To the Right Worshipfull M. George Speke Esquier, H. T▪ wisheth this worlds blisse, and in the world to come, the life that is Christ Iesus.
SAint Paule (right Worshipfull) the elect and chosen vessell of God, Acts. 9. to beare his name a farre off, before the Gentiles, among his sundrie, and godlie counsels, hath this good lesson also: 1. Tim. 4. Ineptas & aniles fabulas deuita: exerce autem te ipsum ad pietatem: Auoid foolish and old wiues fables, and exercise thy selfe vnto godlines. Wherin is plainelie set downe vnto vs, what we must auoid, refuse, and eschue, and also what we must follow, imbrace, and exercise. In the first part of his counsell, there is forbidden not onelie all [Page] [Page] [...] [Page] foolish tales, vaine speaches, & idle talke, which is accomptable before God: Matth. 12. but also all infamous papers and bookes, filthie songs and sonnets, vnchast fables & tragedies, which may be well comprised therein: though some of late yeares are found so impudent, and past shame, that they haue nothing doubted to entitle their pamphlets, the Castell of loue, and Court of venus, which doo not onelie offend the chast eares of the godlie reader, but also giue an offense to his good conscience. Bicause they be not to the mind of the holie Apostle, which teacheth vs thus: Ephes. 4. Omnis sermo malus ex ore vestro non procedat: Let no filthie communication proceede out of your mouths, but that which is good to edifie withall, as often as need is, that it may minister grace vnto the hearers. But what edifieng, & what ministring of grace is found and had in these & the like works, the Lord knoweth that it is too too pitious and lamentable. And in the second clause of his counsell is conteined the onlie scope & end whervnto all mens actions & deeds ought to [Page] be directed; namelie, that they should exercise themselues vnto godlines all their life long, as they promise in their new birth, wrought by doctrine in the holie Ghost and faith at Baptisme, Iohn. 3. Coloss. 2. which representeth in vs the renewing of the spirit, & mortifieng our members in Christ, by the which we are buried in death with him. And right blessed is he verelie, that so walketh in godlie exercises in the course of his pilgrimage, Psal. 119. Psalm. 41. that in the end he may be found vndefiled in the waie, and not haue his sinnes imputed vnto him. For the Lord shall deliuer all such in the time of trouble. This considered, and mine office remembred, I was the more willing to deale (as I could) in these scripture questions and chalenges; which ended, dutie commanded me to offer the same vnto your tuition, as a manifest token of good will, knowing that you are a zelous louer of Gods holie word, a diligent reader, and a gladsome folower of the same, euen from your childhood, when you were deliuered to my gouernment, to be instructed in good literature, [Page] and induced to vertue. And experience hath taught me, that your courtesies are such, that you allow of euerie mans good meaning (though far your inferiours) with fauourable acceptance. The Lord therfore euer so preserue your Worship, 1. Thess. 5. that in nothing you may be blamed, or accused in the comming of our Lord Iesus Christ, 2. Thess. 1. when he shall shew him selfe from heauen, with the Angels of his power, and flaming fier.
To the vnlatined Reader.
GEntle reader, he that required these answers of me, was by function and office such a one, as had vowed and promised the promoting of Gods truth and gospell. But when thou hast perused the summe, the circumstance therof (I doubt me) will proue the old said sawe to be true: Cauda de vulpe testatur: That the foxe is knowne by his taile. Yet the Lord forbid, that we should rashlie iudge of anie man, seeing that God hath ordeined one to be the iudge of the quicke and the dead, the good and the euill, Actes. 10. Rom. 12. Iohn. 8. to whom it is giuen to giue iudgement. And as they were at diuerse times proponed in writing: so they were at diuerse times of leasure againe answered and rescribed, without obseruing anie good order of a catechisme. Therfore thou must not looke to find anie such method, or obseruation of an orderlie teaching herein. It was done (happilie) to appose him, which had beene much practised in the schoole of humanitie, but latelie (in comparison thereof) [Page] [...] [Page] [...] [Page] called to the studie of diuinitie. Wherby he was driuen to the more diligent turning, and search of scripture bookes, least he should haue appeared in his answers Asinus ad lyram positus, as sit therevnto, as an asse is to plaie on the harpe: or else to haue said nothing, but laid his finger on his lip, as Harpocrates vsed, when he would haue silence. For as long as a foole is silent, he differeth not among strangers, from the wise. And as it is easier for malignant Momus, to find a fault somtimes, than to mend it: so is it easier alwaies to aske an hard question of anie man, than to answer it discreetlie according to the truth. And for that the whole consisteth in questions, answers, and syllogisticall obiections, dialogwise, I haue imagined Falsiloquus, which is a speaker of falsehood, to demand, and obiect: and Veriloquus a speaker of the truth, to answer him againe. The Lord giue vs his truth and peace, Iohn. 14. which giueth not his peace, as the world giueth peace. It was not ment at the first that this should haue come vnto thine hands, but now, if thou gentlie accept of it (such as it is) I am sufficientlie acquited and recompensed.
Ad candidum lectorem libelli Prosopopoeia.
The Confutation of Follie.
FIrst tell me (freend Veriloquus) what opinion ought men to haue of the holie Trinitie?
THe same which the Church holdeth and alloweth of, that there is one, true, liuing and eternall God, Iohn. 4. Iohn 1. 1. Tim. 6. 2. Cor. 13. Ioh. 1.4.6. Sap. 11. the which is without bodie, partes and passions, bicause he is a spirit, whom neuer anie man yet saw neither can sée, nor know, but Christ; for he can not be séene with carnall eies, and he is the God of peace and loue, louing all, and hating nothing that he hath made: he is of infinite power, wisdome, goodnes, and mercie, the creatour, preseruer, and nourisher of all things, visible and inuisible, which deliuereth vs from euill. Esai. 43. Iohn. 3. Rom. 5. And in the vnitie of this same diuine nature, there are thrée distinct persons, of the like power, essence, wisdome, glorie, and eternitie, that is to saie, the Father, the Sonne, and the Holie-ghost, which are the blessed Trinitie.
And the sonne of God, [...] patris, Iohn. 1. the word of the father, is the second person in this Trinitie, the true, euerlasting, glorious, and omnipotent [Page 2] God, 2. Cor. 4. Col. 1. begotten before all worlds of his eternall father, and is his verie image, being of like substance togither with him: Col. 2. in whome are the treasures of wisdome, and of knowledge, and fulnes of diuine power. He tooke vpon him, in the wombe of the blessed virgin Marie humane nature of hir substance, and was borne in the world: in somuch that there is conioined fullie and perfectlie in the vnitie of person, a double nature neuer to be separated, that is the nature of God and of man, wherof is made one Christ, perfect God, and perfect man (sinne onlie excepted) who suffered vnder Pontius Pilate, 1. Tim 2. 1. Ioh. 2.4. Eph. 3. Rom. 5.8. Act. 2. and became the mediator betwéene God and man, that in him onlie should be found the sufficiencie of remission of all sinnes, both originall and actuall, for all them that euer were, or shalbe vpon the face of the earth. And the Holie-ghost is the third person in this Trinitie, which procéedeth from the father and the sonne, and is the holie and diuine power, 1. Rom. 10 whereby mens harts are renewed from heauen, he is of like essence, power, glorie and maiestie, with the father, and the sonne, with whome he is coequall, coeternall, and God euerlasting, by whome we comprehend the things of God, for he giueth witnesse to our harts, 1. Iohn. 2. that we are of God, by [Page 3] the which also, Rom. 1. Gal. 5. 1. Pet. 2. we call vpon the father with confidence & faith to be saued by Christ, which is the bishop of our soules.
God made all things, and without him was made nothing, that was made, Iohn. 1. Wisd. 1.
But God made not death, sin, nor the diuell,
Therefore God made not all things.
The fallacie lieth in the consequent which must be denied. Almightie God, that is all wisdome, infinit power and goodnes, created all things in such excellent goodnes, that it is said: Valde sunt bona, Gen. 1. They were all passing good, and God saw that they were good; then he blessed them, and his sentence is not to be reuoked, bicause he being without bodie, parts and passions, cannot repent. And as the diuell was not euer a diuell from the beginning (for the Apostle saith Angeli qui non seruarunt originem suam: Iude. The Angels which kept not there first estate) so he was created, and that an Angell of light, and not a diuell. Colos. 3. For God being most perfectly good, could not consent to make anie thing but that, which was good, and his owne pride made himselfe a diuell, the author of sinne, the heire of eternall fier. Matt. 25. Then he tempting our first parents, by the apple of disobedience, made them likewise so sinfull, that by Adam we are all sinners, Rom. 5. of whome we [Page 4] haue the inclination to doo euill, and then consequentlie followed death, and was engendred of our said parents déeds, as the onelie fruite of their lewd & stubborne disobedience, which they learned of Sathans disobedience: Sic diaboli inuidia, Wisd. 2. mors intrauit in mundum: So by the enuie of the diuell, death entred into the world. Rom. 6. And S. Paule saith: Stipendium peccati mors est: Death is the reward of sinne, which still increased, and wickednes multiplied, by the reason men were tempted, drawne awaie and entised of their owne concupiscence; Iacob. 1. then lust conceiued and brought foorth sinne, and sin, when it was finished, brought foorth death. So that then God tooke vnto him death, for the punishment of sinne, that therewith he might correct the wicked, teaching them that transgressors might not lawfullie sin without punishment. So it is said in another place: Ignis, Eccle. 39. grando, fames, & mors, omnia haec creata sunt ad vindictam: Fier, haile, hunger and death, all these are created for vengeance; that is to saie, after the fall of man, God appointed and exercised all these things for the punishment of the wicked, wherby he tooke vengeance of his enimies, Rom. 1. and dooth vse them as an instrument to strike the wicked withall: and oftentimes dooth punish one sinne with another. Thus we [Page 5] doo now see, Iaco. 1.17. that Omne donum bonum ac perfectum à patre luminum: Euerie good and perfect gift commeth downe from the father of lights, and that he made not death, sinne, nor the diuell in his diuelishnes, from the beginning; Wisd. 1. for he is not delighted in Perditione viuorum, in the destruction of the liuing, nor can be the author of anie damnation, though his wrath and iustice powreth downe his plagues vpon the children of disobedience and vnbeléefe dailie, Esaie. 5. bicause they drawe sinne vnto them, as it were with a cart rope, according to the prophets saieng.
How much shall adulterie be punished by the censure of Gods holie word?
Adulterie (which is the violation and breach of the faith promised in mariage) a thing odious and forbidden of God, Exod. 20. Leui. 18. Deut. 5. is so gréeuouslie punished of him, that all adulterers shall (without they doo truelie repent) bée cast awaie into vtter darkenes, 1. Corin. 6. Hebru. 13. Ierem. 8. which is without the kingdome of God. And if men doo not punish adulterers, God himselfe will surelie punish them. 2. Reg. 12. As we haue an example of king Dauids sonne, which Vrias wife bare vnto him, whom the Lord so stroke with sicknes, for the adulterie of his father, that it fell sicke and died the seuenth daie after. Mala. 3. Thus the Lord himselfe verelie will be a swift witnes against all [Page 6] adulterers.
Carnall copulation is the ordinarie meanes onelie for mankind to be encreased and multiplied, and to fill the world,
Genesi. 1.God commanded Adam and Eue to encrease and multiplie, and fill the world,
Therefore God commanded carnall copulation.
The inconuenience lieth in the consequent, which ought to be denied. For though the minor be true, that God commanded them to encrease and multiplie, and fill the world: yet he would haue it to be doone by such lawfull meanes, as he himselfe hath ordeined, and not by euill anie other waies. Because he cannot agree vnto sinne, nor allowe thereof in anie case, his commandement in these words was so holie, Genesi. 1. that he blessed them a litle before in the same chapter, for that they should encrease and multiplie, to acknowledge him, and to yéeld him the more honor, which was the finall end of their creation, and must be the scope of all their actions. And then he ordeined the honorable estate of matrimonie, Hebru. 13. Genesi. 2. 1. Thes. 4. and the bed vndefiled shortlie after, that euerie one should knowe how to keepe his vessell in holinesse, which he constituted in such a mysterie and vertue, that man and wife are made thereby [Page 7] one flesh, and so to encrease and multiplie, and to liue togither in the feare of God, Marke. 10. and procreation of children in such a mutuall societie each to other, Matt. 19. that they ought rather to forsake father and mother than to forsake each other. Wherefore, such as commit carnall copulation, contrarie to this ordinance, wresting the sacred scriptures therby to mainteine their sensualitie, doo incur the heauie wrath of God, and haue no part in the kingdome of heauen, as it is written: 1. Cor. 10. Hebru. 13. Fornicatores & adulteros iudicabit Deus: God will iudge fornicators and adulterers, and their children shall not prosper, as it is likewise said: Wisd. 3. Filij adulterorū in consumatione erunt: The children of adulterers shall come to an end. So that they shall not onlie haue anie ioy and comfort of their children, as other parents haue, but they shall be a testimonie of their wickednesse against them, as it is said: Ex iniquis qui nascuntur, testes sunt nequitiae aduersus parentes: All the children that are borne of the wicked, must beare record of the wickednes, against their fathers and mothers. And to conclude: Eccle. 15. Nemini mandauit Dominus impiè agere: The Lord hath commanded no man to doo euill.
Ought christian folkes children to be baptised or no?
