet seda
[...]e frame of soul, but there must be an a
[...]tentive, fixed, and setled meditation of the heart in this work; so that self-judging can never be performed without meditation. This duty of meditation, as it is commended in the Scripture, so it is very seldom practised by believers; there is not the
[Page 43] least sinne lurking in the soul, but meditation would finde and search it out. Alas thy light, inconstant desulphurous thoughts, which are like a fl
[...]sh of lightning, these will never go to the bottom of thy soul. Hence this self-judging is in equivalent expressions, called searching and trying, as the Artificer doth coūterfeit from gold mettall; or as the woman took a candle, and swept the house to finde her lost groat. Meditation is the soul in paraphrase, whereas short ejaculations, are but the soul in an epitome, or in characters. It is a shame for us Protestants to see
[Page 44] how much Jesuitical devotion both commends and practiseth this work of meditation; insomuch that
Suarez said, he prized that part of the day, which was for the examination and scrutiny of his conscience, above all the time of his study, wherein he prepared so many voluminous books; and we are seldom or never in this duty.
Lastly, The work of God, even his efficacious grace is above all required antecedently, to inable us to this self-judging; if we cannot do the least good, or think the least good thought without his grace,
[Page 45] how much lesse this which is one of the greatest and weightiest,
Rom. 8. We know not what to pray, or how to pray without Gods Spirit, so neither what to judge, or how to judge, unlesse God assist us in it. This made
Paul say contrary to my text, 1
Cor. 4.3
I judge not my self; What, did not
Paul examine himself, & watch over himself? yes he did, lest he should become a castaway, but he dared not to judge himself with a sententiall absolution of himself, as from and of himself; Why? because
it is God that judgeth. So then, unlesse God who
[Page 46] knoweth our hearts better then we do, who seeth more pride, vanity, rottennesse in thy soul, then thou canst, unless he inable thee; thou maist be an
Hazaell, when thou thinkest thy self a Saint. Would
Peter have spoken so presumptuously, if God had made his own heart known to him at that time?
In the next place let us consider, what is formally constituent of this self-judging,
What is formally constituent of this self-judging. and that lie
[...]h in these things:
1. Examination, exploration, and diligent diving into our hearts. The Greek word is used sometimes for disputation and
[Page 47] doubting, which is a kind of further searching into a thing; then at first appeareth,
[...], and truly this is necessary for our hearts, because they are so deceitfull above all things. Thy principles, thy aims, thy ends, thy motives, and all the secret workings of thy soul, who can find out, but by diligent searching. The heart is like the sea, though the waters are calm above sometimes, yet there are many rocks, and several monsters under the waters. Therefore thou must search and again search, it may be thou art not yet come to the bottom of thy heart for all thy duties.
[Page 48]2. There is required not only examination, but discerning, and separation of the vile from the pretious, of making a difference, between what is of God in thee, and what of the devil in thee; what is of the flesh, and what is of the Spirit; for the meaning is not, as if a Christian should be alwaies searching, and examining, and prying upon his soul, wearying himself in labyrinths of doubts and perplexities, but he must be able to make a separation. Thus the Apostle,
Phil. 1.9, 10. prayeth they might
abound in all judgement, which was seen by
approving
[Page 49] the things that are excellent: and
Heb. 5.14. some are said to have
their senses exercised between good and evil: we see the hypocrite, the reprobate may go farre: we see there are many that do doctrinally dispute, that the work of grace is of the same
species in a temporary believer and one regenerated; yea many dispute, it's impossible to know whether we be in the state of grace or no: therefore there is required this eagle-eye, for from that bird do some derive the word
[...]. Oh then be thus wisely qualified, as to be able upon thy inquiry,
[Page 50] to take the drosse from the gold, to winnow the chaff from the wheat, and so to separate thy waies from the most refined paths of any hypocrite.
3. It's required, that upon sinne discovered, we should passe sentence of condemnation upon our selves; that as God will have at the day of judgement, a judgement of discussion, and then of condemnation to the wicked, so should we: And this is the greatest thing in this duty; if we would condemn our selves, saying, Lord we are worthy of all thy curses, of all thy wrath,
[Page 51] of all thy anger; this would prevent Gods judging of us.
David thus judged himself often; but our self-love, our self-flattery is such, that we are unwilling to sentence our selves as lost & damned wretches. As
Paul had the sentence of death, so we should have of condemnation upon our selves; and this is the way to have it repealed, to come to God, as they did to the King of
Israel, with a rope about their necks.
Lastly, This judging is in a voluntary taking of all shame upon our selves; we judge our selves to mourn, to weep, we judge
[Page 52] our selves to shame, and to an holy revenge upon our selves, 2
Cor. 7.11.
What indignation, what revenge: This was that penance the Church of God did exercise it self with in antiquity; for in grosse scandalous sinnes, such as did offend the Congregation, he that did truly judg himself for his sins, could have no rest, till he did publiquely confesse his sin, and shame himself with tears, in the face of the Church. Indeed afterwards this way was abused, and Officers of the Church took upon them to injoyn penance, and to make new Sacraments about
[Page 53] it, but at first there was only this way of their repentance and self-judging, a voluntary giving of God glory, and shaming themselves; and this is the duty still of all such publique grosse sinners, that do offend the Church. Thus they came to
John Baptist, publiquely
confessing their sins, Matth. 3.6. And those who used unlawfull arts,
came and burnt their books, though of a great value,
before Paul, Act. 19.19. It is not shame, or peoples talk, or any such carnal consideration, could hold them in, when their hearts were truly broken, and if such Church-discipline
[Page 54] were in use, would there be so much bold, and impudent prophannesse as is every where? If they were called upon, as
Joshua to
Achan, to
give glory to God, Josh. 7.19. they would not then presse to Sacraments without a wedding garment, yea with goar blood of their sins upon them; but would rather with the leper stand aloof off, crying out,
I am unclean, unclean: and with another,
Calcate me insipidum salem, trample on me as unsavoury salt: They would not then rage at the Minister, and say, the Sacraments are their dues, but would acknowledge
[Page 55] publike shame and sorrow was due to them: They would not presse to make us guilty of unworthy giving, while they are of unworthy receiving:
Et dum se solvere cupiunt ligare Sacerdotem, as
Ambrose speaketh excellently, while they seek to lose themselves, to binde the Minister. But it is not all the books, all the arguments in the world that will do this, it must be an humble heart, truly contrite before God. To hear men cavilling whether Godly order be
Jure Divino, when the world knoweth their prophannesse, their impiety is not
Jure Divino, may
[Page 56] make us conclude, that it is not arguments, or books, but an humble, self judging heart, that must decide this controversie.
