A Messe of Pottage well seasoned and crummed, With bread of life, and easie to be
digested. Against the contumelious Slanderers of Divine-Service, terming it Porrage.
wherunto is added an Answer to lame Giles Calfines Messe of Pottage, which he terms in his halting speech to be well crummed and seasoned,
&c.
In which small Tract you shall finde such reasons given against it, as are unanswerable
by any man whatsoever.
I Need not make an Apologie to the ensuing Discourse, it is well knowne to all honest and discreet Protestants, how basely our Service-Book is termed (by the name of Porrage, a name very frequent in uncivill mouths) and trampled under foot by unreasonable men, that have neither Faith nor Charitie; and although they bee now well fed to the full, and may goe from one Church to another to please their pallat, and taste of what pleaseth them best yet there may a time come (which I pray God there doe not) that they may be glad of the crums which fall from their Masters Table: but let them alone a while, the thing that I say is this, That our Common Prayer is so abhorred, depraved, detested, and despised by many, as if it were the most vilest thing in the world; nay, if the Devill himselfe had composed it, it could not be more vilified than it is: It is a shame to speak, and I blush to heare it, that men that think themselves such rare Divines, that people that think they have such knowledge and zeale, to terme such a good thing, and such holy matter as there is, to be Porrage: oh fie! where is your judgement? where is your moderation? what, quite lost? is this your zeale turned to hate? you are surely of an hot and fierie spirit, contrary to the name of warme and wholesome Porrage; if you knew but the right vertue of Pottage, you would not have termed the Common Prayer so, but your owne Prayers: For doe yee not know, That they were godly men that made them, they were not made ex tempore, but with deliberation, not hand over head, as many doe in these dayes, but seriously considered of, and premeditated: and doe you not know, That these good men laid down [Page] their lives for this and the Truth? and doe yee not know, That they were established and maintained by Acts of Parliament? in the raigne of three Kings and one Queene, and is it now made a laughing stock; surely you should have more manners than so.
Indeed, it is Parliament time, and men speake and do what they list now, and so do yee: for yee speak evill of Kings, of authoritie and dignitie, and despise government, contrary to the Apostles rule. Oh the great malice that is one against another! against Peere and Peasant, against Priest and People; oh envie, thou limb of the Devill! how rulest thou in the hearts of people, especially against Bishops; oh how odious is that name to many! but I counsell you to speake moderately, and judge charitably; if they bee stained, let them be pained: they have faults as well as wee, yet they are Gods Embassadours, his Stewards, his Angels, Disposers of Gods secrets, Disbursers of his treasuries, then revile them not, for it is written, Thou shalt not speake evill of the Ruler of the people.
But as for that which you call Porrage, who hatcht the name I know not, neither is it worth the enquiring after, nor the worse for that name, nor none the worse that useth it; for I hold Porrage good food, it is better to a sick man than meat; for a sick man will sooner eat Pottage than meat: Pottage will digest with him, when meat will not: Pottage will nourish the bloud, fils the veines, runs into every part of man, and make him warmer; so will these prayers do, and work more effectually, set the body and soule in a heat, warme our devotion, works fervencie in us, lifts up our soule to God. And many things more it worketh in us; if we had but appetite to them, and it is well stored with herbs out of Gods garden, here a little, and there a little, as appears in the beginning of the Common Prayer, and so forward to the end of it. For there is the herbs of Gods owne planting (in our Pottage, as you call it) the ten Commandements, daintie herbs to season any Pottage in the world; then there is our Saviours forme of Prayer, and that is a most sweet pot-herb, cannot be denied; then there is also Davids herb, his Prayers and Psalmes, help to make our Pottage rellish well; then S. Pauls precepts; also the Creed, a very faithfull pot-herb; and the Song of the blessed Virgin, a good pot-herb; so that this Porrage hath abundance of choyce herbs to season it, and those that will eat no such Porrage as these, so well drest, it is pitie but they should fast, and as the proverb is, Those that will eat no porrage must eat no meat. Though they be (as some terme them) Cock-crowed Pottag, yet they are as sweet, as good, as daintie, and as fresh as they were at first: The Sun hath not made them sowre with his heat, neither hath the cold winter taken away their vigour and strength, but they are as wholesome and as well rellished as at the first, and unlesse you be sick for novelties, you cannot eat better than these. Compare them with the Scriptures, and see if they be not as well seasoned and crummed: if you find any [Page] thing in them, that is either too salt, or too fresh; too bitter, or too sower, too little, or too great; that herb shall be taken out, and a better put in if it can be got, or none at all: And as in Kitchin porrage there is many good herbes in it: so there is likewise in this Church Porrage, (as you call it.)