Yes verelie: for though parents be themselues baptised before the birth of their children, yet must their children be baptised likewise, séeing that they be conceiued and borne in sinne originall, which liueth in them, as soone as they come into this world. Bicause baptisme (which is a wetting or washing) is so necessarie to followe faith and beléefe, that they two ioined togither, haue the most certeine and sure promise by Christ, Marc. 16. of saluation and eternall life. And it is not the parents holines that can hallowe and sanctifie their children: wherefore we must flie vnto faith, and then baptisme must be had, the outward signe whereof representeth in vs the renewing of the spirit, Rom. 6. Colos. 2. and mortifieng of our members in Christ Iesus (as we are bound to doo) whereby we are buried in death with him. God ordeined baptisme, and it was ministred by S. Iohn the baptist: Iohn. 1. yet it bringeth not grace with it, as it appeareth by Simon Magus the southsaier and sorcerer. Act. 8. But beléefe, mercie, grace, and the Holie-ghost himselfe is receiued before baptisme, as it appeared in S. Paule, which beleeued and then receiued the Holie-ghost, Act. 9. before he was baptised. Cornelius the centurion capteine receiued the Holie-ghost, Act. 10. before he was baptised. And the gelded chamberlaine [Page 9] of Candace the quéene of the Aethiopians beléeued, Act. 8. and therefore had grace before he was baptised. But baptisme is so necessarie, that Christ saith: Iohn. 3. Nisi quis renatus fuerit ex aqua & spiritu, non potest intrare in regnum Dei: Except a man be borne againe of water and of the Holie-ghost, he cannot enter into the kingdome of God.
Christ said: All they which beleeue and are baptised shall be saued,
Theeues and harlots beleeue and are baptised, Marc. 16. New birth is in doctrine by the holie-ghost.
Therefore théeues & harlots shall be saued.
The consequent is false: & the minor may be answered by distinction. There is a double faith and beleefe. The one being grounded on the testimonie of a good conscience, is not onelie the common beleefe of all the articles of our christian faith, but it is also a sure confidence and trust of the mercie of God, through our Lord Iesus Christ, and a stedfast hope of all good things to be receiued at Gods hand, for Christes sake. This faith is a most strong brasen wall against the assaults of the diuell, and is not idle, but alwaies worketh in charitie and loue, still readie to doo our brother good, and seeketh oportunitie thereto, wherefore, it is a liuelie faith, and comprehendeth [Page 10] all the merits and mercies of God, bestowed on mankind, as our creation, redemption, and sanctification. But the other is the faith and beleefe of harlots and diuels; Iacob. 2. Qui credunt & contremiscunt: Which beleeue and tremble, knowing that God is true, and iust, yet haue they no goodnes at all ioined with their faith, but dooing all euill, and nothing well, therefore it is dead in it selfe: whereby it commeth to passe, that their faith and baptisme dooth nothing preuaile, or further them vnto saluation: bicause they haue no desire to continue in that estate of innocencie, and perfection, which they promise at the time of their new birth in baptisme, but they reuolt from God, Iohn. 3. and turne awaie from his mercies. And as Christ died for none, but for such as laie hold on him by a liuelie faith (for his death shall be rather to the death of infidels, than to their life) so the faith and beléefe of hypocrites, théeues, and harlots, which haue an outward shew, and nothing in substance, couered ouer (as it were) with the smooth skinne of words, is nothing worth. For the people of Israel in the old time could saie; Iere. 7. Matt. 7. Templum Domini, templum Domini; The temple of the Lord, the temple of the Lord. And we can saie now a daies, Domine, Domine, Lord, Lord; and hypocrites [Page 11] will so saie to the worlds end. But here is no new obedience to God, nor his word, which is required of the penitent; here is no loue to God nor man, which God commandeth; here is no goodnes towards God, nor man, therefore it nothing auaileth them to their saluation.
How necessarie is inuocation and praier?
So necessarie, 1. Thes. 5. Colos. 4. that S. Paule saith: Sine intermissione orate: Praie without ceasing. And againe: Orationi instate, vigilantes in ea: Continue in praier, and watch in the same, meaning thereby, that in all our actions and attempts, we must still be prest and readie to praie, Luke. 12. séeking after the kingdome of God first before all things in faith. Rom. 10. For he calleth not truelie vpon the name of God, which beleeueth not in him; and without a sure confidence in God, that he is both omnipotent, whereby he is able to doo it, and also mercifull, whereby he is willing to doo it, when it shall seeme good to his infinite wisedome, and that our praier be so made in acknowledging of our sinnes, that it may redound to Gods glorie, to the furtherance of our saluation, and the promoting of his church, else is it but vaine, and lippe labour. Christ praieth for vs, that be [Page 12] his: Iohn. 16.17. Hebr. 7.9. Iohn. 11. Rom. 8. for he knoweth that he is heard of his father. We manie times knowe not what to praie for, but the spirit aideth our infirmitie. And praier is of foure kinds. Deprecation, which is to beg, either to mitigate the punishment due for our sinnes, or else that God will turne awaie his heauie displeasure conceiued for our sinnes. Supplications are requests whereby we craue such things as be necessarie, either for the sustentation of this life, or for the life to come. Intercessions, are praiers made in the behalfe of others. And thanks giuing is when we praise God, and celebrate his name, for all his benefits conferred both vpon our soules, and also vpon our bodies.
1. Cor. 12. S. Paule writeth: No man can saie that Iesus is the Lord but by the Holie-ghost,
Hypocrites, theeues, & harlots, doo saie that Iesus is the Lord,
Therefore hypocrites, theeues, and harlots, haue the Holie-ghost, and by a consequent doo beléeue, and they calling vpon God, doo please him, are heard of him, and so be saued.
I answer by distinction: for Paule speaketh of the true inuocation, according to this saieng: Zachar. 12. Effundam super eos spiritum gratiae & pre [...]m: I will powre out vpon them [Page 13] the spirit of grace & praier. Againe, Rom. 8. Accepistis spiritum adoptionis, per quem clamamus Abba Pater: Ye haue receiued the spirit of adoption, wherby we crie Abba Father. But the counterfeit and false inuocation nothing auaileth at all, which is not doone by the confidence, and in the knowledge of our mediator the sonne of God, but in the trust of their owne merits and worthines, as plainelie it appeareth in the gospell by the talke of the Pharisie. Luc. 18.
What is the gospell of Christ?
It is the glad tidings of the forgiuenes of our sinnes, the gift of grace, and eternall life, freelie by the death and passion of Christ the sonne of God, and our mediator, of the Gréeke word [...]. And it is the power of God to saluation, for all them that beléeue; as S. Paule saith: Rom. 1. Virtus Dei est in salutem omni credenti: by the voice whereof, the church and houshold of God is congregated, and gathered together.
Christ said to his disciples: Marc. 6. Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospell to all creatures,
Beasts are Gods creatures, comprised in the generalitie of all,
Therefore we may preach the gospell to brute beasts.
The consequent much deceiueth: and the minor may be answered by distinction. For God made his creatures of two sorts, namelie reasonable, as men and angels: and vnreasonable, as brute beasts, which though they be Gods creatures, and haue manie senses common togither with man, as their being, moouing, seeing, tasting, hearing, smelling, and féeling; yet they can not in anie case be capeable of the gospell, which is eternall life for all beléeuers, and was ordeined onelie for the comfort of man, that did beare the liuelie image of God, which is most absolute righteousnes, and most perfect holines, vntill man by blots of sinne did marre that image, and hath yet some semblance with God in the eternitie of the soule, consisting of these powers, will, wit and memorie, whereof beasts are depriued, & can neither haue abilitie of reason, of number, or of beléefe. If such cauillers as propound these syllogisticall obiections and quarels, had but a little more wit than beasts, they might vnderstand by these words following, Marc. 16. Qui crediderit, & baptisatus fuerit, saluus erit: He that beléeueth, and is baptised shall be saued, that this later clause cleane taketh awaie this cauill, and expoundeth that which goeth before, and that brute beasts haue no possibilitie [Page 15] of either of these two conditions, as to beleeue or to be baptised. But there are some happilie of the same follie, as I read a learned mistres had, who finding in S. Paules epistles these words: Si vir dormierit, mulier est liberata: 1. Cor. 7. If the husband sleepe, the wife is at libertie, vsed (by the authoritie of these words) licentious and incontinent liuing, when hir husband slept, as well by night as by daie, and being reprooued thereof by the Ordinarie, she alleaged the same scripture, affirming that she had doone nothing, but that which was lawfull and allowable by the testimonie of Gods word. Turne the leafe & read furder (saith the iudge) and you shall see, that by this word (Sleepe) is meant the naturall death. Nay sir (quoth she) turne you, and read you, for I take that which best serueth for my purpose. Thus we see that there be some: Qui deprauant scripturas, 2. Pet. 3. ad suam ipsorum perditionem, which peruert the scriptures vnto there owne destruction. And further, though it be written, that: Fides ex auditu, Rom. 10. auditus autem per verlum Dei: Faith commeth by hearing and hearing by the word of God: Hebr, 4. yet such as heare the word of God, and couple it not with faith, take no more profit thereby than the brute beasts doo by hearing, which haue no proportion of reason in vnderstanding [Page 16] such mysteries. The popes holy power. And the old popish Sancters tooke vpon them to blesse, consecrate, hollow, & sanctifie crosses, wood, mettall, stones, belles and bones, yea (and whatsoeuer ye will) by sprinkling ouer of holie water, crossing, annointing and blessing: yet all these trumperies could take no more holines and goodnes by all their circumstance of charmings, than beasts can by offering them the word of God. For brute beasts haue no hearing with vnderstanding of such matters. Dead and senseles things haue no hearing at all. If they haue no hearing, they haue no faith; if they haue no faith, they haue no goodnes; if they haue no goodnes in them, then sprinkling ouer of water, crossing, annointing, blessing of words, can not make them better than trumperies, as they were before.
When, and how was the Holie-ghost made manifest and knowne?
First, in the work of the creation, where it is said: Gen. 1. Spiritus Domini ferebatur super aquas: The spirit of the Lord was caried vpon the waters, that is to wit, he nourished all the worke that was made, as an hen nourisheth hir chickens, which generall act of the Holie-ghost was after transferred to the Church, which he nourisheth by singular meanes, and [Page 17] defendeth it. Next the holie-ghost spake by the prophets. Thirdlie, he appeered in the likenes of a dooue, at the baptisme of Christ. Fourthlie, Matt. 3. he was manifested to the disciples in the daie of pentecost, in the shape of firie toongs, Act. 2. which patefactions are certeine testimonies that the Holie-ghost is an other person than the father and the sonne.
Christ saith: Iohn. 16. The Holie-ghost shall lead you into all truth,
Therefore Christ taught not his disciples all truth: but the Holie-ghost will reueale some new things, as the masse, traditions, and worshipping of the papisticall church.
I denie the consequent, and answer by distinction: for Christ speaketh of the same veritie which is reuealed in his word, as he saith in another place, Sermo tuus est veritas, Iohn. 17. quam spiritus sanctus illustrabit: Thy word is the truth, which the Holie-ghost shall open. He speaketh not of those things which God hath not opened to his church in his holie word, as to know the time of our deaths, when the daie of iudgement shalbe, or such like, the curious searching out whereof is the rashnes of man, forbidden by this saieng: Scrutator maiestatis opprimetur à gloria: The searcher out of the maiestie of God shall be confounded with his [Page 18] glorie.
What is the certeine note and marke of the presence of the Holie-ghost?
The spirituall or good motions of the hart, as is praier and inuocation, the loue to heare the word of God, and the true imbracing of the same: whereas there are no such motions felt, there the Holie-ghost is not, and such as are without these good féelings are no true members of the church, according to that saieng: Rom. 8. Qui non habet spiritum Christi, non est eius: He that hath not the spirit of Christ, is none of his: 2. Reg. 11. Iohn. 18. except they doo returne to God by repentance and conuersion, as Dauid, Manasses, Peter, and such other did, which receiued againe the Holie-ghost by repentance and faith, that was put awaie from them by their falles, contrarie to their owne conscience.
What is the office of Christ?
First, Christs office is by his preaching to open to vs and his church, his fathers eternall will. Next, to offer him selfe vp a sacrifice to his father, for the redemption of all the world, and to deliuer his vniuersall church from death, sinne, and the tyrannie of the diuell.
Act. 12. Nero killed Paule, Herod killed Iohn and Iames,
[Page 19]Therefore Christ deliuereth not his church, giueth hir no peace, nor victorie against hir enimies.
Christ giueth vs the eternall victorie, which hereafter we shall behold. And now we haue the victorie also, howbeit we can not see it with corporall eies, for the church is preserued, though the diuell rage and horriblie inuade it. God defendeth it maruelouslie, without anie mans power or strength: as the father himselfe saith: Seruabo vos non in arcu, Ose. 1. nec in gladio, sed in Domino Deo vestro: I will not deliuer you through my bowe or sword, but in the Lord your God, that is, in my sonne, which is your Lord and your God. Also God saith in Zacharie: Ego ero igneus murus vester: Zachar. 2. I will be to you a wall of fier round about.
When began the kingdome of Christ in mankind?
The kingdome of Christ, or the presence of the sonne of God, was in mankind streightwaies from the beginning of the making and receiuing of man among the fathers, prophets, and the godlie people of the old Testament, as Irenaeus saith, Semper adest [...] humano generi: The word (that is the sonne of God) was alwaies present with mankind. Also S. Paule saith: Christus hodie & heri, Hebr. 13. & in [Page 20] omnia secula: Christ yesterdaie and to daie, and the same continueth for euer the author of truth and goodnes.
The taking awaie of an other mans thing against the owners will, is theft,
Matth. 21.Christ commanded the asse and hir colt to be brought vnto him, and that against the owners will,
Therefore Christ did not well.
The minor is to be denied, Christ was the superior Lord of this people, although he vsed not that his externall power and right, bicause he came to be made a sacrifice for our sins: yet notwithstanding he had power ouer this people, as he himselfe saith: Dominus hijs opus habet: Matth. 21. The Lord hath néede of them. Againe, he tooke not awaie the asse against the owners will, but with his good will, when the disciples had alleged vnto him the cause of taking hir awaie, declaring their message, which the Lord gaue them in charge to doo.
When shall the kingdome of Christ (which is the collecting of his church) end?
In the last daie, when as the Apostle saith: 1. Cor. 15. Regnum patri suo tradet: He shall deliuer vp the kingdome to his father, ouercomming [Page 21] all his enimies, and his churches, as sin, death, sathan, hell, & all tyrants, for then shall we see the verie sonne of God, which is corporall, & he will bring vs vnto his father, there shall he present his church before his eternall father, then shall we beginne to see and know the father visiblie, whose fruition is eternall life. In the meane season, the kingdome of Christ is named in vs, bicause it dwelleth in vs by his ministerie. And trulie therefore is his word sent vnto vs, for he is called [...], both in respect of vs, and of his father also. And the Apostle here speaketh of Christs kingdome in this world, 1. Cor. 15. whereby he congregateth his church together, and dooth mightilie defend it by his infinite power and mercie without corporall violence.