The concomitants of this self-judging.The next thing is the Concomitants: And fi
[...]st, self-judging is accompanied with exalting and setting up of God, as
David, Psal. 5.4.
Thou maiest overcome when thou art judged. So much as the soul judgeth it self, so much it cleareth God. O God my perdition is of my self, if temporal, if spiritual judgements fall upon me, I must clear thee, I cannot charge the holy God foolishly. Thus man is low, and God is set up.
[Page 57]2. This is accompanied with sincerity, and ingenuity.
Examine me and try me, said
David, Psal. 26.2. The sincere heart is willing every secret corner of his soul should be searched into, but the hypocrite of all duties, cannot abide this self-judging, he will never say,
Even my son Jonathan shall die.
3. It is accompanied with much shame and relenting of soul: He is judged, even as a poor malefactor is judged, that bitterly laments his misery, and therefore the whole work of conversion is in this self-judging.
The last thing, are the
[Page 58] Consequents of self-judging;
The consequences of this self-judging. which are,
1. A readinesse to every duty, to every holy performance. He that hath judged himself faithfully, he cryeth out with
Paul, What wilt thou Lord have me to do Thou hast never throughly & deeply judged thy self, if thou canst not pull out thy right eye.
2. He doth renounce all his own righteousness, flying alone to Christ, and seeking for justification by him alone. The Pharisee did not judge himself, and so he saw not the need of Christ.
We thus judge, saith
Paul, 2 Cor. 5.14.
if Christ died for all, then all
[Page 59] were dead, descendēdo ad coelum ascenditur; by descending we ascend to heaven.
3. They are patient and humble under all those chastisements God layeth upon them for their sins; they judge themselves worthy of them, and hell it self.
Why should a man complain of the punishment of his sins, Lam. 3.39. Thus they accept of their punishment.
4. They have a deaf ear against all the censures and calumnies wicked men cast upon them. They judge themselves more then all the world doth, and for that heart corruption which the world cannot know.
[Page 60]5. This will make him a savoury, experimentall Christian, he can tell how to speak to the temptations, to the doubts of other mens hearts, and to the cases of conscience in godly men; by this duty constantly performed, he cometh to have wonderfull skill in heart-work, he knoweth more then books can teach him, he closeth with a heart searching Ministry, he speaks from the heart, to the heart of another.
Lastly, He doth not sinfully censure others, he hath enough to do to judg himself; neither can he give way to uselesse disputes,
[Page 61] and opinions in Religion: Oh this self judging will make a man avoid all these endlesse questions that beget nothing but strifes; therefore its excellent counsell to those who spend their whole life in disputes and opinions, to be more acquainted with self judging, and thou wilt finde thy own heart will help thee to work enough: thou wilt finde errours, lusts, such combats and rebellions in the practicall way of powerfull godlinesse, that thou wilt be amazed to see how men can take up so much time abroad, and keep so little at home.
Some practical Corallaries or Conclusions from the truth premised.Let us adde some Corallaries, or Conclusions from the truth premised.
1. That a natural unregenerate man, cannot judge himself, he wants all the forementioned Antecedents; so that in this sense it is true,
The spiritual man judgeth all things, 1 Cor. 2.15. Can a beast judge, what the reason of a man is?
2. This self-judging is not opposite to an Evangelical, Gospel frame, nor to the Spirit of Adoption; you may think this is too legal, this will incourage doubtings, & banish fears; certainly the Apostle did
[Page 63] not intend to prejudice grace, or to take the
Corinthians off from Christ, while he presseth this duty.
3. This self-judging though a duty, yet is wisely to be managed; we must not judge in our temptations, in our sad thoughts, or when the Devil distempers thy eyesight.
4. This self-judging is not to keep us in uncertainties; but as we are to prove all things in doctrine, yet not be Scepticks; we must hold fast that which is good: so about our hearts we must judge, yet so as to make
[Page 64] our Calling and Election sure. This self-judging must not oppose assurance.
5. No man can so judge himself, as to finde out all the naughtiness of his heart; he cannot empty this Sea; if our hearts condemn us, God is greater then our hearts, 1
Joh. 3.20. God seeth more vileness and corruption in us, then we are able to finde out.
6. Under Gods judgements, or upon special approaches to him, we are to receive this duty. Therefore we are more solemnly to perform it at this time in approaching
[Page 65] to the Sacrament; for hereby we shall prevent Gods Judging of us.
1. Every Sacrament we have received God took notice of: God hath not forgot all thy former unworthy receivings. Thy old sins, thy old formality, may be matter of trembling to thee: as
Melancthon said
Totus cohorresco, &c.
I am all in a trembling to think, how once in Popery I went boldly, and fell down before Images, worshipping of them: so say, horrour taketh hold of me, to think how prophanely and irreverently I once approached
[Page 66] to this Table.
2. Judge thy self, because of the special grace and favour vouchsafed to the fit guest: the more thou judgest thy self, Gods love will be the mo
[...]e welcom to thee: As the Centurion judged himself unworthy that Christ should come within his roof.
3. Judge thy self, it may be this may recover the benefit of former Sacraments which was lost: Godly men may receive unworthily, though in the state of Grace, because not in a Proxime preparation; and therefore receive the Judgement
[Page 67] of Chastisement, though not eternal Condemnation: Thus Self-judging then may recover the benefit of all by-past Sacraments.
CHAP. II. Of Gods Judging and punishing his own Children for their sins, with the Aggravation and mitigation of them compared with the sins of others.
1 COR. 11.31.
For if we would judge our selves, we should not be judged.