For first in Kitching porrage, is good water to make them so; on the contrary, in the other porrage is the water of life. 2. There is salt to season them: In the other is a prayer for grace to season our hearts. 3. There is Oatmeale to nourish the body: in the other, is the words of him that is the bread of life, which nourisheth our soules and bodies to eternall life. 4. There is Thyme in them to relish them, and it is very wholsome: In the other is a wholsome exhortation, not to harden our hearts whilest it is called today: this relisheth well. 5: There is a small Onion to give a taste: In the other is a good herbe called Lord have mercie upon us, which gives a sweet taste to the soule. 6. There is Rosemary to comfort and refresh the body: In the other is comfortable words of Christ: Come unto me all ye that are heavy laden, and I will refresh your soules. 7. There is Marie-gold leaves, to revive the spirits: And so in the other, there is the soules magnifying the Lord, and the spirits rejoycing in God our Saviour. These and many wholsome herbes are contained in it, and all these boyling in the heart of man, will make as good porrage as the world can afford, especially if you use the herbes following for digestion, viz. The herbe repentance, the herbe grace, the herbe faith, the herbe hope, the herbe love, the herbe good workes, the herbe piety, the herbe zeale, the herbe fervency, the herbe ardency, the herbe vigilancy, and the herbe constancy; with many more of this nature, which are most excellent for digestion. And those that despise this porrage of ours have no appetite to the Lords Prayer the ten Commandements, the Psalmes of David, and other good matter that is in them, this being contained in the Common Prayer, must be despised also: but me thinks I heare some say, they despise not those. What is it then I pray that you dislike in this porrage? O sir I know your meaning by your gaping, this sticks in your teeth, and spoyles your stomack. 1 There is, (you say) too much of the Surplice, which smelleth of the garment of the whore. 2. There is too much crossing in Baptisme, and that smells (you say) of the marke of the Beast, (but of what beast I wot not.) 3. There is too much bowing and that tastes of Idolatry. 4. There is too much ring in Matrimony, and this smells of superstition. 5. Too much kneeling at the Sacrament this tasts of Antichrist. 6. Too much standing up this smells of vaine glory. 7. Too much Glory be to the Father, and this is superstitious. 8. There is too much Lord have mercy on us, and this is needlesse. 9. Too much Lords Prayer, and this is odious in every ones mouth. 10. There bee too many prayers, and they savour not of the spirit. And what of all these, doe they savour so strong in your nose, that you dare not peep into the Church? Then I may say, you savour of an ill smell, and are very absurd, and you have got a great cold in your feet, and it is fumed up into your head, and so stuffes your braine, that you cannot smell any [Page] thing at all, and carrion is as good to your scent, as good & wholsom porrage is. That which you hold to be the worst, (as namely crossing, bowing, surplice, kneeling, &c. is not worth the speaking and he is a mad man that believes there is salvation in them, and so of necessity we must use them: no, they may be left at any time, when authority shall command: they are ordered but for decency sake, and as neare to the Primitive times as could be gathered; and if we have no order in our Churches, we shall be a reproach to all people. If wee should bee of that minde as the fashion is, or many people are, we then must have a new forme of prayer every yeare, so that you would have something, but know not what: so that you are not content full nor fasting, neither with porrage, nor without.
If Pottage had not beene good food, Iacob would have made none, neither would the Angel of the Lord have carryed Abbacuc by the haire of the head, to Daniel in the Lyons Den, that hee might eate the Pottage which Abbacuc had prepared for the Reapers. Ile warrant you Daniel was glad of them, he went not behinde the doore to eate them, as many in our dayes to stand at the Church doore till the Service is done, and then come and eate the bread out of others mouthes: but believe it theres no death in this pottage, in this Common-prayer, though many have preached, and said there is, and that it is meere popery. If this be the opinion of Round-heads, then it is no marvaile we are so subject to change: for marke it alwayes, that that which is round is soonest moved, and never constant, neither in manner, fashion, or place: their wit is like quick-silver in a foot-ball, alwayes running, so nothing can stay their humour. Therefore I counsell you to doe as Esau Iacobs brother did, who sold his Birth-right for a Messe of pottage, so would I have you to doe, to sell your selfe-opinions for this Pottage; I do not meane that you should your chiefest Birth-right, The Word of God, that unto which you are borne, and must dye for; not to sell this for Ceremonie, not to sell the substance for a shadow, but despise the bare conceite of it: and I dare warrant you that the using of this which you call Porrage, will never prove your bane, neither shal you commit any sinne in the least degree, provided, that you use them to no other end, then they were ordered unto, and that is as St. Paul speaks concerning the World, to use it, as not abusing it; for the fashion of the World passeth away, to such end we may use them and not abuse them knowing that it is in the power of the King and Parliament, to alter and change them when they please, if in case they be corrupted.