The minister of the gospell ought not to vse corporall violence,
Christ vsed corporall violence in whipping the biers and fellers out of the temple, Iohn. 2.
Therefore Christ did not well.
This may be answered thrée 1 waies. First, I denie the minor: bicause Christ mooued not sedition, neither vsed corporall violence. Act. 5. But as Peter killed Ananias and Saphira his wife, without corporall violence (yea God him selfe quicklie destroied [Page 22] them) so Christ here saieth: Zelus domus tuae comodit me: Psal. 69. The zeale of thine house hath eaten me, that was a certeine diuine force and indignation, enflamed with the loue and desire of the affirming, and propagation of the honor of God.
2 Secondlie I answer to the minor. As the minister of the gospell ought not vse corporall violence truelie, but in his owne house: so Christ did well in casting out of these chaffering hucsters out of the temple, Iohn. 2. bicause it was his house and his place.
3 Thirdlie, Christ is not onlie a minister of the gospell, but also a king, yet he shewed not himselfe as a king, but vsed the spirit without violence, that he might signifie, that he punisheth all the wicked at the daie of iudgement. And it is also a signification of the daie of iudgement.
Wherefore dooth God take men to grace and mercie, and not the diuels?
Bicause the sinne of the diuels is blasphemie, and the sinne of our first parents was imbecillitie and weakenes. God also sheweth his iustice in the eternall punishment of the diuell, and his mercie in deliuering of man. Matt. 25. And Christ said: Ite in ignem aternum, qui paratus est diabolo & angelis suis: Go [Page 23] into euerlasting fire, which is prepared for the diuell and his angels. Againe, Iude. Seruabit diabolos aeternis vinculis: God will reserue the diuels to euerlasting chaines. Thirdlie the diuell sinned against God wittinglie and willinglie, both in pride and contempt of the sonne of God, whom therefore he contemneth, bicause he cast him awaie to be worse than all creatures; and man sinned by the instigation and deceipt of the diuell. Genesi. 3. And bicause the diuell sinned both of malice, and wittinglie, and hateth the sonne of God our mediatour, with a perpetuall and insatiable hatred, God receiueth him not into fauour. For that the onelie sonne of God is the onelie mediator betwéene God offended, and his creatures offending, which mediatour the diuels persecute and blaspheme, to the vttermost of their power, alwaies labouring to contrarie the immutable will of God.
The will of God is immutable, Prou. 19.
Moses gouernement was appointed by the will of God,
Therefore it is immutable.
I answer to the minor by distinction. The will of God is immutable as he himselfe hath decréed. To the minor, the politike gouernement of Moses was ordeined [Page 24] by the will of God, but so, that it should be abolished againe, when the Messias came, which is the sauiour of mankind, and that by thrée waies; first, by merit; next, by efficacie; and thirdlie, by intercession, when he wrought in the world the mysterie of our redemption, with other his signes, wonders and miracles.
What are miracles?
Miracles are the workes of God, such as creatures, No imitation of Gods miracles. men, and angels cannot imitate. That is to saie, the creation of the world, the stopping of the course of the sunne, the continuall moouing of the celestiall bodies, the raising vp of the dead, and to make the fruitfull barren. And miracles are of two sorts, ordinarie, and inordinarie; ordinarie are the creation, the preseruing, and propagation of mankind; inordinarie, to stop the course of the sunne, to make the fruitfull barren, and to raise vp the dead, which the diuell can in no case imitate and followe. Therefore he dooth alwaies maligne and take an offense against God.
Matt. 18.He that giueth cause of an offense dooth euill,
Christ geue cause of an offense,
Therefore Christ did euill.
I denie the minor; for Christ is [Page 25] no cause of an offense giuen. There is a double offense, one giuen, and an other taken. The offense giuen, is an euill doctrine, or a wicked example of life, whereby others deceiued are made the worse. In Catalogo haereticorum, lib. 2. As Arrius the heretike bishop of Alexandria was the author of a most horrible offense giuen, which affirmed Christ to be a creature onlie, and confounded his Godhead. It is written therefore, that he burst asunder in the middest, and his bowels gushed out. Of which offense it is said, Vae mundo a scandalis: Wo vnto the world, bicause of offenses. And againe: Vae illi per quem scandala fiunt: Matth. 18. Wo vnto the man by whom offenses doo come. The offense taken is, when some are offended in hatred of the true doctrine, as the Bishops, the Pharisies, the Saduces, and the Scribes were with the gospell. Therefore Christ said, Sinite eos, Matth. 23. caeci sunt, & duces caecorum: Let them alone, they are blind, and the guides of the blind.
What is the lawe?
The morall lawe, which is holie, and is established by the gospell (as S. Paule saith) is the eternall, Rom. 7. & immoueable wisedome in God, and the rule of righteousnesse in the will of God, discerning the good from the euill, the which lawe is made manifest to the reasonable nature in his creation, and after oftentimes [Page 26] repeated, and established by the voice of God, shewing in the church, that God is a iudge, binding all naturall creatures, that they shall be conformable to that rule of the commandements of God, declaring his horrible destruction to all them which will not reforme themselues according to that rule, except they haue remission for Christes sake.
Luke. 16.Christ said: The prophets and the lawe reigned to Iohn the baptist,
Matth. 11.Therfore the morall lawe is abrogated, and must no more be preached.
I denie the consequent, and answer to the antecedent by distinction. Christ speaketh of Moses policie, that is, the ceremoniall and iudiciall lawe, and not of the ten commandements, which are the stedfast and perpetuall wisdome, iustice, and will of God, which is immutable: and God will haue all men to obeie his wisedome and iustice, and would haue all men, at all times, to be in their maners and vsage conformable vnto the same, Exod. 20. wherefore he saieth by Moses: Ego sum Dominus Deus tuus: I am the Lord thy God.
What is the peace of God?
It is the tranquillitie of conscience, and ioy, resting and reposing it in God, that he is at peace with vs, by his sonne Christ, [Page 27] of the which peace Christ himselfe speaketh saieng: Pacem meam do vobis, Iohn. 14. pacem meam relinquo vobis: I giue you my peace, I leaue you my peace, which is without all grudge, worme, Marc. 9. or sting of conscience, and without all contrarietie, diuision, or schisme.
It was not lawfull to depart from the temple of Hierusalem, and to make a schisme,
Iohn the baptist departed from the temple, Christian mens ceremonies are spirituall things. 1. Cor. 10. and made a schisme, bicause he taught not in the temple but in the desert, and ordeined a new ceremonie of baptisme, and misliked the sacrifices commanded by God,
Therefore Iohn the baptist did not well.
I denie the consequent, and answer by distinction. There is a double schisme. One is necessarie, which is done by the commandement of God, peculiar vocation and calling. So Iohn the baptist departed from the temple of Hierusalem in which his father Zacharias the préest taught and sacrificed, bicause he was called therevnto by the most excellent and singular commandement of God. The other is schisme rash and vnaduised, hauing no commandement, nor iust cause of reuolting, which is to be denied and vtterlie to be eschued.
Tyndall and Luther had no commandement of God, nor especiall calling,
Therefore they did naught, in separating themselues from the holie father the popes church.
I denie the consequent, bicause that separation or schisme was necessarie and godlie. For either it was a singular calling, as Iohn the baptist departed from the ordinarie power: or else they did it for the vniuersall commandement of God, which bindeth and compelleth all men, that they must depart from the companie which imbraseth wicked doctrine, and false worshippings, according to such commandement as this is: Fuge idola, and Non habebis deos alienos coram me. Exod. 20. Thou shalt haue none other gods but me. This vniuersall commandement is greater, and of more force than a singular calling, therefore all men must willinglie obeie it.
What is the cause that Turkes, Iewes, Infidels, and manie Christians are not partakers of Christs benefits, but are damned?
The cause is, they cannot a [...]e vnto themselues the benefits of the sonne of God by faith, which is the redéemer of all men. Et dedit vitāsuā redemptionē pro multis; 2. Cor. 1. And gaue [Page 29] his life a redemption for manie, 1. Tim. 2. Matt. 20. Exod. 15. and it was prefigured in the deliuering of the children of Israell. But they being reprobates contemne these things, and as it were cast awaie from them, the sonne of God, blaspheming him, as the Turkes, Iewes, and manie others doo, which beare the onelie names and outward shews of Christians, but in their déeds and actions they are woorse than Pharisies, that outwardlie séeme to blesse him with their mouths, and cursse him with their liues and manners. Therefore they are not heard of God, when they aske of him.
Whatsoeuer (saith Christ) ye shall aske the Father in my name, Iohn. 16. he will giue it you,
If I aske a kingdome of him, he will giue it me,
Bicause he is true.
The minor is not true. And distinction may be vsed in answering hereof. For though that God be the author and giuer of euerie good and perfect gift, both spirituall, Iacob. 1. and bodilie, yet he giueth them and bestoweth them on such as pleaseth him, when, where, and in such sort and quantitie as it best séemeth to his good and fatherlie prouidence. So that we must not appoint him either the time, measure, [Page 30] or meane of his gifts: but in all causes whatsoeuer we must tarrie the leasure of the Lord: Qui benedictus est in omnibus vijs suis, Psal. 145. & sanctus in operibus: Which is blessed in all his waies, and holie in all his workes. And as his giftes be in number infinit, in quantitie vnmesurable, and in nature euerie one most excellent good, both spirituall and corporall: so he bestoweth them alwaies vpon his, both spirituallie and corporallie. Spirituallie, for the furniture and beautifieng of the mind and soule of man, as faith, grace, will, wit, memorie, learning, cunning and science. And corporallie, for the endowing and encreasing the outward happines of the bodie of man, as helth, beautie, strength, riches, power and possessions. In all which petitions made for the gifts of God, we must follow the generall rule that our sauiour Christ hath prescribed vnto all flesh: saieng, Primùm quaerite regnum Dei & iustitiam eius, Matth. 6. & adijcientur vobis omnia haec: First séeke ye the kingdome of God and the righteousnes therof, and all these things shall be giuen you; meaning thereby that we shall haue all worldlie things the easier and with lesse trauell. Then we must aske nothing hurtfull to the right of the church, wherby the seruice of God shall be diminished, our neighbour or common wealth impaired, [Page 31] nor anie thing that should be an hinderance to our owne saluation. To aske a kingdome, when we cannot well guide our owne priuate estate, we shall offend God; because we haue not to appoint him the measure of his giftes, happilie hurt the condition of manie, & hazard our owne soules. Therefore we must content our selues with our owne calling, remembring the holie Apostles saieng: 1. Tim. 6. Quastus magnus pietas cum sufficientia: Godlinesse is great riches, if a man be contented with that he hath. For, 1. Cor. 7. Vnusquisque donum suum proprium habet ex Deo: Euerie man hath his proper gift of God, and he dooth sometimes (as it were) bridle and hold backe his seruants from committing sinne and wickednes togither with the world, by the bit and bridle of scarsitie and penurie, knowing (bicause he is the searcher of the hart & reines) that if some might haue their harts desire, and might enioy the fruit of their owne inuentions, they would ignorantlie seeke their owne destruction by excesse. Therefore it is written: Rom. 8. Penuriam multo meliùs feras quàm saturitatem: A man may better awaie with penurie than with saturitie. God that made man knoweth what is in man, and what estate is best for euerie man.
Wherefore doo the philosophers [Page 32] saie, that mans will is cause of his owne miseries?
Bicause men willinglie (though vnwares) procure to themselues manie miseries, as for example. Antonius at Rome willing to wage warre against Augustus, was causer of his owne harmes. 2. Reg. 11. King Dauid, by taking awaie Vrias wife, procured himselfe manie calamities. Thus oftentimes mans wilfull mind is his owne miserie, for that they are snared with pleasures and voluptuous liuing without Gods spirit; as fishes are taken with the bait.
He calleth vpon the true God, which calleth vpon one God maker of heauen and earth, which is almightie, wise, iust, & good,
The Turkes and the present Iewes doo call vpon one God maker of heauen and earth, which is almightie, iust and good,
Therefore they call vpon the true God, and shall be heard.
I denie the minor: because the Turkes doo call vpon their idoll, yea (rather I may saie) they doo call vpon nothing. For they doo not call vpon that God, which is the father of our Lord Iesus Christ, or which is the father, the sonne, and the Holie-ghost, the which God hath manifested or opened himselfe in his [Page 33] word. And because they doo not call vpon God in faith and knowledge of our mediator, they are not heard, for Christ saith: Iohn. 16. Nemo venit ad patrem nisi per me: No man commeth vnto the father but by me. Againe, Iohn. 14. Quicquid petieritis patrem in nomine meo dabit vobis: What so euer ye shall aske the father in my name, he will giue it you. Therefore Turkes and Iewes doo erre from God two waies, in essence & will: wherof, without Christ our mediator, there can be nothing rightlie determined.
What are the true & principall causes of death, and other the calamities of mankind?
There be two causes, the first and principall cause is sin, which Adam committing departed from God, and afterward spred into all men, that is to saie, the infirmitie of our corrupt nature, and inclination to all euill. The second cause is, Rom. 5. the tyrannie of the diuell increasing by Gods wrath, mans miserie & horrible fast, & stirring vp still in mankind, anger, furie, warre, slaughters, murthers, and such like, with all other kind of wickednes.
Had not the old fathers the true worshipping of God, before the politike gouernance of Moses?
Yes verelie: because they had first the morall lawe, or knowledge thereof, wherby they should liue vertuouslie. For God said in paradise: Genesi. 3. Erunt duo in carne vna: They shall be two in one flesh, which saieng forbiddeth all wandring lustes and licentious appetites. Also they had the doctrine of the promises, Genesi. 22. De semine contrituro caput serpentis: Of the séed that should quash the serpents head, wherin all the nations of the earth shall be blessed. Thirdlie, they called vpon the same God, which declared himselfe to his church, in his most certeine word, and by manie excellent testimonies, and that in knowledge and trust of his sonne, the promised redéemer of the world.