VVE proceed to the second Doctrine, which is very usefull to awaken
[Page 69] the Godly, and to make them walk with an holy fear, not abusing the grace of God, and making his love an occasion of sin; which is,
Th
[...]t God doth Judge even his own people for their sins: Justification and Gospel Grace doth not set Believers in such a secure condition, that let them live how they will, Gods love will indulge all, God will take no notice of their sins to chastise them for them. In the Text we have Gods judging of such; for although it cannot be thought, that all who came irreverently to this Ordinance were truly
[Page 70] Godly; so on the other side we cannot conclude none were; yea it is plain, that some of those were truly holy, though offending God in their Sacrament-Sins, because the Apostle addeth,
verse 32.
When we are judged we are chastened of the Lord, that we may not be condemned with the world. This then being laid for a foundation, it is plain, that God judgeth his own people for their sins. Now this word Judgement doth imply, that God is not only a Father to his People, but a Judge also, a Fatherly Judge: so that although as a Father he be merciful
[Page 71] and pittiful, yet as a Judge he is severe, and will chastise for sin: this is notably expressed, 1
John 2.12.
If any man sin, we have an Advocate with the Father: Though he be a Father, yet we need an Advocate upon our sinning, even the Lord Christ. Though he is a tender Father, yet an Holy Judge also; and therefore doth God assume to himself such tempered Relations, that his People might have such a tempered and qualified frame of heart, that they might rejoyce with trembling, that they might love with reverence, that though they call on him
[Page 72] as a Father, yet because he is such a father, they are to pass the time of their sojourning here in fear, 1
Pet. 1.17. Therefore observe what the Apostle addeth, if ye call him Father, who without respect of persons judgeth every man: if
David though a man after his own heart? If
Solomon though beloved of the Lord do sin against him, he will chasten them, and make them feel the bitterness of their fins as well as others; although alwaies their is a great difference between the afflictions that are upon the Godly for their sins, and those which are
[Page 73] upon the wicked. The wo
[...]d then in the Text doth suppose a real anger, and just displeasure in God against his own people when they offend; for to judge is more then to chasten: to chasten is commonly made the action of a Father; but to judge and to punish, the act of a judge; yet this latter God doth to his offending people; whether it be punishment, properly so taken, is afterward to be sp
[...]ken unto; we have the like passage, 1
Pet. 4.17. The time is come that judgement must begin at the house of God; here is judgement, and that to
[Page 74] Gods house. It is true, the word judgement, even as to judge is used in several senses in the Scripture, sometimes for that strict justice of God, whereby he will take notice of sin to punish it, according to the utmost desert of it. Against this
David, though a godly and justified man, doth earnestly deprecate,
Psal. 143.2.
Enter not into judgement with thy servant, and the reason is full of weight;
for in thy sight no flesh shall be justified: There is no holy man can stand in this judgement, if God be only as a Judge, and not a Father likewise, we are all damned men;
[Page 75] but at other times judgement is used for mercy, and moderation opposite to anger, as,
Jer. 10.24.
O Lord correct me, but with judgement, not in thine anger; that is in moderation, let my afflictions be medicinal, not destructive,
Aliter secat Chirurgus, aliter Lanius; he prayeth that God would let no more blood from him then may abate his disease, and weaken corruption within him, suitable to this, is that expression,
Ier. 30.11. Where God, though he threatens the Nations to make a full end of them by his anger, yet to
Israel he saith,
I will correct thee
[Page 76] in measure or in judgement, he would not pour out all his wrath: Thus the godly have submitted to Gods rebukes;
Jeremiah doth not pray to be corrected, but it is his concession and resignation,
If Lord I have provoked thee, and thou correct me, let it not be in thy anger and hot displeasure; for who can indure under that.
But in my Text, to
judge, and
judgement is not taken for moderation, or mercy, but f r severity and afflictions, arising from Gods anger to his people, when they have sinned aga nst him.
Let us lay open the
[Page 77] Doctrine; and first consider, that there are two extream and dangerous errors
Two errors to be avoided. about this truth, and you must carefully avoid both these rocks: for first there is the
Antinomian erring on the right hand, and they do so magnifie the grace of God in justification, they do so exalt the love of God in Christ to believers, that they say God never seeth any sin in them, he is never angry with them; he is as well pleased with
David in his Adultery, as when making his Penitential
Psalm: as well with
Peter, denying Christ, as when weeping bitterly; but certainly
[Page 78] this opinion may quickly fall from the head to kill the vitals of all holiness; for if God doth not see sin in me, why should I see sin in my self? And if God be not angry with me for my offences, why should I be angry and grieved at my self, when I have fallen into any sin; so that this opinion doth overthrow all those commands which are made to the godly upon their falls, to repent, and to recover from their backslidings, with brokenness and bitterness of heart. As also it chargeth
David and
Peter, with others, who have so bitterly bewailed their revolt
[Page 79] from God with weakness, yea sinfulness, troubling and grieving themselves where they ought not. According to this Doctrine, God never chastiseth for sin (as they express it) but from sin, that is, the afflictions which come upon the godly, do not arise from Gods anger for sin past, only they are afflicted to prevent future. But the instance in my Text doth confute this; for these
Corinthians being guilty of sinfull approaches to the Lords Table; it was because of this sin that God brought such a general mortality amongst them; for this cause, saith
[Page 80] the Apostle,
ver. 30.
Many are sick and weak not some, but many, and it was for this cause: It is true indeed the afflictions Gods people have, are for the preventing of future corruptions, and to teach them not to sin any more; yet withal they are sharp stings for sins past. Let not then the gracious heart delude himself, that because he is in a state of grace, he may therefore sin and do what he list: let him remember what the Apostle saith, even in the person of the godly,
Heb. 12.29.