AN Answer to lame Giles Calfines Messe of Pottage, which hee tearmes in his halting speech to bee well crummed and seasoned, &c.
WHereas it seems to some lame in reason and blind in judgement, a great indignity to call the Service-Booke Porrage, by a Metaphore and similitude which will very well hold, considering the fat Cookes that first composed it out of the Popes Kitchin, and have put thereinto weeds of Idolatry, thickned with many tautologies and repetitions; yet because Similitudo currit quatnor pedibus, Similitudes are more cleare to illustrate than strong, to prove, it shall be here demonstrated that the Service-Booke is corrupted and unlawfull, and first from the name, then from the nature: for that which is called the Liturgie is the same with the Masse, and so promiscuously called by the Papists Jesuites; and is onely but an English Masse, as theirs is in Latine. Now it is knowne, that [...], names are the very images of things, so that this Liturgie is either a Lethargie of worship, or a Masse of Idolatry: it is therefore the Popes porrage, and his Idoll of Ignorance, and we are not to offer to an Idoll: Ergo, We are not to offer it to God as a worship.
But that you may take a view of this Crambe recocta this twick-s [...]d pottage, marke the ingredients thereof, and whereof it is made, and you shall finde therein no purity, but all papistrie; the common prayers taken out of the popish Breviarie, out of the Papists Rituall is deduced the Administration of the Sacraments, Buriall, Matrimony, and Visitation of the sicke, and then the Consecration [Page] of the Lords Supper, Collects, Epistles and Gospels are taken out of the Masse-booke; and besides, in all the essentiall and integrall parts thereof it is omoregenous with the Masse▪ and therefore being taken and translated word for word out of the popish Masse, it is not a booke of Divine Service and worship, but an abhomination to God, and therefore to be abolished, which may be proved out of these places of Scripture, Deut. 7. 25. 2 King. 23. 13. Ezra 9. 1. and Esa. 44. 19. Thus you see it is not taken out of the garden of godlinesse, nor composed of pure wholsome herbs as some ignorant Cooks would pretend, but the old profane pot-herbs of papistrie. Now you shall next discerne the matter of this porrage, which is false and erroneous in the corrupt Translations of the Word; as first, Psal. 105. 28. the booke hath it thus, They were not obedient to his word; but the Scripture faith, They were not disobedient, to his word. Another place is, Luke 10 1. After these things the Lord appointed other seventy also, and sent them two and two before them: but the Service-booke reads seventy two. Besides, there are many omissions, as of Hallelujah in the 72. Psal. and for, Praise the Lord, seventeene times omitted, the Booke putteth in, Gloria Patri▪ drowning also 160. Chapters, and in stead thereof have placed the Apocrypha. Besides, in reading the Scriptures they take but scraps and shreds▪ And thirdly, much superstitious action in reading the Epistles and Gospels.
Having thus proceeded against the Service-booke in these accusations, of false Translations additions omissions, and mis-nominations, there are other faults in this booke committed by mis-application of Scriptures, by coyning things, and by popish expositions, and by pressing upon Ministers and people an heap of popish Ceremonies and Tenents, as the prayer at the buriall of the dead, Crosses and Surplices, and bowing and cringing to the Altar, and Christning Font, all which being mans invention, must needs be Idolatrous: for, Quicquid praeter mandatum est Idolum, Whatsoever is placed in Gods worship without the Commandement of God, is an Idoll: besides, there are foppish foolish things in the book, as tautologies and battologies. vaine repetitions of words, and that mutuall salutation between Priest and people, in these words, The Lord bee with you and with your spirit▪ and W [...]men at the comming into the Church making a curtesie to the Priest: besides all this there is a Letany, which is not a stump or limb of Dagon, but the head of the Masse-booke, in which there is nothing but vaine repetition, and a multitude of words, as Lord deliver us, Heare us wee beseech thee, and ridiculous Invocations like Magick spels, and no better than conjuring. And therefore if the matter of the Service-Booke be partly false, foolish, ridiculous, and frivolous, therefore the worship therein contained should notbe presented unto God.