Wherefore was the Iewes politike gouernance ordeined, séeing that it should be afterwards abolished?
It was ordeined, because God would haue the place to be certeine, where his sonne should be borne, where he should teach, and shew foorth the testimonies of his doctrine, where he should be crucified and rise againe, and from whence the gospell should be first sent into all the rest of the world, according to the prophets saieng: Psalm. 18. Exiuit sonus eorum in omnem terram; Their sound went out into all the world. Therefore Hierusalem was (as it [Page 35] were) the towre of the church, where the true doctrine was manifested, opened and purged by Christ and his Apostles. But when Christ was exhibited and profered, and the voice of the gospell was published in all the world, then it behooued this politike gouernance to be put awaie and abolished. First, that there might a testimonie remaine, that Christ was offered to all the world, and that the Leuiticall worshipping was not the true and principall worshipping of the eternall & spirituall worshipping of the kingdome of Messias: but the true acknowledging of God and his sonne, inuocation, setting foorth and confessing the heauenlie doctrine, the feare of God, patience in aduersitie, and other spirituall motions agréeing with Gods mind and will. As Christ saith: Iohn. 4. Veri adoratores Deum adorabunt spiritu & veritate: The true worshippers shall worship God in spirit and in truth.
Whether was the sinne of Eue greater in eating the apple forbidden by God, Luke. 2. or the sinne of the virgin Marie, in léesing the child Iesus in Ierusalem?
The sinne of Eue was the greater sinne.
Obiects discerne sinnes according to maius and minus. Obiection is any thing that may be seen before our eies.
[Page 36]The sinne of Marie was greater in obiect, for the child Iesus was the son of God, & better than an apple, as a man excelleth a beast,
Therefore Marie sinned more grieuouslie, in léesing by negligence the child Iesus, which is the sonne of God, than Eue did in eating the apple.
First, the maior may be thus answered. Obiects discerne sinnes, according to maius and minus, but not principallie. And a principall distinction of she causes of good or euill workes must be had, and the mind vnderstanding what they are, and considering the commandement, and then the will obeieng or repugning, chooseth some thing, either contrarie to the commandement of God, or according to his commandement. He therfore that sinneth willinglie and wittinglie, committeth a more grieuous sinne, than he that sinneth by ignorance, Diuersitie of sinne. and common imbecillitie and weaknes. Againe, answer may be made to the minor: Marie sinned ignorantlie and not wittinglie, because she thought that the child Iesus had béene with Ioseph: but Eue sinned willinglie and wittinglie, contrarie to hir conscience, breaking the commandement of God, fréelie choosing the eating of the apple forbidden of God. He that so sinneth, putteth [Page 37] awaie his faith, the Holie-ghost, and looseth the fauour of God, and is damned without repentance, because: Stipendium peccati mors est: Rom. 6. The reward of sinne is death. Of the sinnes of ignorance, which are not committed wittinglie and willinglie, the prophet speaketh thus: Psal. 18. Delicta quis intelligit? Who vnderstandeth his offenses? And, Ab occultis meis munda me Domine: Psal. 19. Lord cleanse me from my secret sinnes. Affectate or coueted ignorance is a sinne against our conscience, but ignorance not affectate is mans weakenes, which dooth not condemne vs, so that we acknowlege it, and aske forgiuenes thereof at Gods hand, with faith and repentance in newnes of life following. But to speake brieflie of our first parents offense, no man ought to make it a small fault, weighing it by the eating of an apple, séeing that by Sathans allurements they reuolted and turned awaie from Gods truth to a lie by infidelitie: and gaue credence to the wicked and false suggestions of the old serpent the diuell, which accused God of vntruth, enuie, and of malicious withdrawing some goodnes from them: and so much they forgat Gods great goodnes and benefits, which had made them after his owne image, Gen. 1. Coloss. 3. that by pride and ambition they sought to be equall with his maiestie also.
What dooth mariage signifie?
First, it signifieth the coupling togither of the diuine nature with mans nature, and that maruelous league, true, and ardent loue, wherewith the sonne of God entierlie loueth mans nature, which he tooke vpon him. Next, it signifieth the loue of the sonne of God, the defense & preseruation of his church, whereof S. Paule speaketh: Ephes. 5. Christus dilexit ecclesiam, & semetipsum tradidit pro ea: Christ loued his church, and gaue himselfe for it.
The consequent is not good from a particularitie, to a generalitie,
Matt. 8.Miracles are particular deliuerings, as of the leper and palsie man,
Therefore, we make an euill argument of these examples, to saie: that God will likewise deliuer all other men.
First, I denie the consequent. Although examples be particular, yet the promise is vniuersall, Rom. 10. as: Omnis qui inuocauerit nomen Domini saluus erit: Euerie one that calleth on the name of God shall be saued. Againe, Venite ad me omnes qui laboratis, Matt. 11. & ego reficiam vos: Come vnto me all ye that be heauie laden, & I will refresh you. These promises are declared by examples, which therefore are not vniuersall, because all men doo not receiue them in [Page 39] faith. Next, there is vnlikenes in bodilie aids and cures: for God deliuereth not vs by one meanes alwaies. So Ionathas, 1. Macab. 12 although he were good & godlie, was killed togither with his father, by a craftie policie. Manasses, who repented, was brought out of captiuitie, and manie other saints caried awaie into captiuitie to Babylon, neuer returned againe. Thirdlie, a spirituall promise simplie made is vniuersall, and is Gods commandement, and is vnmoueable, that we should beléeue to receiue forgiuenes of our sinnes, righteousnes and euerlasting life, fréelie by faith, onelie for Christes sake our mediator, Iohn. 3. according vnto these words: Sic Deus dilexit mundum, vt filium suum daret, vt omni qui credit in eum non pereat, sed vitam habeat aeternam: So God loued the world, that he gaue his sonne, that euery one that beléeueth in him, should not perish, but haue life euerlasting. Also: Rom. 5. Omnes qui credunt in eum habent vitam aeternam: All that beleeue in him, haue euerlasting life. And: Iustificati fide, pacem habemus: We are at peace with him, being iustified by faith. The psalmist saith: Psalm. 1. Beati omnes qui confidunt in eo: Blessed are all they that put their trust in him.
What is circumcision?
It is the cutting of the foreskin [Page 40] of the priuie member, which is called in Latin Praeputium: and it was commanded Abraham and his posteritie, that they might be admonished by this outward signe, chieflie of the promise made vnto Abraham, that Messias the promised seed should be borne of his posteritie. Next, that it should be a signe of encreasing his posteritie as the starres of heauen, and the sand of the sea. Gen. 22. Thirdlie, of giuing the land of Chanaan to his successors, that it might be certeinlie knowne, in what place the Messias should be borne, Gen. 17. teach, and die. Abraham was ninetie yeere old and nine, when the flesh of his foreskin was circumcised, and the mankind, obseruing this ceremonie, did sanctifie their women thereby. For the manchild onelie was commanded to be circumcised, when he was eight daies old, being bond or frée, without exception.
Wherefore should not circumcision be yet vsed among vs that be Christians?
Gala. 5.Because S. Paule dooth saie: Quòd si circumcidamini, Christus pro vobis frustrà mortuus est: If you be circumcised, Christ is become but in vaine vnto you. For the lawe conteining the ceremonies, decrees and commandements, Ephes. 2. 2. Cor. 3. Act. 15. is abolished by Christ. Because the lawe brought no man vnto the perfection of [Page 41] christianitie, which the knowledge of Christ requireth generallie of euerie man, for that it is said: Estote vos perfecti, Matt. 5. sicut pater vester coelestis perfectus est: Be you perfect, euen as your heauenlie father is perfect.
Why dooth S. Paule call circumcision then the seale of righteousnesse, if it bring vs not vnto righteousnesse?
Not because Abraham by this externall signe was iustified before God, or pleased God, as the Iewes supposed: but that by this signe he applied vnto himselfe the promise of GOD of the reconciliation, attonement, forgiuenes of sins, Gen. 22. and the gift of eternall life fréelie for the promised séed vnto him, and that he should by this signe confirme his faith. For the sacraments are testimonies, pledges and tokens of the applieng of the benefits of God vnto vs, and confirmation of our faith.
The lawe forbiddeth vs to touch lepers, Leuit. 13.
Christ touched a leper, Matth. 8.
Therefore Christ did not well.
I denie the consequent. First, because the lawe forbiddeth the touching of lepers to this end, not for that it is sinne or euill, but that the harme and contagiousnes of the [Page 42] leprosie, should not spread it selfe abroad furder among the people. Therefore it is lawfull to touch lepers to cure them. For morals are to be preferred before ceremonials, as the prophet saith: Ose. 6. Misericordiam volo, non sacrificia, scientiam Dei volo non holocausta: I will haue mercie & not sacrifice, I will haue the knowledge of God and not burnt sacrifices: which saieng comprehendeth both tables, whereof the first speaketh of the knowledge of GOD, Two tables of commā dements. and his true worshippings, by the meanes whereof we deale with God, as in feare, faith, loue, inuocation, giuing of thanks, and so foorth. The second table conteineth the works of mercie, or of loue towards our neighbor, and so did Christ reason when he cured the man of the dropsie on the sabboth daie: Luc. 14. Vos extrahitis pecudes in sabbato ex fosis, quanto magis licet in eo sanare hominem? You plucke beasts out of the pit on the sabboth daie, how much more is it lawfull to cure a man on the sabboth daie? Also Christ was not tied vnto this lawe, which was ordeined of God for the politike gouernance of the Iewes: and Christ was the son of God, and therefore as he saith in another place: Matth. 12. Luc. 6. Dominus erat sabbati: He was Lord of the sabboth. Thirdlie, the curing of the sicke man so presentlie was the worke of God, and [Page 43] the confirming of Christes vocation and calling. Therefore Christ was not tied vnto the ceremoniall lawe.
What is the church visible?
The church visible is a companie of people imbrasing and professing openlie the pure doctrine of the gospell, confessing the sonne of God, his benefits, and reteining of a lawfull and perfect vse of the sacraments of Christ, according to this saieng: Oues meae vocem meam audiunt: Iohn. 10. My shéepe doo heare my voice. And this church of Christ is but litle, contemned, & subiect to persecution in this world. Therefore it is said: Luc. 12. Noli timere pusille grex: Feare not litle flocke. Againe, Non multi sapientes secundum carnem, 1. Cor. 1. non multi nobiles, sed quae contempta, & ignobilia coram mundo, elegit Deus: God hath not chosen manie wisemen according to the flesh, not manie of high degrée, but the despised and foolish things of the world. And in another place: Iohn. 16. In mundo afflictiones habebitis: You shall haue trouble in this world, and that chieflie before potentates, and monarchs.
How manie monarchies hath there béene in time past?
There hath béene foure monarchies. [Page 44] 1 The first, was the kingdome of Babylon, which continued a thousand yeeres, euen vntill the time of Cyrus, from the daies of Abraham, who liued in the time of Ninus the first king of the Babylonians.
2 The second was the kingdome of Persia, which continued two hundred yeeres, Cyrus was the first gouernor thereof.
3 The third was the kingdome of the Graecians, which continued three hundred yéeres, Alexander Magnus was the first gouernour thereof.
4 The fourth and the last monarchie was the empire of Rome, which began from Iulius Caesar, and continued about foure hundred yeeres vnto Constantinus, or Valentianus the later, and a monarchie is the rule of one, of whome all other doo hold.
Saint Paule was beheaded at Rome, after Christ 37. yeeres by Nero.Good and iust men ought to be well vsed,
S. Paule was a good and iust man,
Therfore he ought to haue béene well vsed, and not to haue lost his head.
The maior may thus be answered. Good and iust men ought to be well vsed, but according to the will and ordinance of God, and that trulie in their due season. And God will haue his church in this life to be subiect [Page 45] to persecution. For the bloud of martyrs is the séed of the gospell. And God dooth suffer almost the chiefest members of his church, and his best seruants, to be murthered of tyrants for their good and well dooings, and not for anie faults that the persecutors can find in them, that they should confirme their doctrine with their owne deaths, and that they might be made somewhat like vnto Christ vpon the crosse, by the sealing vp of their words and workes in their bloud. But after this life certeinelie good and iust men shall be well vsed, and contrariwise, wicked men shall be euill vsed, as the example of the rich glutton and poore Lazarus dooth witnes the same. Luc. 16,
Wherefore dooth God suffer his church, which he loueth, to be so hardlie intreated, séeing she is iust in afflictions, as he saith in the prophet: Ierem. 12. Dedi dilectam meam in manum inimitorum meorum: I haue deliuered my beloued into the hand of mine enimies?
There be two especiall causes. The first is, that the church hath yet sins and much filthines, which God would haue to be acknowledged, purged and mortified in the godlie. As the Apostle saieth: Rom. [...]. Corpus destinatum est morti propter peccatum: The bodie is dead because of sinne which hangeth in our nature. [Page 46] And S. Peter saith: 1. Pet. 4. Iudicium (id est poena) incipit à domo Dei: Iudgement (that is to saie punishment) shall begin at the houshold of God. The second cause is, for that God would haue the power of his sonne, by that meanes to be the more manifest, when he ouercommeth the diuell by the weake, as he deliuereth and preserueth his church, against the which the diuell and his members with great furie dooth rage and stirre; as he restored our first parents falling awaie from him, and preserueth his church at all seasons, by his diuine and mightie power.
God alwaies heareth vs not beneuolentlie, neither deliuereth he vs in afflictions,
Therefore it is lawfull for vs to doubt of him.