For our God is a consuming fire. David complaineth of his
[Page 81]
broken bones, and wi
[...]h many tears and agonies of soul prayeth that God would restore his loving kindness to him, for he had lost the sence and feeling of it. It is true the people of God are to grow up into the Spirit of Adoption, and to cast out all tormenting fears; but they must distinguish between Liberty and Licentiousness, they must not under that pretence cast out an holy trembling and a reverential fear lest they offend God at any time. In the
second place, the Devil promoteth his Kingdom of darkness on the left hand, if he cannot
[Page 82] on the right; therefore in Popery their is also corrupt Doctrine about this point, and instead of milk they wring till blood cometh; for they say, God doth not only judge his people for their sins, though he hath pardoned the fault, but that he doth afterwards in a proper way punish them, and avenge himself in a way of Justice, which they are to satifie in respect of temporal punishments by some voluntary penalties either inflicted upon them, or voluntarily assumed. Thus when
David hath his sin pardoned, yet they say, the death of his childe was
[Page 83] inflicted as a proper punishment to satisfie the justice of God: Christs blood takes away the guilt of sin, but mans poenal exercises, must take away the temporal punishment. Thus by their distinctions they do greatly obscure the Doctrine of Justification, which doth take off all the guilt of sin, so that there remaineth properly no more punishment for sin thus pardoned; I would not contend about the word punishment, I s
[...]e Divines do use the word concerning those afflictions which God layeth upon his people, only we cannot say they are
ultiones,
[Page 84] they are not acts of vengeance to the godly, as they are to the wicked, being of the same nature, though different in degree with the torments of hell to the damned.
Calvin therefore doth distinguish between
Judicium ultionis and
Judicium castigationis, a judgement of revenge, and a judgement of Chastisement; the latter onely befall the godly, and if you say, why then doth the Scripture require humiliation and repentance? Yea,
Bellarmine urgeth my Text,
to judge our selves, which he would have, to imply such voluntary punishing of our selves,
[Page 85] through Fasting, and other duties, that thereby we may satisfie Gods justice, so as to remove the temporal punishment.
I answer, the Apostle doth not use the word
[...], when he speaks of our duty, but
[...], which is to examine and search our selves, to separate the evil from the good, upon discussion of our selves to be greatly humbled, and loathing of our selves for our sins N
[...]t that these duties are to satisfie Gods Justice, but onely they are the way, wherein God alone will communicate mercy. Thus you see how the
[Page 86] truth is stated between two extreams, and it is good for Christians to be throughly informed herein, that in the afflictions which befall them they may know how to judge of God, and also to deport themselves accordingly. To judge of God, as one indeed angry and displeased, and whose anger is terrible, so that to a godly man, it is more dreadfull then all troubles, to apprehend Gods displeasure to him. It is not, saith
David, the loss of my childe, the troubles in my Kingdom, that affects me so much, as because
God doth hide his face from me, Psal.
[Page 87] 51. and it must needs be so, because the heart of a believer awakened for sin, is made very tender, and so the frowns of God do more pierce his heart, then almost Hell flames do terrifie the wicked: as a little offence to the eye, because a tender part, is more grievous then great blows to other parts of the body. The godly therefore are not to despise the rod of God, yea, none are more to lay it to heart then they. But further, as they are to be sensible of his anger, so withal to assure themselves that he is angry, because he loveth them: that this bitter
[Page 88] fruit doth come from a sweet root: that all his exercises have their rise from a Fatherly care towards them, and therefore they are to receive them as medicinal, not as poenal and destructive.
But I shall not inlarge further herein: let us for the more particular affecting of our selves, who pretend to have an interest in the Lord more then others, consider the grounds why God will not let his own people,
Reasons why God will punish his own people for their sins. when sinning, to go unpunished; they must be called to a severe account, yea when God letteth the wicked ones of the world live in
[Page 89] their ease, go on securely in their impieties, and blessing themselvs therein; at the same time the godly for lesser sins shall have the bitter cup of affliction to drink of, so that by outward events you would think the godly only were hated by God, & the wicked loved: And the
first ground of Gods judging his own people, if not judging and humbling themselves, may be from the
order, and
way which God hath appointed for the communicating of Christs benefits to us, for this is the foundation of that Antinomian errour mentioned, when they
[Page 90] read such places, as that Christs blood
is made an atonement for our sins: that the father laid our iniquities upon him: that he is made righteousness to us, and that we are accepted of in Christ: They think this is all, and because this is accomplished by Christ, though we be wallowing in our lusts, they think these great merci
[...]s are to be applied to us, but they are to remember the other places as well of believing, of repentance, not that they are causes, or merits, or to be opposed to Christ, but they are the qualifications of such subjects to whom Christ will thus reveal
[Page 91] himself; and the Pool, as it were in moving whereof the Angel cometh down, and healeth us, so that its a blessed thing to avoid extremities in this point in our afflictions, not to be securely presuming, nor yet slavishly dejected; not to look upon a Christ without duties, nor yet oppose duties to Christ.
2. Another ground why God may even break the bones, yea the heart as it were of his own children when offending him, is from the many aggravations that are to be found in the sinnes of the godly, so that the like cannot be found in the transgressions
[Page 92] of the wicked man, insomuch that the offences of the godly do in some respects more displease God, then all the sins of wicked men: As first, when the people of God sin, it is against more experience of the sweetness and comfort by grace, and also of the bitterness of sin, which they have felt in their own souls; and certainly this must highly aggravate thy sin, thou knowest what the songs and joys are, of an heart reconciled to the Father through Christ. Thou knowest how bitter a thing it is for God, to shut thee out of his doors for thy transgressions, to
[Page 93] give thee childrens bread no longer, but to suffer thee to live upon husks: Oh what an aggravation is this to every sin thou fallest in, to remember these experiences: Alas, the wicked when they sin, they never tasted of a better life; they never found any thing sweeter then the creature; therefore they think they do not sin to their loss, and so they have not experimentally felt the terrours of the Lord it may be upon their souls: hence it is no wonder if they eat poison for honey; but for thee who hast been taught all these things upon thy soul, to meddle
[Page 94] with sin that cost thee so dear; to deprive thy self of that joy and heaven thou hast had: Oh tremble under the approaches of any sin to the
[...] Christ used this as a motive in his prayer for those who crucified him,
Father forgive them, for they know not what they do; but how shall Christ say, forgive thee, who knowest what thou doest: All the experience God hath wrought in thee about holy things, doth sadly aggravate thy evil ways.