Now as for forme, which is the essence of a thing, it is nothing but unformed heap of disorder, and will-worship, the Minister using a strange and ridiculous change of voyce, posture and place; and then many short Collects, of [...]ort shrods patched up together, to make a wearisome service upon the long last, and much tossing or driving the Service between the Priest and the people, praying with the Priest or repeating his prayer, and adding som responses and answers.
Thus the name, originall, matter and manner of the Service booke, hath been shewed to be naught, and corrupt, therefore not to be suffered, but abolished, which hath been proved by nominal and real Arguments, and now it shall bee also clearely evinced from the proper and necessary bad effects thereof, and the evill cau [...] is worse then the effect. Nam propter quod aliquid tale, &c. is a position in Logick and Philosophy: and these evill effects are foure, first it maketh a number of Sir Iohns, meere Surplice and Serv [...]ce-book men: also many non-residents and plurallists, who take choyse of Curates to serve their cures at a cheape rate; besides it was a great affliction to Conformists, and non-Conformists, so that the Service-book was in some sort like the Metheg Ama [...]h, the bridle of the belly tract, or strength of the Philistims; so this Service-booke was the strength of the Philistim prelacy; and a bridle with a cur [...]ing bit to stop, to winde and turne them at their pleasure; and some about this Service-booke were committed to the Egyptian bondage.
In the second place, this Service-book brooked up all preaching, Doctor Houson affirming that preaching was no part of Divine worship; and thus Christs Word gave place to a fardell of mens devices: besides the Service-booke entrenches upon [...], the people, Religion, and Law, and especially upon the Law by imprisoning and exercising jurisdiction in rebus non spiritualibus, in matters that were not spirituall, and then good people suffered in this furnace, in spoyling their goods, losse of liberty, and forsaking their owne Countrey, Gen [...] patriae plangente, as Lipsius saith, the Genius of their Countrey lamenting after them, or else laid in prison til their bones rotted, as Doctor Abbot said M. Baits should be, who was afterwards starved in the Gatehouse. And thus the furnace (for not adoring the Service booke, as Nebuchadnezzar for not adoring his Idoll) was ordinarily heated, and devoured many that were cast into it, and all opposition in that kinde was punished with cutting, branding, slitting, whipping, pilloring, and fining. Then for bad people, if ignorance be the mother of destruction, then much guilt lyeth in many plac [...] of the Service-booke, having in some parishes not had a Sermon in many yeares: and in other places Sermons that [Page] were only. Husks, and no bread to feed upon, and all this proceeding from divers places of the Liturgie and Service-booke, wherewith the Common people and Priests of Ignorance were enforced to be content.
The l [...]st evill effect of this Service-booke is directly and immediately against God. Calvin in his Letter to Frankeford calleth it, the leavings of the popish dregs: and the Frankford book calleth them burthens, yoaks, and clogs to Gods people and his Service: this derogation from Gods Service is their festivall dayes to Saints, and their kneeling at the Communion, for non: but God can appoint an holy-day, and for kneeling at the Sacrament it is a popish, moderne posture of but 400. yeers standing, and is meer wil-worship; for denying of which some have extreamely suffered: and in regard this kneeling is a kneeling in respect and adoration by or before a creature, it is Idolatry, and likewise there be many strong arguments urged against the Crosse, to prove it the marke of the Beast. Lastly, the intercession of the Saints must be according to the will of God, otherwise he heareth not: but the prayers of the Service Booke are not such, but delinquent and peccant, both in name, originall, matter, form, effects, properly proceeding therefrom, therefore they have no acceptance before God, they shall not by him be heard: and therefore are profanely and superstitiously u [...]ed, and being grosse papistry, may be called the Popes pottage, made of divers weeds instend of Herbs, preposterously served up by the Priest, unwholsome for the soule, and displeasing to God, as being mans Cookery, full of absurdity, contrary to Gods glory.
Thus lame Gyles Calfine, I hope I have satisfied you in your halting Laodicean opinion: for whereas you say it is the true bread of life, I do think you are mistaken, and that you were an hungry and wanted your breakfast at that time: and whereas you say they are well seasoned, you are mistaken also, unlesse you hed put some flesh into your pot, or at least wise the foure first letters of your name; which if you had done, they would have been somewhat better crummed and seasoned. So in fine, good Gyles Calfine, hopping to an end, He leave you in the middest of your pottage; and (such Stuffe); and for my part I will put off my doublet, and will swim to the meate, which is fitting for men, and not for such children as you are who are ignorantly brought up, and still are as innocent in matters of Exposition, as alyour generation was in matter of state-affaires. And so much for this time.