The consequent must be denied. Because, although God dooth sometimes defer our deliuerance in corporall perils, yet we ought not doubt of his good will and deliuerance in the end. Let vs commit our soules to God with well doing. 1. Pet. 4. For God would haue vs in corporall things to be subiect to his will, and that we should be prepared to obedience, and he dooth not deliuer vs, or mitigate our calamities after one manner alwaies. Therefore we ought first to determine in faith, that God will receiue vs, and forgiue vs our sinnes for [Page 47] his sonnes sake our mediatour. Next, that we should craue deliuerance at Gods hands onelie, and none other waies, and that we should expect the same according to his good will and pleasure. Thirdlie, that we should obeie, and emploie our calling, and then commit all corporall successe vnto God. Fourthlie, we must put our selues in subiection to the pleasure of God, and shewe our obedience in afflictions, and tarrie his leasure, vntill that he deliuereth vs, and dooth mitigate our sorrowes. As Dauid saith: Si velit Dominus, reducet me: si non velit, 1. Reg. 15. fiat voluntas Domini: If it please the Lord, he will bring me out of captiuitie; if not, the will of the Lord be fulfilled. Therefore, although God deliuereth vs not presentlie in bodilie harmes, yet we ought not be doubtfull of his deliuerance in the end, neither of his promise of grace, which is the fruit of the gospell, but most certeinelie to determine that God will receiue vs, be mercifull to vs, and forgiue vs our sinnes for his sonnes sake. As it is written: Omnis qui credit in filium habet vitam aeternam: Iohn. 3. Euery one that beléeueth in the sonne of God hath eternall life. And againe: Iob. 13. Etiamsi occiderit me Dominus, tamen sperabo in eum: Although the Lord kill me, yet I will put my trust in him.
Did you euer heare or read of a [Page 48] riuer or poole called Asphaltites?
Yea, it is a place mentioned in Genesis, & a poole in the later part of the tribe of Iuda: & this Asphaltites is otherwise called either the salt sea, or the dead sea: for in this place the flue cities, Sodome, Gomorrha, Adama, Seboim, and Segor, were destroied with fier from God, for their incestuous lusts and other sins, Genesi. 19. as it is mentioned. And this poole is a monument of the punishment and wrath of God, against the sinnes of that time, and all others: it is in bignes about the space of eight miles, it dooth smoke and breath out firie pitch and brimstone of a most stinking sauor, by a secret and a meruelous working of God euen to this daie. Moses writeth thereof thus: Pluit Dominus ignem à Domino: Genesi. 19. The Lord rained vpon them brimstone and fier from the Lord; that is to saie: The son of God receiued fier of his eternall father, and was the executor of that fier and punishment.
Matth. 9.Whosoeuer dooth attribute vnto him selfe that which is proper to God, he is a blasphemer,
Christ did attribute that vnto himselfe which was proper to God,
Therefore (saie the Phariseis) Christ was a blasphemer.
I denie the consequent. Yet this kind of reasoning were true, if Christ had beene like vnto the Phariseis, that is, if Christ had béene a méere man, and not God withall. Because he said vnto the sicke of the palsie; Fili confide, remittuntur tibi peccata: Ibidem. Sonne be of good chéere, thy sinnes be forgiuen thée, they thought him to be a blasphemer. But sée (I pray you) how much worse our papists and monks are, than the Scribes and Phariseis. For they being instructed by Gods word could saie: Quis potest remittere peccata nisi solus Deus? Marc. 2. Who can forgiue sinnes but God onlie? Yet our papists attribute the forgiuenes of sinnes to the merits of saints, masses & indulgences, which they depart not with for naught, but sell this trash verie deere. Sure it is a strange kind of merchandise, they sell that which they haue not they sell smoke and receiue gold, they promise men heauen but deliuer them hell. But what shall we saie concerning the ministers of the word of God? Doo they forgiue sinnes or no? They themselues as of themselues doo not forgiue sins, Matt. 9. but they pronounce & declare the remission of sins to all such as they find like to the man sick of the palsie; they giue nothing of their owne, but offer that which is anothers, by the commandement of Christ. They offer the [Page 50] release and forgiuenes of sins in the voice of the gospell. Whosoeuer receiueth this voice faithfullie, doubtles he receiueth the full forgiuenes of all his sinnes. For Christ himselfe dooth saie: Luc. 10. Qui vos audit me audit: He that heareth you heareth me.
Tell me I praie you, are all christian men priests or no?
Yea that they are trulie. For, as euerie one regenerate by the participation of water and the Holie-ghost is called a Christian, of Christ; so by him, he is made a king and a priest, Apoc. 1. as it is written: Fecit nos reges & sacerdotes patri suo: He hath made vs kings and priests to his father. And hereof S. Peter calleth vs Regale sacerdotium, 1. Pet. 2. A roiall priesthood. For by Christ, we haue right and authoritie to preach the word of God, yet euerie man in his calling. We haue right & libertie to call vpon God, according to this saieng: Inuoca me in die tribulationis: Call vpon me in the daie of trouble. Againe: Quicquid petieritis patrem in nomine meo dabit vobis: Whatsoeuer ye aske the father in my name he will giue it you. We haue also power and authoritie to offer vp sacrifice of praise and thankesgiuing. Propitiatorie is pacifieng Gods wrath. For no mortall man can offer vp a propitiatorie sacrifice, because that honor onlie belongeth to Christ, our [Page 51] high bishop and Lord. There are fiue kinds of christian mens sacrifices: a troubled spirit, the sacrifice of righteousnesse, the sacrifice of praise or the calues of our lips, confessing the name of God, the sacrifice of beneficence and communion, and our owne bodie which is a reasonable sacrifice. The prophet Micheas asked the Lord, what acceptable thing he should offer vnto him? His answer was; I will shew thée (O man) what thing is good, and what the Lord requireth of thée: Vtique facere iudicium, Mich. 6. & diligere misericordiam, & humilem ambulare coram Deo tuo: Namelie that thou doo right, loue mercie, and walke humblie before thy God. But touching them which are called priests amongst vs now adaies, you shall vnderstand that they are so called for thrée causes. First, because they are dedicated to Christ, togithers with other Christians, and are rightlie called priests, because and in as much as they are true Christians. Next, in imitation of the people of Israell, which called them priests that were occupied in the ministerie of the word of God, and in the sacrifices of the law, and this honor was onelie granted vnto the tribe of Leuy. Thirdlie, it pleased the holie fathers, the successors of the Apostles, to adorne before others, with this worthie sacerdotall title, those [Page 52] which teach the word of God, minister the sacraments, and declare vnto men, that sinne, death, and damnation, are abolished by the onlie sacrifice of Christ our high priest. The old priests of the lawe did offer vp beasts, but the Apostles and other priests of Christ and his gospell, doo as it were slea men, and offer vp a liuelie sacrifice to God by the gospell. S. Paule testifieth that he made the like sacrifice, when he slue the Gentiles with the sword of the gospell: Rom. 15. Vt fieret oblatio acceptabilis Deo, sanctificata per spiritum sanctum: That the offering of the Gentiles might be acceptable to God, & sanctified by the Holie-ghost. The papists would so make a sacrifice, of a sacrament. But the papisticall sacrifice is plaine sacrilege, for it was not ordeined to teach Christ, and to slea men to God by the sword of the gospell; but to offer vp Christ for the quicke and the dead: by that meanes defiling, and treading vnder foote the sacrifice of Christ, which by his priesthood hath found eternall redemption, for it is written: Hic autem vnam pro peccatis offerens hostiam in sempiternum sedet ad dextram Dei: Hebr. 10. This man after he hath offered one sacrifice for sinnes, is set downe for euer on the right hand of God, and from henceforth tarieth till his foes be made his footestoole. For with one offering he hath made them perfect for euer that are sanctified. [Page 53] Therfore the popish priests are verie wicked, which impudentlie dare reiterat, and eftsoones beginne afresh that which is made perfect for euer by Christ our high priest.
The scripture reporteth Abraham, Noe and Iob, with others, to be good men and iust,
But Christ saith, Marc. 10. there is none good but God onelie, and Christ is true,
Therefore Abraham, Noe, and Iob, with others, are not good men and iust.
I denie the consequent. For as no man shineth but by Christ Iesus, Iohn. 1. which is the true light, lightening euerie man comming into this world, and beléeuing in him: so, there is none good, godlie and holie, but by Christ onelie, which is Summum bonum, The chiefest felicitie, the truth, the righteousnes, the life, wisedome, and the word of the father: 1. Cor. 1. Qui factus fuit nobis sapientia à Deo, iustitiáque, & sanctificatio & redemptio: Which is of God made wisedome vnto vs, and also righteousnes, and sanctifieng, & redemption. Iam vos mundi estis, Iohn. 15. propter sermonem quem loquutus sum vobis: Now you are cleane through the word which I haue spoken vnto you. The gospell of Christ Iesus doth clense vs and sanctifie vs, if it be receiued in faith: Rom. 1. Est enim virtus Dei ad salutem omni [Page 54] credenti: For it is the power of God vnto saluation to euerie one that beleeueth, Marc. 16. Cui qui crediderit saluus erit, Whom who so belieueth shall be saued. Iacob. 1. So we sée, Omne bonum esse à Deo: That all goodnes commeth of God, which onlie doth purge vs, and regenerate vs by his word, to be made the sonnes of God, of the children of wrath. There is none good but whome Gods goodnes doth make good; there is none holie but whom God doth make holie; there is none vertuous but by Gods vertue. No man by nature is good, but onlie God, which is almightie and omnipotent. Man is changed by the spirit and grace of God, and is made a good trée, righteous & holie, as man may be good, and as it were in a second kind of goodnes, not comparable to Gods most excellent goodnes in anie case.
How manie causes be there of ciuill punishments?
1 Thrée chiefe causes. First, the righteousnes and iustice of God, which will haue sinnes to be punished with corporall and eternall paines, according to the immoueable rule of his diuine iustice. His reasonable creatures therefore be bound either to the obedience of GOD their creator, or to his punishments.
[Page 55]Next, the publike peace and tranquillitie, 2 without the which the gospell cannot be preached, neither the church collected togither, and preserued in mankind.
Thirdlie, example; that others, by the punishments 3 of the wicked might be admonished, and terrified from the committing of the like sinne.
The tares in the gospell must not be taken awaie, Matth. 13.
Adulterers be the same tares spirituallie,
Therefore adulterers must not be taken awaie.
The consequent is false. And an answer may be made to the maior, by distinction. The tares, as the adulterers, and such other wicked and disobedient to the gospell, are not to be taken awaie of the apostles and ministers of the gospell, touching the ministerie of the word, but touching the ciuill power. Bicause the ciuill magistrate hath authoritie to take awaie adulterers, mankillers, théeues and such other wicked, as the apostle saith: Magistratum gerere gladium in terrorem malis, Rom. 13. vt puniar eos: That the magistrate beareth the sword for the terrour of the wicked, to punish them. And againe: Lex est iniustis posita, 1. Tim. 1. inobsequentibus, impijs, parricidis, matricidis, homicidis, scortatoribus: [Page 56] The lawe is giuen to the vnrighteous and disobedient, to the vngodlie, and to the sinners, to murtherers of fathers, and murtherers of mothers, to mansleiers, and whooremongers.
What thinke you? Is it not lawfull for a man some times to make a lie for aduantage and profit, or for pleasure?
No truelie; it is not lawfull in anie case for christian men to lie, howsoeuer the matter standeth. There be some that make such distinction of lies, Three kind of lies. that they hold opinion that there be thrée kinds of lies, sporting lies, officious, and pernicious lies: but of what sort so euer they be, truelie they be not tollerable, nor to be borne withall amongest such as professe God: Ephe. 4. bicause he hath forbidden it by the apostle, writing thus: Deponite mendacium, loquimini veritatem cum proximo suo vnusquísque: Laie awaie lieng, and speake euerie man truth to his neighbour. The mouth that speaketh lies dooth slaie the soule.
Psalm. 5.God will destroie all them that speake lies,
Genesi. 12. Abraham did lie, and yet was not destroied,
Therefore God dooth not destroie all them that speake lies.
The consequent is not true▪ [Page 57] And distinction may be well vsed in this answer. Exod. 23. Leuit. 19. For though in the lawe lieng be forbidden, and that euerie man should speake truth vnto his neighbor: Quando sumus inuicem membra: Séeing that we are one anothers members, yet is it difference, when men lie to saue life by compulsion: and when they doo it of a set purpose and a malicious mind to destroie life. And Dauid saith: Psalm. 5. Thou hatest all them that worke iniquitie, Et perdes omnes qui loquuntur mendacium: Thou wilt destroie all them that speake lies. Therefore S. Peter by his apostolicall authoritie (or rather God himselfe) slew Ananias and Saphira his wife, Act. 5. bicause they lied by agréement, and of a set purpose to tempt the spirit of the Lord. Abraham and other saints of the Lord, taken in this fault, perished not, bicause the Lord imputed not their sinnes vnto them: and they committed not lieng in the malice of their mind, or for anie pleasure they had in sinne, but for bare néed to saue their owne liues and others. Ge. 12. &, 20 So Abraham lied vnto Pharao and Abimelech, to saue his owne life, and Sara his wiues. Gene. 26. Likewise Isaac his sonne lied, in denieng his wife Rebecca to Abimelech king of the Philistines in Gerar. And Dauid counterfeited himselfe to be mad before Achis the king of Geth. 1. Reg. 21. Iudit. 11. Iudith likewise [Page 58] deceiued Holophernes, to saue hir citizens by craft, falselie declaring the cause of hir comming. Prou. 24. Furthermore: Septies in die cadit iustus, & resurgit: The righteous falleth seuen times a daie, 3. Reg. 8. and riseth againe. There is no man that sinneth not, yet the Lord imputeth not our sinnes vnto vs, but rather forgiueth the same, when he séeth and trieth our harts, knowing in what intent and mind we commit euill. Esaie. 43. Titus. 1. He it is that putteth awaie our iniquities; Peccatorum nostrorum non recordans amplius: Rom. 8. And no more remembreth our sinnes. Mundis omnia munda: To the cleane all things are cleane. And all things worke for the best, to them that loue God. But the Lord destroieth them that delight in wickednes, and haue a pleasure in their mind to lie in their ordinarie traffike & talke, to deceiue others thereby.