2. As the godly sin against more experience, so they also rebell against more light and knowledg,
[Page 95] which is always highly aggravating a sin: What made the Angels sins to be so greatly displeasing to God? What made
Adams sin so highly offensive? amongst other reasons this was one. They sinned against a great deal of light and knowledge which God had indued them with: Now the godly man hath not onely natural light, but revealed light; he is supernaturally illuminated, and that not only in a common way, as many Hypocrites are, but in a special and peculiar manner, such as no reprobate can attain unto; oh then how greatly must
[Page 96] God be offended, when thou shalt sin against that quick, penetrating, and tender light, which shineth in thy breast; and therefore God will judge thee for thy he
[...]rt-sins, thy soul-sins; the pride there, the unbelief there, because thou hast light to discover all these. Any false motions, any sinfull inten
[...]ions, any corrupt minglings of thy self with the things of God, these God will judge, because thou hast spiritual light within thee, which like the Sun-beams make thee discover those atomes, those secret little sins, that other vi
[...] u wouldst
[Page 97] never take any notice of; remember then what light thou hast put under a bushel, as it were, and then no wonder if God judge thee for this.
3. The godly mans sin is more hainous then the wicked mans, because of that love, that Free-grace, those bowels of mercy shewed to him, which never were to ungodly men. No wonder then, if of all sins God will not bear the abuse of his love and his grace, especially that discriminating grace; he gave his Son to thee, not to another, who if converted, might have done him more service:
[Page 98] his Grace did convert thee, change thee when thou wast as froward as others, wallowing in thy lusts as others, and so how can God take thy rebellion against so much Free-grace; what patience is it, that Hell doth not swallow thee quick up: As the Apostle argueth comparatively the excellency of Christ,
To which of the Angels said he, Thou art my Son: so to what wicked man, to what unconverted man, abiding in his sins, hath God drawn nigh with that grace and favour, as he hath to thee? how unreasonable is it to turn grace then into wantonness:
[Page 99] Argue as
Ezra did,
cap, 9.13.
Thou hast given us such a deliverance as this, and should we again break thy Commandments, O Lord, thou hast done for me more then for many thousands, who sit under the power of their lusts, and shall I despise this love of God?
4. The godly mans sin is to be aggravated, because of the special priviledges which God doth bestow upon him; for he maketh him his Son, his Friend, admits him into his presence and favour. Now thou who art at such a Feast always, shouldst never be without thy Wedding-garment:
Seemeth
[Page 100] it light to you, said
David, to be Son in Law to a King: and thus, is it a small matter to be taken into Gods favour, to be his adopted children; to be in communion with him; to stand, as it were, before him: surely this must greatly aggravate thy sin: The more favour and honour from God, the more abominable is thy sinfulness.
Michal told
David falsly,
Thou hast made thy self like one of the vile persons: but it is true of thee, Is it for one accustomed to the Kings presence to be tumbling in mire and dirt. Oh shame thy self in thy humiliation for this; how
[Page 101] uncomely is this to a justified person? how unsuitable to the spirit of Adoption; observe that passage, 1
Kin. 11.9. God was angry with
Solomon, because his
heart was turned from God, which had appeared to him twice: How many times in a gracious manner hath God appeared to thy soul, and wilt thou provoke him?
5. The godly mans sins are the more hainous because committed against greater obligations, and bonds to the contrary; for every duty, every ordinance is a greater obligation against sin. The more thou hast prayed against
[Page 102] passions, & yet passionate: the more thou hast prayed against pride, and yet proud; and so of every sin, the greater is thy sin. God will bring thy prayers, thy duties to witness against thee, haply the wicked man never, or very seldom hath prayed against his evil ways; but in every confession, in every prayer thou hast bewailed, and resolved against such evils, and therefore in this respect, the greater aggravation of sin, when committed. Again the Sacrament of the Lords Supper that is a strong & mighty obligation against sin. Now the godly they are
[Page 103] admitted to this Ordinance, they are not commanded to stand in the Court, but they may enter into the Holy of Holies; they are children, and this bread is to be given to them. Now if they walk in proud sinful waies, what a witness wil this ordinance be against thee; did ye receive Christ to serve the Devil? Did ye receive Christ to vaine & unbelieving thoughts. Oh know that all sins after obliging Ordinances have a kind of perfidiousness and Covenant-breaking in them, and this must needs aggravate.
6. The sins of Gods
[Page 104] people are to be heightned in this consideration, that they are not only transgressions, but unkindnesses, and therefore they are said not only to anger God, but to grieve him, as
Ephes. 4.30.
Grieve not the holy Spirit of God: God complaineth of
Israel who were his people in a peculiar manner, though all not upright in heart,
that forty years long they had grieved him: and truly what grieveth the spirit of God, must exceedingly grieve us. Hence though the sins of the godly cannot be that sin against the Holy Ghost, which the Scripture makes unparpardonable,
[Page 105] yet because the Spirit of God, is in the godly a Sanctifier, a Sealer, a Comforter, and worketh choice and glorious effects in them; therefore they do in a more special manner grieve the Spirit of God. The Spirit of God dwels in the godly as in his Temple, and not so in a wicked man; now to defile this Temple, to prophane this Temple by applying thy self to any evil way, how distastfull must it be to the Spirit of God: Oh remember, wicked mens sins anger God, but thine do grieve him also; as a stubborn child doth not only offend his
[Page 106] parents, but make them inwardly grieve also.
7 The people of God in their sins have this aggravating particular why God should judge them rather then others, because they have greater power to withstand it, there is not that necessity upon them in sinning, as is in unregenerate men: It is true, an unregenerate man cannot but sin in all that he doth, yet this necessity doth not excuse but aggravate, both because it is voluntarily contracted upon himself, and because this necessity is voluntary, and with delight,
Eo magis libera quo magis Ancilla, as
Bernard:
[Page 107] But now in a godly man, there is a spiritual life and power within him to avoid sin; he is not in the progresse of holinesse, as in the first conversion, meerly passive, but now
actì agimus, and
moti movemus; the grace of God exciting, we have life within us to co-operate. Now then, if God hath infused such a life within us, it is thy greater sin, if thou dost not act accordingly: God hath brought thee out of thy first bondage, and if thou dost yet live a slave, the greater is thy condemnation. It's made a dispute, whether a godly man can avoid any more
[Page 108] sins then he doth, or do any more good then he doth: Some Orthodox men are reported by the Arminians to affirm they cannot; but no doubt converting grace takes away that spiritual death in sin, and giveth principles of life, and all habits of grace infused, have a sufficiency in their way to produce their acts, yet so as they need actual grace to excite and apply these to operation. A man that hath his eye healed, hath a power to see, yet if there be not light to actuate the
medium, he cannot see. We need grace even after conversion, to excite and
[Page 109] quicken those principles: But this sheweth that a godly mans sin is therefore to be aggravated, because he hath a principle within to refuse it.