Séeing that Christ was not subiect to Moses lawes, whie did he then obeie them?
1 First the especiall cause is, whie the Sonne of God obeied these lawes and others, that he might signifie thereby that he made himselfe subiect to the whole lawe for vs: that is as much to saie, he deriued, and put vpon himselfe the wrath of God, and the punishment which was due to vs.
[Page 59]Next, that he might shew himselfe the onelie and first begotten sonne of the eternall father, 2 for whom, and in whom all things were made; and the lawe of the first begotten was ordeined, to signifie vnto vs, that this first begotten sonne of God eternall should come in the flesh, to worke the mysterie of our redemption, and to be made sinne for vs, Rom. 8. 1. Pet. 2. 2. Cor. 5. that is to saie, a satisfaction for our sinnes; and euen so by sinne, that is by sacrifice offered vpon the trée of the crosse, he hath taken awaie, condemned, and doone awaie our sinne.
It is wrong to giue to equals vnequallie,
God sauing Dauid, and damning Saule, gaue to equals vnequallie,
Therefore God is vniust, receiuing some, and sauing them, and casting awaie others, and damning them.
I answer first to the maior, which is not true vniuersallie: bicause that God giueth diuerse gifts to equals, for diuerse functions and ministeries, as God gaue king Cyrus more and greater gifts than to anie of his common soldiers for the gouernement of his kingdome. Therefore the maior is not true in things not necessarie to all mens saluation. God is equall to all men in things necessarie [Page 60] to all mens saluation. God is equall to all men in things necessarie to their saluation, sauing repentant Dauid, Dauid repented and not Saule. and condemning Saule that did not repent. And yet Dauid and Saule were not equals touching repentance. Therefore God is equall to all men, according to this immutable rule; that he receiueth all them to saluation, which beléeue on our mediator: and contrariwise, he casteth all them awaie, Hebr. 4. & 7. 1. Tim. 2. which beléeue not on our onelie mediator Christ Iesus. For God would haue all men to repent, and applie the promise of grace in faith vnto themselues, and so consequentlie to be saued. And S. Chrysostome saith: Quem Deus trahit, volentem trahit, non repugnantem: Whom God draweth, he draweth him willinglie, and not against his will. Therefore, there is no cause of damnation in God, but in themselues which are damned, bicause they doo not repent and receiue the promise of grace in saith. Iohn. 3. For he that beléeueth in Christ shall not die, that is, he shall not be damned, and the wrath of GOD shall not abide vpon him. Matth. 4. Deut. 8. Luke. 4.
How dooth a man liue by the word of God?
Séeing that [...], the word, is the second person of the diuinitie, it is immediatlie [Page 61] effectuall in them that beléeue, when it is spoken: susteining and comforting them, and bringing it to passe maruellouslie, that they are nourished and defended thereby: as Christ speaketh of himselfe: Ego sum via, Iohn. 14. veritas, & vita: I am she waie, the veritie, and the life. And in another place: Iohn. 10. Egò vitam aeternam do eis: I giue them eternall life.
The church is the house of God, 2. Reg. 12. and the piller of truth,
Therefore the church dooth not erre.
I may answer the maior by distinction. First, the church is the house of God, 1 and the piller of truth, which is vniuersallie true. Bicause some members of the church (though they be verie few) do alwaies obserue the truth. Such were these among the people of God, Marie, Ioseph, Zacharie, Elizabeth, Iohn the baptist, Simeon, Anna the prophetesse, and others, in the time of Christ. So Iohn the baptist certeinlie knew the Messias to be the sacrifice for all the world, when he saied: Iohn. 1. Ecce agnus Dei, qui tollit peccata mundi: Behold the lambe of God that taketh awaie the sinnes of the world. Which thing the apostles knew not, before the Holie-ghost was giuen them. And except this error had béene corrected amongst them, they had perished. Secondlie, manie doo 2 [Page 62] erre in the church, yet diuerslie, some in the foundation, that is, in the knowledge of the lawe, and of the gospell, or in the articles of our faith, and stubbornelie defend their error, as the papists defend their error, of the doubt whether we be in the fauour and grace of God or no, Articl. 10. contrarie to the article of our faith: Credo remissionem peccatorum: I beléeue the forgiuenes of sinnes. Also they mainteine inuocation, and praier to saints. As long as they wilfullie continue in these errors, and others like, they are no true members of the church. And others erre in common traditions, as about eating of flesh, and such others: as S. Peter noluit edere de immundis, Acts. 10. would not eate of vncleane things.
Dooth the diuell giue the kingdoms and riches of this world?
No, bicause it is written in the prophet: Dani. 2. Dominus transfert regna, atque constituit illa: The Lord dooth transferre kingdomes, and appoint them. And againe it is said: Domini est terra, Psal. 33. & plenitudo eius: The earth is the Lords, and the fulnes thereof.
Abraham beleeued that his posteritie should inherit the promised land of Canaan: Gen. 12. and that his posteritie should be increased as the starres of heauen, and as the [Page 63] sand of the sea,
Therefore S. Paule erred, in applieng the example of Abraham to the faith of spirituall things, as the forgiuenes of sinnes, and eternall life.
I denie the consequent. Bicause corporall promises doo include in them the spirituall promise; namelie, the reconciliation of sinnes: for without that, the corporall promise is vnprofitable. If truelie a man doo not determine, that God is at peace with vs, and dooth iustifie vs, for the loue of Christ Iesus, Rom. 8. he can neither aske, neither beléeue to receiue corporall gifts, as his liuing, and defensement in safegard. Therefore it is verie requisite, that faith touching spirituall things be manifest in our praier. Hereof it is, that Abraham beléeued the first and principall promise of God, Gene. 22. for the séed that should be borne of his posteritie, whereby he himselfe, and all his ofspring, with all nations should be blessed: likewise it is said: Ero Deus tuus, & seminis tui post te: I will be thy God, and the God of thy séed after thée.
What be the causes of our temptations, and falling awaie from God?
There be two chéefe [Page 64] 1 causes. First, mans imbecillitie and weakenes, bicause by Adam we are all sinners, and haue of him the inclination to doo euill. And the apostle saith: Rom. 5. Vnusquisque dum tentatur a propria concupiscentia abstrahitur & inescatur: Euerie one, when he is tempted, he is drawne awaie, and entised of his owne concupiscence. Then sinne groweth consequentlie: Iacob. 1. first by suggestion, next by consent of our spirit, and last of all by the pleasure that our flesh taketh to fulfill that suggestion and consent. Then we fulfill our lewd desires with gréedinesse, contrarie to the mind of the apostle which saith: Desideria carnis non perficietis: Galat. 5. Ye shall not fulfill the lusts of the flesh.
2 Secondlie, the diuell intiseth vs by innumerable meanes secretlie to commit much wickednes; yea, and that some time against nature: as Medea by temptation killed hir owne children. Sodome, Gomorrha, Adama, Sebim, and Segor sinned against nature; and also Iudas in betraieng Christ his redéemer, of whom the euangelist saieth: Iohn. 13. Diabolus in Iudam post sumptam offulam ingressus est: The diuell entred into Iudas, after that he had receiued the sop. So the diuell still letteth our right iudgement, in the vnderstanding of the doctrine necessarie for our saluation, he putteth darknesse into [Page 65] our harts, & confirmeth errors in our minds, wherefore S. Peter saith: Diabolus circuit nos, 1. Pet. 5. quaerens quem deuoret: The diuell goeth about vs, seeking whom he may deuoure, and spreddeth abrode such nets of temptations and vices alwaies, as he perceiueth vs to be most addicted and giuen vnto.
What ought christian men to doo, when the sting of sinne and worme of conscience dooth bite them?
First, they must in no case despaire, 1 as though they were not written in the scroll of the liuing. And although we be most sinfull all the whole packe of vs in déed: yet we must learne of the apostle to saie: Rom. 5. Exsuperat gratia super peccatum: Grace is more aboundant than sinne, we must confesse our sinnes, and be trulie repentant for them, then may we, Cum fiducia ad thronum gratiae accedere: Hebru. 4. Drawe néere to the throne of grace, with hope and confidence in him that is the onelie propitiation and obteiner of mercie for them all that be such. We must set before vs the example of such as truelie repented, as Manasses, Marie Magdalene, Peter, and the théefe vpon the crosse: we must fullie persuade our selues to be predestinate and elected to saluation, if we assent to the word of God, and beleeue the [Page 66] gospell: according to this saieng: Quos elegit, hos & vocauit: Whom he hath chosen, those hath he also called.
2 Next, we must thinke that the commandement of God is alwaies immutable, how that we must beléeue the sonne of God which saith: It is not the will of your father which is in heauen: Matth. 18. Vt pereat vnus de pusillis istis: That one of these little ones should perish.
3 Thirdlie, we must thinke that the commandement of dooing repentance is vniuersall, and the promises therevnto annexed be likewise vniuersall, and includeth all people, as: Venite ad me omnes: Matt. 11. Esaie. 53. Come vnto me all yee. And againe, Delicta omnium nostrum tulit: He hath borne all our sinnes. Thus haue the seruants of God alwaies wrestled with sin, that the pricking thereof should not perse them to death. Thus did the woman the Cananite, which acknowledged hir selfe vnworthie of Christs benefits, obteine grace and mercie by faith, and constancie in hir inuocation and praier.
The diuell dooth miracles and strange works, what difference therefore is there betweene true miracles and false?
1 There is a three double difference. The first is taken of the substance o [...] miracles, bicause that the diuell truelie cannot [Page 67] imitate or followe the true miracles, or the miracles of the church: as to raise vp the dead to life againe, to let the course of the sun, to stop the course of flouds, and to make the barren to beare children.
The second difference may be taken of the 2 accident, that is to wit, in confirmation of false worshippings, and false doctrine, as the [...]racles which were doone among the gentils and papists were doone of the diuell, for the confirmation of idolatrie, and false worshipping, as the inuocation and praier to the dead, contrarie to the expresse word of God, saieng; Thou shalt haue none other gods but me. Exod. 20. And this rule is alwaies immutablie to be obserued: that we must beléeue no miracle doon contrarie to the expresse word of God. Also, Deut. 18. Thou shalt not enquire the truth of the dead.
The third difference is, that the miracles in 3 the church doo repell and cast out the diuell, whether he will or no; Luc. 11. as Christ did cast out the dum diuell, and afterward the dum spake, & the people maruelled, the like he did other times also.
Can the holie and elect people of God fall, and léese the Holie-ghost, their faith, [...] grace of God, and be damned?
No, they cannot, for our sauiour Christ hath said; Matth. 24. Except those daies (of trouble) should be shortened, no flesh (that is, no man) [Page 68] should be saued: but for the sake of the elected, those daies shalbe shortned. And againe, False christs and false prophets shall arise, and shall giue great signes and wonders, insomuch that (if it were possible) the verie elect should be brought into error. By these words it appeareth manifestlie, that God in mercifull prouidence will shorten the daies of trouble that shall be towards the end of the world, bicause his elected and holie people may not thereby be brought to euerlasting destruction: and that it is not possible for them to be so brought into error by false christs, and false prophets, that they should by error be brought into euerlasting damnation. 1. Cor. 10. And S. Paule hath written thus to the Corinthians; God is faithfull, and will not suffer you to be tempted aboue your power, but euen in the midst of the temptation he will make a waie, that you may be able to beare it. Rom. 8. And againe to the Romans; Who will laie any thing to the charge of Gods elect? 2. Tim. 2. And againe to Timothie; The firme foundation of God standeth stedfastlie, hauing this seale; God knoweth who be his. But least this doctrine should encourage any man to lead a carelesse life, the apostle saith in the next sentence; Let euerie one that calleth vpon the name of the Lord, depart from iniquitie. And to the Romans, There is no condemnation to [Page 69] them that be in Christ Iesus, which walke not after the flesh. Eph. 4. And to the Ephesians the apostle saith; Gréeue not the holie spirit of GOD, in whom you are sealed against the daie of redemption. Our care is to liue without sinne, according to the exhortation of th'apostle Iohn, 1. Ioh. 2. My little babes, I write these words to you, that you should not sinne: but if any man doo sin, we haue an aduocate with the father, euen Iesus Christ the righteous, and he is the propitiation for our sins. Gods elected doo sinne (as the wise man saith) verie often: but they rise againe by repentance. Prou. 24. The righteous person (saith he) falleth seuen times, and riseth againe, but the vngodly fall downe headlong into mischiefe.
The elect people are alwaies beloued of God: therefore they cannot fall.
The elect people are indéed beloued of God, and so beloued, that nothing can separate them from his loue. Rom. 8. As the apostle writeth; I am sure that neither death, neither life, neither angels, neither principalities, neither powers, neither things present, nor things to come, neither fortitude, neither higth, neither depth, neither any other creature can separate vs from the loue of God, which is in Christ Iesus our Lord. But yet they may and doo fall [...]s Salomon saith, Prou. 24. and being downe they rise [Page 70] againe, being lifted vp by that louing Father, from whose loue their often and horrible falles cannot separate them. For so God loued the world (that is, Iohn. 3. his elect in the world) that he gaue his onlie begotten son, that all that beleeue in him shuld not perish, but haue euerlasting life.
Tell me, what is blasphemie, and whether the sinne therof be remissible and pardonable, or no?
Blasphemare, est maledicere ac malè precari al [...]js, per nomen seu inuocationem Dei.Blasphemie is a sinne against the Holie-ghost: a curssing and reproching, commonlie referred vnto the despite of GOD: when one knowing and willinglie would adnihilate and make void the power of God, and withstand the truth that a man knoweth; as the Phariseis reuiled & reiected Christ, oppugning the truth manifested vnto them by the testimonies of God, and attributed the works of Christ to the diuell; Matth. 12. Marc. 3. Luc. 11. Exod. 10. and to take vpon him aboue the might of God, as Pharao, Senacherib, and Holophernes did. And touching pardon thereof, I answer by distinction, that they are forgiuen which sinne therein by ignorance, and afterward truelie repent them thereof, as S. Paule did, 1. Tim. 1. which saieth, that he was a blasphemer, but yet he receiued mercy & forgiuenes of his sinne; bicause he persecuted the congregation of GOD ignorantlie. And this is a generall rule, euer inuiolablie to be obserued [Page 71] Venite ad me omnes, qui laboratis: Matth. 11. Come vnto me all ye that are heauie laden with the burthen of sinne, &c: Vius ego dicit Dominus: Eze. 18.33. 1. Tim. 2. Rom. 5. As sure as I liue (saith the Lord) I will not haue the death of a sinner, but rather that he should conuert and liue. And that God would haue all men to be saued. Againe: Gratia exuberat super delictum: Grace is more aboundant than sinne. We must déeme of the will of God according to these saiengs of scripture and promises; and not after our owne opinions, or according to the omnipotencie of God, which although he can condemne some, and can saue other some, yet he onelie saueth those that vndoubtedlie beléeue the voice of his onelie Sonne Iesus, and condemneth them that striue against him, and withstand his diuine calling of them, perseuering still in their blasphemies, as the apostle saith: Nolite errare, non enim idololatrae, 1. Cor. 6. moechi, homicidae, &c. Be ye not deceiued, for neither idolaters, whooremongers, mankillers, neither theeues, neither the couetous, nor droonkards, neither cursed speakers, nor pillers and pollers shall inherit the kingdome of heauen. And there is no sinne so great and horrible, but that the death of Christ, the onelie sonne of God, is a sufficient price and redemption thereof. As the holie apostle saith: 1. Iohn. 2. Ipse est [Page 72] propitiatio pro peccatis nostris: He is the obteiner of mercie for our sinnes, and not for our sins onelie, but for all the sinnes that euer were or shall be doone in the whole world, from the first Adam to the last man, if we our selues lées [...] not the benefit of his passion, death, resurrection, and ascension, by our owne wilfull contempt and disobedience.
No man ought to praise himselfe,
Iohn. 8.Christ praised himselfe, when he said, Which o [...] you can reprooue me of sinne?
Therefore Christ did not well.
I answer vnto the maior by distinction. No man ought to praise himselfe, that is to wit, for his owne righteousnesse, or for his owne priuate vertues, except it be for that euerie one ought to kéepe a good conscience before all men, according to the saieng of the apostle: Haec est gloriatio nostra, testimonium conscientiae nostrae: This is our reioising, euen the testimonie of our conscience. And S. Augustine saith: Bona conscientia mihi opus est, propter me ipsum, sicilicet coram Deo; bona fama propter proximum: I haue need of a good conscience for my selfe, that is before God; I haue néed of a good name, for my neighbour. But the teacher of the congregation of God ought to boast of the [Page 73] truth and certeintie of his doctrine, that he teacheth no foolish vanities, nor is a false pro [...]het. So Christ boasteth here, of the truth and veritie of his doctrine, saieng: Quis arguet me de peccato? Who can reprooue me of sinne? Iohn. 8. That is, of errour in my doctrine, or of anie false opinion. Which thing when the Iewes could not doo, yet notwithstanding they accused Christ without cause, reprooued, and persecuted his doctrine, which is the verie voice and commandement of almightie God the heauenlie father.
I haue heard of Neuters in religion: I praie you tell me what are they?
Neuters are epicures, scorners and contemners of the true religion and heauenlie doctrine, and there are found too manie such now a daies, which are of no religion, and such force not whether there be anie seruing of God or no, so that they may liue in iolitie, and féed the humor of their lewd lusts and concupiscence. Of whom Christ speaketh thus: Luc. 11. Qui non est mecum, contra me est: He that is not with me, is against me; and he that dooth not gather with me, scattereth abroad. Contrariewise, there be some that be weake, which doo not scorne at religion, but yet for feare they doo not professe the true doctrine, but fall by frailtie, [Page 74] and would happilie learne, if they were better taught, of whom the holie apostle speaketh thus: Rom. 14. Infirmum in fide assumite: Take him vnto you, that is weake in faith, that is to say, helpe and aid him, that he may increase further in faith. Luc. 17. And the apostles themselues were fraile and weake, before they had receiued the gift of the Holie-ghost: wherefore they praied; Domine adauge nobis fidem: Lord increase our faith. So likewise God receiued Darius to repentance, Dan. 6. which cast awaie Daniel to be destroied of the lions, bicause he knew not that Daniel was innocent and guiltlesse in the crime that was laid against him; wherfore the kings sinne therein was committed by ignorance.
What is Christian religion: and how manie parts be there of religion?
Christian religion is the true worshipping of God, and kéeping of his commandements. There be foure parts thereof. Obedience, Parts of religion. which the lawe of God commandeth; faith, which the gospell requireth; praier, and sacraments, which Christ hath ordeined, and left vnto his church, there to be vsed vntill his second comming to iudgement.
I haue heard some to haue beene doubtfull of Christes descension into hell, but [Page 75] tell me what thinke you thereof?
I thinke it is lamentable, that curious heads should spread such a schisme, and put such errour into the minds of men simple and vnlettered. And I beléeue that as Christ in his bodie descended into the bowels of the earth, so his soule seuered from the bodie, he descended into hell. And after the same sort, he kept his promise with the théefe vpon the crosse, when he said: Hodie mecum eris in paradiso: To daie thou shalt be with me in paradise. Although his bodie was committed to the graue, yet was his soule, his power, and his Godhead in paradise, & wheresoeuer else it pleased himselfe to be. Therfore, there be some that affirme that he descended into hell thrée waies: in power, spirit, and person. In power, when the vaile of the temple did rent; Matth. 26. in spirit, when he said, Tristis est anima mea vsque ad mortem: My soule is heauie euen to the death; and in person, when he was laid in the graue.
Christ saieth: Iohn. 8. If a man kéepe my saiengs, he shall neuer sée death. But no man dooth kéepe the word of Christ, bicause it is impossible to satisfie the lawe of God, through our corrupt nature. Therefore no man dooeth liue by kéeping the word of Christ, and by a consequent, Christs promise is impossible, absurd, [Page 76] and vaine.
I denie the minor, bicause Christ speaketh héere not properlie of the lawe, which requireth perfect obedience, as it is said: Qui facit legem, Leuit. 18. Deut. 15. viuet in ea: He that fulfilleth the law, shall liue thereby: but of the Gospell, which is a frée promise of remission of our sinnes, the gift of righteousnes, and of eternall life, in faith, for Christ, and by Christ, the son of Go [...] our mediator and redéemer. And they doo obserue the Gospell and kéepe the word of Christ, which assent and agrée to the promise of God, touching his mercie, and doo begin a new obedience, as Marie Magdalen, Zachee, the théefe vpon the gibbet, Paule, and such other truelie repentant did: all which receiued forgiuenesse of their sinnes, according to this promise of Christ, and did not sée death; that is, they tasted not of the horrors of death, though the remnant of sinne (to wit) naturall weakenesse did still hang vpon them, whereby they fell sometime into externall or actuall sin, but they repented, Rom. 8. asked forgiuenes, & beléeued in Christ according to this saieng: Nulla est condemnatio his, qui insiti sunt in Iesu Christo, qui non secundum carnem viuunt, sed secundū spiritum: There is no condemnation for them that be grafted in Christ Iesu, which liue not according to the [Page 77] flesh, but according to the spirit. So the apostles also did kéepe the word of Christ, as Christ himselfe saith: Tui erant, & mihi dedisti eos, Iohn. 17. & serm [...]nem tuum seruarunt. They were thine (O father) and thou gauest them me, and they haue kept thy word: that is as much to saie as, They had the beginning of their faith of me, and new obedience, although there were in them much infirmitie, darkenesse, and doubtfulnes, and their faith verie féeble, Luke. 17. as they themselues did testifie, saieng: Domine adauge nobis fidem? Lord increase our faith.
Is it not lawfull to giue men thanks, sith we receiue benefits of them?
Whatsoeuer benefits and goodnesse men do to vs, 1. Cor. 12. 2. Cor. 9. we ought to account them receiued of GOD, bicause he alone in verie déed dooth giue vs them, by the ministerie of men, which are second meanes and instrumentall causes therein; so that our thankfulnesse redoundeth to the glorie of God, Matt. 5. 1. Pet. 2. the true and finall end of all our actions or dooings.
The gentiles knew the power of God, Christ is the power of God, therefore the gentiles knowe the power of Christ; and by a consequent, the gentiles are saued.
I denie the consequent, bicause there is a double power of God, that is to wit; [Page 78] there is one power of his creation described in the lawe, and this power onlie did the Gentiles knowe, without the promise of the mediatour, how that God requireth righteousnes, and punisheth the vnrighteous. Gods double power. And there is another power of saluation by Christ the son of God, which is two waies called the power of the father, first naturall, and next of saluation. For although the sonne was with the father, yet the scripture speaketh of him that he is God and man, which was sent into the world for this purpose, that he should be the propitiatour, or obteiner of mercie, and the quickener of mankind. Therefore there was a farre other and greater light of the knowledge of God and faith in Abraham, than there was in Cicero, Plato, and Xenophon, &c.
What is it to keepe the word of Christ?
It is not to kéepe his testament safe in our bosome, or in our chests: but it is certeinlie to determine in our faith, that God is reconciled and at peace with vs, and that our sinnes are freelie forgiuen vs for his sonne Christes sake, and that righteousnes is imputed vnto vs by him, whereby we haue eternall life, and also doo beginne a new obedience, without the which no man can haue the [Page 79] true faith, as the apostle saieth: 1. Tim. 1. Milita bonam militum, retinens fidem & bonam conscientiam: Fight a good fight, kéeping the faith, and a good conscience.
Tell me, Iohn. 8. what is it neuer to sée death, nor to taste of hir, as Christ saieth?
It is, not to feele the sorrowes of death, and of hell, whereof the psalmist saieth: Circundederunt me dolores mortis, & dolores inferni inuenerunt me: Psalm. 17. The sorrowes of death haue compassed me round about, and the paines of hell haue gotten hold on me. Those that are quickened in their faith, doo not sée nor taste of such sorrowes: Quia pacem habent cum Deo per fidem: Rom. 5. Bicause they are at peace with God thorough faith.
Wherein ought a man to take comfort in the time of his persecution? Iohn. 8.
In the example of Christ, at whom the Iewes did cast stones, but Christ escaped from the hands of his enimies, without anie harme. First, bicause the time of his passion appointed of God his father from the beginning was not yet come. Next, bicause that the Messias or the sauiour ought not to die with anie kind of death, Deut. 21. Gala. 3. but by hanging on the tree of the crosse, as it is said: Maledictus pro nobis factus est: He is made accurssed for vs. 1. Cor. 15.
1. Cor. 15.Saint Paule saith, that in the later daie, the sonne will deliuer vp the kingdome to God the father,
Luke. 1.Therefore, the kingdome of Christ shall not be euerlasting, as the angell said it should be.
In this place S. Paule speaketh of the kingdome of Christ in this world, wherby he gathereth together his church and preserueth it against hir enimies. This kingdome of Christes truelie shall end in the last daie, and then he will present his church before his father, who together with the sonne and the Holie-ghost shall be all in all.
Exod. 12.When did the Iewes offer vp their pascall, or figuratiue lambe?
Euer in the first moneth of the yeare, which is March with vs, vpon the twelfe daie in the vernall equinoctium, which lambe signified Christ, whose death is called sinne, Rom. 8. as the apostle saith: Peccato damnauit peccatum in carne: By sinne he damned sinne in the flesh, Hebr. 10. Hebr. 8. when he was offered vp once sufficientlie for our sinnes. No sacrifice then is left vs after the death of Christ, but the sacrifice of righteousnesse, and of thanks giuing. Further, Psalm: 4. Psalm. 50. as the Iewes were woont to offer vp lambes in their ordinarie sacrifices, and euer one lambe at Easter: so Christ is our pascall [Page 81] lambe, as it is said: Ecce agnus Dei, Iohn. 1. qui tollit peccata mundi: Behold the lambe of God, that taketh awaie the sins of the world. The Iewes kept this ceremonie about 1540. yeares. For there are so manie yeares from their comming out of Aegypt, to the yeare of the passion & resurrectiō of Christ, after which time the ceremonie of eating the pascall or typicall lambe ceased.
No man is iustified by onelie knowledge, as the diuell is not iust, nor saued, although there be excellent knowlege in him,
Therefore, it is not rightlie said, The knowledge of God shall iustifie manie. Esai. 53.
I answer to the antecedent. It is a figure of spéech: for the Hebrues in their words of knowing, doo comprehend the effect: as in this saieng: Nouit viam Dominus iustorum: The Lord knoweth the waie of the righteous, Psal. 1. that is to saie; The Lord considereth & regardeth their waie. Also, knowledge here dooth signifie light in our minds; next, the motion of our heart, or the trust of our mind resting on God the father, 1. Tim. 2. Hebr. 4.7.8.9.12. 1. Iohn. 2. Ephes. 3. Rom. 5.8. Iohn. 15. through Christ the onelie mediator betwéene God & man. The diuell and the wicked people haue not this trust & confidence in God, bicause they doo not apprehend and take hold on the sonne of God by faith, neither doo they comfort themselues by his benefits, [Page 82] in the time of fearefulnes of death and sinne; for it is thus said of the diuels: Damines credunt & contremiscunt: Iacob. 2. The diuels beléeue and tremble.
Esaie. 53. Esaie saith of Christ, that he did beare the sinnes of manie,
Therefore, he did not beare the sinnes of all,
[...].And by a consequent, Christes death is not a sufficient sacrifice for all men, and God hath a scroll of those that be elected to eternall life, for which onlie the sonne of God died.