8. Hence it is, because of this supernatural life within him, that all the sins of a godly man have a kinde of unnaturalnesse in them; when a wicked man sinneth, he sinneth of his own, it is naturall, as it is for a serpent to be poysonous, for a wolf to be ravening; but if a godly man sin, it's wholly
contra-natural: How cometh this figtree to bear thorns, this Vine to bear thistles? Hence, 1
Joh 3.9.
he that
[Page 110] is born of God, is said,
not to sinne, yea
he cannot sinne, because the seed abideth in him, for sins are against his divine principle; it is as if iron should swim, as if fire should descend:
How can I do this and sin against God, said
Joseph, Gen. 39.9.
9. Therefore God doth judge his people when offending, because their sinnes do dishonour God more; what disorders are in an house redound to the Masters reproach; from wicked men no other thing is expected, every one looketh that swine will wallow in the mire; but when sheep do so, this
[Page 111] is intollerable. This aggravation God putteth upon
Davids sinne, 2
Sam. 12.14.
Because by this deed, thou hast given great occasion for the enemies of God to blaspheme. Now remember that the honour and glory of God is worth ten thousand such as thou art.
10. And lastly, The sinnes of the godly are a stumbling block and incouragement to the wicked; if they see thee proud, earthly, passionate, they think they may do so likewise. Besides, thou dost hereby discover some wearinesse of God, as if to turn from him to sinne
[Page 112] were better, as if thou didst not finde that contentment and fulnesse in the waies of God, as thou didst hope for; so that seeing all these things are in the sinnes of the godly, no wonder if the Lord do in a special manner, call them to account, & make them taste of the bitter cup he giveth them to drink.
Use of Exhortation, let the People of God then speedily set upon this duty of self-judging. It is a fearfull thing to fall into the hands of God provoked; if thy heart be dull, hard, sensless, lay all these quickning aggravations of thy
[Page 113] sins to thy soul, and they must needs humble thee. The Sacrament of the Lords Supper, as from one consideration, it requireth joy, and gladness of heart; so from another, godly sorrow and brokenness of soul, to see Christ crucifyed, as it were, for thy sins before thy eyes, and thou hast been many times ready to crucifie him again and again: Cry out, O Lord, my heart is overwhelmed, what can I say, This sin with these aggravations make me fear and tremble. Oh it is not in my own worthinesse, in my own fitnesse, I presume to draw to this
[Page 114] Ordinance, for with the Centurion, I am not worthy Christ should come within my roof; and thus the lesse thou sparest and excusest thy self, the more welcome wilt thou be to this Table.
CHAP. III. Of Gods punishing his people for sins against a
Positive Institution, such as Sacrament-sins.
1 COR. 11.31.
For if we would judge our selves, we should not be judged of the Lord.
THE last Observation is, That
God doth judge his people, not only for moral grosse sinnes, but Sacrament-sins, sinnes that are against a positive institution. The
Corinthians were guilty of many other
[Page 114]
[...]
[Page 115]
[...]
[Page 116] sins, some whereof were contrary to the moral Law, yea to the very light of nature; but the Apostle doth not instance in them as a cause of that publick judgement which was upon them, but he pitcheth on their prophane approachings to the Lords Supper, which is of a positive Institution. The original of all that calamity which is come upon mankinde, and that sinne for which God was so provoked, that all the posterity of
Adam is obnoxious to eternal wrath, God punishing no sin in the like manner, as he did this; What was it? but a transgression
[Page 117] of a positive law.
Uzzah was stricken dead,
Nadab and
Abihu consumed with fire from heaven, and all because they did not keep to such order, in Gods worship, as he had instituted: 1
Chron. 15.13. Yea
Moses but for deferring Circumcision, which was an Ordinance likewise of meer institution, so that it had been no duty to circumcise, if God had not commanded it, yet he was threatned to be killed for his delay therein. The Paschal lamb also,
Exod. 4.24. to which the Sacrament of the Lords Supper doth answer, whosoever did neglect,
[Page 118] was
to be cut off from among his people, Numb. 9.13. By these instances it doth appear how severe the wrath of God is against all such as do not keep to the Ordinances of God, and that in such order as he hath required, as we reade
David acknowledging, 1
Chron. 15.13.
I shall not treat in the general about all the positive institutions of Christ, but limit my self to this of the Lords Supper, and to shew you, that seeing God will so justly judge men for their unworthy approaches to it, it is good for us to judge our selves for such sins first, and this
[Page 119] may prevent Gods judging of us; only to understand the Doctrine, you must know that that speaketh of sins of two sorts, moral sins, and positive sins; to understand which distinction, you must know, that this division is according to the two kinds of Commands which God imposeth upon his Church; there are moral commands, which command or forbid that which is either intrinsecally good, or evil; so that because they are goo
[...] God commandeth them they are not commanded and therefore good: suc
[...] is to love God, to fear hi
[...]
[Page 120] and such are the duties of the second Table: for we regard not those Schoolmen, who say nothing is intrinsecally good or evil, but meerly so from the outward Command of God, or his prohibition. Again, there are positive commands, and these have their goodness onely, because God commands them, in themselves they have no intrinsecal goodness, only Gods institution makes them good; thus the sanctification of the Lords Day is a duty by positive institution: so the observation of the Sacraments, it is a duty by Gods meer will and institution,
[Page 121] so that the not being baptized, the not receiving of the Lords Supper had not been any sins, if God had not required them: only these positive Commands are again distinguished into positive
temporary, such things as God hath required of h
[...]s Church for a time only, as to be Circumcised, to observe the Judaical Rites and Sacrifices: it was great sinne to keep them up when the time of their obligation was expired. 2. There is positive
perpetual, and that is when God hath appointed such Ordinances to be observed till the coming
[Page 122] of Christ, as the Lords day, Baptisme, and the Lords Supper, we are to shew forth his death till he come, 1
Cor 11. This is called by some Divines Moral Positive, and the other Moral commands, are called Moral Natural. Now as there are two kinds of Laws, so there are such kinds of sins which are the transgression of those Laws; when a man is unjust, unclean, intemperate, then he breaks the natural Law of God; when he prophanes the Sabbath, when he cometh unprepared to a Sacrament, he breaketh the Positive Law; and whereas
[Page 123] it might be thought these latter sins are not very hainous, because they are only
mala quia prohibita evils, because prohibited, Gods prohibition maketh them to be sins. The Doctrine telleth us, that for such sins God will judge us: yea it is worth the while to take notice of that place,
Levit. 17.
ver. 3, 4, 5. where God speaking not of a prophane killing of beasts for common food, but religious, by way of Sacrifice, he enjoyneth this order, that whosoever killeth a beast, thus for a Sacrifice, and bringeth it not unto the door of the
[Page 124] Tabernacle,
blood shall be imputed to that man, he hath shed blood. A notable place, to shew how hainous a sin it is not to keep to Gods order in his worship. The very not bringing of it to the door of the Tabernacle maketh it as hainous a sin as to kill a man; and indeed in some respects these sins are worse then the other, whereof this is the chief, because the Lord doth by these Positive precepts demonstrate his soveraignty over us, and try our obedience; so that if we be negligent or omissive therein, we do expresly and formally manifest our
[Page 125] disobedience to God, and do refuse to own him as our Lord: Not to add that in these positive institutions, God regardeth our good; he hath appointed Sabbaths and Sacraments, not for his good but for ours, not that he needeth us, but because we need him; and therefore we must highly sin against our souls,
What particulars are to be examined, & inquired after with special respect to the Ordinance of the Lords Supper. when God shall in such a mercifull manner tender our good, and we refuse it.
This foundation laid, let us inquire into the duty of Self-judging in this particular Ordinance of the Lords Supper, and because this judging as you
[Page 126] heard doth imply a judgment of
discussion, and upon sin discovered, a judgement of
condemnation. Let us speak to both, and for the judgement of
Discussion: these things are to be done, first the worthy Receiver, who may receive comfortably, is to judge himself about the state of grace, to examine himself, whether he be a new creature, whether God hath ever put a supernatural and heavenly principle in him, or no? for if he be a man in the state of nature still? If he have no more in him then what he came with into the world, he cannot
[Page 127] put forth those actual graces of Faith, and spiritual hunger after Christ, and his benefits, which make the Lords Supper to be spiritual meat and nourishment indeed. There was once a prophane custom crept into the Church, which was removed by a Council, That the Lords Supper should no
[...] be given to dead men, and the elem
[...]nts being symbols of nourishment, in the use whereof we a
[...]e commanded to eat and drink, all this supposeth that while men are dead in sins, void of spiritual life, they cannot spiritually eat and drink, nor put forth
[Page 128] gracious actings in the Ordinances; for there must be a good root, befo
[...]e the branches be good; there must be a good Fountain, ere the streams be; and so a good foundation of grace and spiritual life within, before thou art able to put forth Sacramental act ngs; only you must remember that the Church admits such to this Table that have competent knowledge, and are free from gross sins, because she cannot judge of the hearts of men: neither is the Sanctification, or Regeneration of a person, either in Baptism, or the Lords Supper
[Page 129] a foundation of the administration of the Sacrament; for then the Minister would be in perpetual doubtings to whom to give it to, or ra her conclude to give it to none, because he cannot certainly judge of grace in another mans heart, but the ground of our administration is Christs command, with the order and way he hath prescribed. Now the Word doth only barr ignorant and prophane, the other are admitted to come; yet they must know that without a principle of regeneration, they cannot spiritually eat and drink at this Feast. Therefore
[Page 130] rest not in mans approbation, that is but a poor reed to lean upon: you see the Officers let in that man to the Feast, and did not keep him out, who came without a wedding-garment; but the Master of the Feast, when he cometh and vieweth them, he finds him out, saying,
Friend, how camest thou hither, without a wedding garment? Mat. 22.12. which made him speechless immediatly; he did not plead, thy servants admitted me, they bid me come; so neither wilt thou be able to plead, who being not born again, or in a state of grace, approachest to this Ordinance:
[Page 131] Lord I was admitted by the Ministers, I gave them satisfaction. This is not enough, but search into the bottom of thy soul, inquire what are the great things God hath done to thy inward man: remember it is
mensa Aquilarum, not
Graculorum, a Table for Eagles, not Jayes, as
Chrysostom said. If a gracious heart doubt about this work of grace in himself; such an one is to know that his duty is to come; for where there is a sense of sin, an hungering after Christ, a bewailing of our infirmities, these are incouragements for thee to come, though
[Page 132] it may be thou art not assured of thy being in the state of Grace: many of Gods children would be denied this bread, if none might come, but those that had assurance of their being in Christ. I have not time to inlarge on this
2. We are to judge our selves about our present fitness, and capacity for the Lords Supper: Not only whether grace be in us for the main, but whether it be actuated, and preparing the soul, that it is like a room ready swept & drest to receive Christ: Every godly man is not in an immediate fitness to receive
[Page 133] the Lords Supper. Some of these
Corinthians were truly godly, as was proved, yet they became guilty of unworthy receiving, by their actual indisposition. The instrument may want tuning for present melody; the k
[...]y may be rusty; the heart may be so dul, unbelieving, c
[...]rnal, and unsavoury, that there is not a present temper of heart to close with those Ordinances as he ought to do. If thy heart be a Fountain, but sealed up; if a Box of oyntment, but not opened; there is a gulf be
[...]w
[...]en Sacramental benefits and thy heart. If you ask,
[Page 134] what doth actual fitness consist in: I answer it is in the actual exercise of those graces, the principles whereof are in thy soul: It is like the wind breathing upon the flowers of a garden, which make them send forth a sweet smell; its like a tool whetted, like a Spring running, like a fire kindled, many times thou hast wood laid together, the principles of grace within thee, but there is not fire that doth kindle it; the graces to be actually put forth, are a renewed sorrow and tender meltings of thy heart for thy former impieties; serious meditation about
[Page 135] Christ his Person, his Offices, his unspeakable love in dying for thee, not to give over thinking about this, till thou finde it prove like coals of fire in thy bosom; Heavenly mindedness likewise lifteth up thy heart, and makes thee suitable to heavenly gifts; spiritual hungrings and longings of soul after the benefits received, holy joy and gladness of heart, with great thankfulness unto God: Oh when a soul is dressed in all these ornaments,
the Lillies of the field, nor Solomon
in all his glory, is not like it: As therefore the master invited his guests,
[Page 136] saying,
Come for all things are ready, is it likewise true of thee concerning thy fitness, I come Lord, for all is ready, my soul is put in order, the heart is furnished to receive Christ. And if the godly soul say, oh this is that which troubleth me; I am so disordered, my heart is untuned, this disquiets me, that distracts me, my heart is in an uproar, no fitness is there to entertain Christ. To such an humbled soul I say, Because these things are a burden to thee, thou desirest these mountains might be levelled, and these valleys raised; therefore
[Page 137] thy soul is in some preparedness and fitness, though not so much as thou wouldst be: the more empty and lowly in thy own eyes, the more welcome to Christ: Besides as these make thee in some sort fit to come, so they put thee in a necessity of coming. Eat of this honey, that thy eyes may be inlightned; draw nigh to this Ordinance that thou mayest have more of Christ, and his graces: the more thou keepst from this pool, as it were, the less healing thou canst expect. Among many things that may be said to convince and incourage
[Page 138] such a tempted person, I would chiefly propound this, Thou art afraid to come to the Sacrament; Art thou also afraid to come to Christ? Darest thou not lay hold on a promise, what! all the while thou k
[...]epest from a Sacrament, wouldst thou also keep from Christ, and the Promise? Surely thou wilt return a negative to this; but consider, those that may come to Christ, may come to Sacraments; those that may by Faith lay hold on him, may also draw nigh to this Feast: As Christ saith,
Come unto me, all ye that are heavy laden, and I will ease you:
[Page 139] Thus doth the Sacrament, as it were speak, Come unto me ye burdened sinners, and Christ in the use of his means will give rest to you; thou art greatly deceived, if thou thinkest thou mayest lay hold on a promise, and not come to the Sacrament at that time; for a Promise and a Sacrament are the same things; the Sacrament is nothing but a visible promise, appointed by God to assure thee of his love, and to be an help against thy infirmities: It is true in some cases of relapses and repentings of them, there the party though believing in
[Page 140] Christ is yet to abstain that he may give satisfaction to the Church, because it is not only a Sacrament of Communion with Christ, but also with one another; here he may believe, and lay hold on the Promise, when yet in respect of Christs order, he is to forbear the Sacrament; but this publike satisfaction, is not to be delayed, he is to take his first opportunity, and then the Church is bound
[...],
2 Cor. 2.8. to confirm her love to him. Therefore
Calvin doth well reprove some ancient Canons about Church Discipline of too much severity, when
[Page 141] persons offending were to be kept, some two, some three years, from the Lords Supper, though they did publikly humble themselves.
In the next place from a Judgement of discussion, we are to go to a Judgement of
condemnation; for upon winnowing of thy self, thou canst not but finde much chaff: by searching into thy self, much corruption will appear, and when this is found out, thou art to pass a sentence upon it: O Lord, I judge my self for this folly, this lust, I am ashamed of my self, I dare not in my own name draw
[Page 142] nigh unto thee: especially let the Communicant condemn himself in these things: first, all his former prophane, ignorant, and irreverent approaches to this Table. Oh let thy heart tremble, to think with what security, and joll
[...]ty thou didst draw nigh to this Ordinance, being full of ignorance, not able to discern of the duty in hand; full of prophaneness, coming in thy sins, and going away in thy sins. It is a speech of
Chrysostom, That a man had better never have received the Sacrament in all his life, then to have taken it once unworthily:
[Page 143] Therefore bewail thy self, think how many times thou hast made thy self guilty of the
body and blood of Christ: Such sins God hath not forgotten, tho thou mayst have forgotten them. Happily the
Corinthians did not think that it was for this sinne God did so greatly afflict them: and how little do people lay to heart their former Sacrament-sinnes, whereas horror should take hold on thee, as often as thou doest remember, with what boldness and prophanesse thou didst come to these dreadfull mysteries. 2. Judge and condemn thy self for thy
[Page 144] failing in all those duties thou wast obliged too by this Ordinance. If thou receivest these Ordinances, and art as proud, as carnal, as sensual, there is no more quickened obedience in thee, thou doest not live a more heavenly and spiritual life after this heavenly food: Know here is also matter of condemnation: The life of Christ should appear in him, who hath received Christ; As a man coming from an Apothecaries shop, carrieth about him some of the sweet smell there. The Jews would not taste any thing after the Paschal Lamb, that the taste
[Page 145] might be long in their mouths. If you see one live upon excellent fare, yet as faint, and as diseased as before; this argueth some vitiated principle within; were there a true principle, thou wouldst finde this Ordinance to be such strength to thy soul, as
Elias food was to his body. But thou wilt say, because I am conscious to my self of my sinfull wayes, and I cannot get out of these snares, therefore I will never come to this Ordinance. To this I answer, this wil not serve thy turn, for then thou bringest thy self into a perplexed necessity
[Page 146] of sinning, if thou comest to a Sacrament with these lusts upon thee, thou eatest thy damnation, and because thou do
[...]st wilfully live in a state unfit for a Sacrament, thou indangerest thy damnation also; therefore thou hast no way to take but to reform, to repent and to be made partaker of it. This I speak to warn all such as live in a wilfull incapacity and unfitnesse for a Sacrament, they will not receive, because daily fal ing into such sins; but wo unto thee that thou doest thus wilfully indispose thy self; how doest thou obey that command,
[Page 147]
Do this in remembrance of me? How greatly doest thou contemn Christ and his benefits, with the seal thereof; therefore lay this to heart & tremble. Thou that livest in a wilfull unfitnesse to come to a Sacrament, thou art no waies fit to die, no waies fit for heaven, and darest thou continue in such a life, when if death cometh, thou art sure to fall into hell: Meditate on this, Am I not fit for a Sacrament, how then am I fit to die! Cannot I meet Christ in an Ordinance, and can I meet him as a Judge? and so if no fitnesse for a Sacrament, no
[Page 148] fitnesse for heaven:
Without are dogs; this is true, both concerning heaven, and the Church.