I denie the consequent. For the promise of the gospell is vniuersall, as Christ saieth: Matth. 11. Venite ad me omnes, qui laboratis: Come vnto me all ye that labour. Rom. 3. S. Paule saieth: Non est distinctio: There is no difference. Againe: Rom. 10. Deus est diues in omnes: God is rich towards all. Therefore the prophet maketh no distinction touching the benefits of Christ his death, which is auaileable and sufficient for all men, 1. Ioh. 2. as the apostle saith: Et ipse est propitiatio pro peccatis totius mundi: And he is the propitiation, and the obteinment of mercie for the sinnes of all the whole world: but touching the men themselues, whereof some apprehend the benefits of Christ by faith, and other some willinglie reiect and cast awaie the same from them, so that they themselues be the causers [Page 83] [...]o themselues of their owne damnation, making Christes death rather to serue to their damnation, than to their saluation by their disobedience, and lacke of faith, as it appéereth by them in the parable that were bidden to the mariage, and yet they would not come. Matth. 22. Others expound this word [manie] for all mankind, as here is the like: Matth. 26. Hic calix est noui testamenti, qui pro vobis, & pro multis effunditur in remissionem peccatorum: This cup is of the new testament, which is shed for you and for manie (that is) for all, for the forgiuenes of sinnes.
Died Christ (I praie you tell me) then for all men, or no?
No. Christ died for none, Iohn. 3. Act. 13. but for such as laie hold on him by a liuelie faith, and as for infidels, blasphemers, obstinate sinners, and all such as take plesure to perseuere and continue wilfullie and gréedilie in wickednes, contrarie to their owne conscience, contemptuouslie casting (as it were) Gods mercies from them, his death truelie shall be to them death, and not life.
He that is dead (saith S. Paule) is iustified from sinne, Rom. 5.
Iudas is dead,
Therefore he is iustified, and by a consequent is righteous.
I denie the consequent. First, bicause there is an vnlikenesse in the example. For Christ (of whom the apostle speaketh here) died innocentlie and willinglie, as it is written: Hebru. 5. Voluntate eius sanctificati sumus: We are sanctified by his will. He praied for vs with teares, Et exauditus est propter reuerentiam: And was heard for his reuerence or willing obedience. But Iudas and all other wicked doo die vnwillinglie, and against their wils, by the compulsion of sathan, with fretting and repining against God. Christ truelie perceiued and felt (as it were) a strugling and wrestling in his flesh, Matt. 26. like as he saieth: Spiritus est promptus, caro autem infirma: The spirit is willing, but the flesh is fraile: yet notwithstanding he fretted not, nor was angrie with God; as were Iudas, Saule, and Caine: but willinglie made himselfe obedient to his fathers will, as he himselfe confessed: Non voluntas mea, sed tua fiat: Not my will, but thine (oh father) be fulfilled. Againe, it is written: Oblatus est, quia voluit: He was offered vp, bicause he would willinglie. And so the saints of God, as Iohn, Paule, Peter, and such others, were obedient to the will of God, in their death, and crosse; but yet their will and obedience was farre otherwaies, & differing from the will of the sonne [Page 85] of God, as Christ himselfe said to Peter: Alius te cinget, & ducet quò non vis: Iohn. 21. Another shall girt thée, and lead thée whither thou wouldest not. Further, all saints also are sinners and trespassers, and therefore their obedience is no merit or desert sufficient to purchase either their owne righteousnesse, or anie other mans: as the obedience of Christ is a sufficient merit or desert for to worke the righteousnesse of all the true faithfull people dispersed through the whole world, vpon the face of the earth wheresoeuer.
What is that which we doo call the propitiation of sinnes?
It is the death of the sonne of God, which in Gréeke is [...], a satisfaction and a sacrifice for the sins of mankind. Therfore it comprehendeth both the cause efficient promeriting for vs the forgiuenes of our sins, and the effect, which is the reconciliation of vs with God, and the gift of eternall life.
We are the swéet bread (as S. Paule saith) therfore we néed not to be purged. 1. Cor. 5.
I answer by distinction, we are indéed the swéet bread by imputation, and inchoation, but not in perfection. Therefore it is necessarie that we alwaies increase [Page 86] in new obedience, as the prophets, Christ, and the apostles doo still crie vnto vs, saieng: Agite poenitentiam: Repent, repent; and our sinne therefore is not imputed to vs, bicause Christ is offered vp for vs, Et deleuit chirographum aduersus nos scriptum: And hath put out the hand writing that was written against vs, and hath fastened it to his crosse, whereby he hath wiped awaie our sinnes. The theefe hanging with Christ vpon the crosse is a sufficient testimonie thereof. And further, S. Paule saith: Exuite veterem hominem, & induite nouum: Put off the old man, and put on the new man.
What vse and fruit haue we Christians of the resurrection of Christ?
We haue our iustification. For God dooth forgiue vs our sinnes for Christes sake, which died for vs, and rose againe for our iustification, and reckoneth vs righteous, though the remnant of sinne still hangeth on vs, as S. Paule saith: Christus traditus est in mortem propter peccata nostra, Rom. 4. & resurrexit propter iustificationem nostram: Christ was put to death for our sinnes, and rose againe for our iustification, that is to saie, Christes death is a satisfaction for our sinnes, whereby the wrath of God the father is pacified, and by Christes [Page 87] resurrection, the righteousnesse of Christ is imputed vnto vs, which is begunne in vs here in this world, and finished and perfected with eternall life in the world to come. Whereby Ieremie calleth Christ our iustification. Ierem. 33. And Christ himselfe speaketh of this righteousnes in Oseas, where as it is said: O mors ero mors tua, Ose. 13. morsus tuus ero inferne: Oh death I will be thy death, oh hell I will be thy destruction; that is to saie: I will destroie and abolish death and hell, in such sort that they shall not anie more be able to hurt me, nor my church or congregation from henceforth.
Whie did there manie others rise with Christ after his passion, Matt. 27. as the euangelists doo make mention, and came into the holie citie?
To the end that we should beléeue, This was a figure of the resurrection. that Christ would raise vp his whole church in the latter daie, and that his church should haue eternall saluation, wherein the faithfull shall enioie the fruition and the sight of God, with the most swéete loue of him, during all eternitie; the beginning of which estate of life is perceiued and knowne in the resurrection of Christ, that we should not be doubtfull of the remainder of another and better life, after our temporall death in this [Page 88] world, and that at the generall resurrection, all, both the quicke and dead, shall be rewarded according to their works doone here in this world, good or euill.
He that calleth vpon one God, the maker of heauen and earth, calleth vpon the true God,
The Turkes and Iewes call vpon one God, the maker of heauen and earth,
Therefore they call vpon the true God.
I denie the minor. For the Turkes and Iewes calling vpon one God, they denie him to be the true God, the maker of all things, which is the father of our Lord Iesus Christ. The infidels call not vpon the true God. Therefore they call vpon an idoll, and not vpon the true God. Further, they cannot be certeine by hearesaie; first, bicause they haue no promise; next, bicause they reiect, and (as it were) cast from them the sonne of God, the mediatour, cruellie blaspheme him, and tyrannouslie persecute him in the members of his church, and chosen vessels to saluation.
What is the finall end of Christes incarnation?
It is to béecome a sacrifice for his church, and that he might be present with hir, quicken hir by the gift of the Holie-ghost, [Page 89] and might raise vs vp vnto eternall life. Therfore the sonne of God is not onelie a redeemer reconciling vs to his father by the merit of his death, but he is a sauiour in effect, Esaie. 7. Matth 1. Dani. 12. whereby he is called Emanuell, that is to saie, God with vs. And the prophet saith, Christ standeth: Pro filijs populi, propugnans eos: For to defend the children of the people.
For how manie causes is the church of God subiect to the crosse of afflictions?
There be sixe causes of the churches afflictions. The first cause is 1 common, and pertinent to all men, that is to wit, sinne, or the corruption of nature, following the fall of our first parents, and spred abroad by generation into all their posteritie. And of this cause it was said: Gene. 3. In quacunque die comederis, morte morieris: Whensoeuer thou doost eate of the trée, thou shalt die the death. And againe: Rom. 5. Per vnum hominem peccatum in mundum intrauit, & per peccatum mors: By one man sinne came into the world, and by sinne came death. The philosophers make will and matter the cause of sickenesse and of death, as the substance of an apple is the cause of his putrifaction. But these are not the principall causes. The principall and chéefe cause of sickenesse [Page 90] and death, is sinne, for the which mans nature is subiect to corruption and death.
2 And the second cause truelie, whie the church or congregation of God is more subiect to the crosse and miserie than other men are, is the diuell, which bicause he hateth God, he inuadeth his church the more gréeuouslie than anie other companie.
3 The third cause is, bicause God would haue his wrath against sinne to be perceiued and knowne; which the wicked companie and the epicurean sort doo securelie contemne and scoffe at.
4 The fourth cause is, for that the church hath also hir sinnes, which must be mortified by the crosse of afflictions.
5 The fift is, bicause God would haue our afflictions to be the testimonies of his presence in his church, when he deliuereth vs by his diuine power.
6 The sixt cause is, that we should be certeine that there remaineth another iudgement, in the which the godlie that haue béene afflicted in this life, as Iohn the baptist and Paule with others shall be rewarded; and the wicked, as Herod, Nero, and such other shall be punished with eternall death: bicause it is impossible, that the godlie people should be alwaies in miserie, [Page 91] and the wicked contrariewise should be still in pleasure.
Whie dooth Christ call the diuell, Iohn. 16. the prince of the world?
He dooth not call him so, in respect that he is the maker and the guider of the world, which is the onelie worke of God; but bicause he dooth beare rule in worldlie men, and such as are not new borne, which securelie giue themselues ouer to sinne, whom the diuell leadeth whither it listeth him, according to his will and pleasure, holding them still to be his bondslaues, captiues, and thralles, as long as they liue licentiouslie. The holie apostle also calleth him the gouernour of such liuers, Ephe. 2. saieng: Ye walked in time past according to the course of this world: Ac iuxta principem, cui potestas est aeris, qui est spiritus nunc agens in filijs cō tumacibus: And after the gouernour that ruleth in the aier, the spirit that now worketh in the children of vnbeléefe and disobedience.
What dooth Christ meane by the world, in the gospell? Iohn. 16.
He meaneth worldlie and carnall men, which falslie and wickedlie iudge of Christ, and of the doctrine of his church, of whom there be foure sorts. First, the mightie men of power iudge the doctrine of the gospell [Page 92] to be Seditiosam, Luc. 23. seditious.
1. Cor. 1.The wisemen of the world suppose it to be Stultitiam, foolishnesse.
Matt. 26.The iusticiaries accompt it to be Blasphemiam in Deum, blasphemie against God.
The Epicures doo esteeme the gospell to be Anilem fabulam commentitiam, an old wines fained fable; Psalm. 14. as for example: The foole said in his heart, Non est Deus: There is no God. And the first psalme calleth such persons, Derisores, scorners. Thus we sée that these foure kind of people; mightie men of power; worldlie wisemen; iusticiaries, that is, such as suppose they can make themselues righteous in the sight of God, by the merit of their owne workes; and Epicures, which do make Summum bonum, their chéefe felicitie, to be in all voluptuous, carnall, and licentious liuing, with greedines thereof, beléeuing as the Saduces did, that after our death there is no part of man remaining. These foure sorts are taken for the world, in the scriptures of God.
Iohn. 9.God dooth not heare sinners, All men are sinners,
God therefore dooth heare no man.
I will answer by distinction: first vnto the maior, God dooth not heare sinners, that is; such sinners as doo not repent. [Page 93] Againe, to the minor: All men are sinners in respect of their corrupt nature, but such as doo repent, that is to wit, such as acknowledge their sinnes, conuert from them, and flie vnto God for the mediatours sake, and haue not againe anie purpose of wickednesse in their minds, such certeinlie are heard of God, not for their owne worthinesse, but for Christes sake, as he himselfe saith: Iohn. 16. Quaecunque petieritis patrem in nomine meo, dabit vobis: Whatsoeuer ye shall aske the father in my name, he will giue it you.
Manie martyrs praied to be deliuered from tyrants, but they were not heard,
Therefore this promise of Christ: Iohn. 16. Whatsoeuer ye shall aske the father in my name, he will giue it you, is not vniuersallie true.
I answer to the antecedent by distinction. The things which we desire of God, are of two sorts. Some be spirituall, as the forgiuenesse of our sinnes, and the inheritance of eternall life, which are granted vs, according to this saieng: Nolo mortem impij, Ezech. 18. sed vt conuertatur ac viuat: I will not the death of a sinner, but that he should conuert and liue. Againe, My shéepe heare my voice, Iohn. 10. Et ego do eis vitam aeternam: And I giue them eternall life. [Page 94] Other gifts of God are corporall, which he dooth not streightwaie giue them when we aske them, or not after that sort as we doo aske them, bicause God will haue his church subiect to afflictions, and to shew hir obedience vnto him therein. Therefore corporall things are to be asked with the condition of the glorie of God, of our saluation, and the profit of our neighbour. And often times God giueth not that that we aske, but that which is much better than that we aske: bicause we haue not the perfect knowledge, to aske such gifts as are most requisite and necessarie for vs. As it well appeareth by the answer that Christ made vnto the mother of Zebedeis children, which would haue hir two sonnes Iohn and Iames, to sit the one on his right hand, and the other on his left hand, in his kingdome, saieng vnto them: Matt. 20. Nescitis quid petitis: Ye wot not what ye aske.
What is the kingdome of Christ?
The kingdome of Christ is to sit at the right hand of his eternall father, defending his church, preseruing the ministerie of his gospell, gathering together his congregation by the voice of his word, quickening the hearts of his faithfull people by the gift of [Page 95] the Holie-ghost, and finallie raising them vp from death, and afterwards giuing them eternall life. And therefore he is called Emanuell, Matth. 1. that is, God with vs. And S. Paule speaketh of the ascension of Christ, and of his spirituall kingdome out of the psalme: saieng; Psalm. 68. He ascended on high, and led captiuitie captiue, Ephe. 4. that is to wit: he hath ouercome, and as it were caried awaie in a triumph, sinne, death, hell, and the diuell, his enimies and his churches, which before held vs captiues; and hath giuen gifts vnto men, as the Holie-ghost, prophets, apostles, euangelists, doctors, and pastors, for the edifieng of the saints, and is effectuall in them, euer preseruing his church. This is the spirituall kingdome of Christ, euen vnto the latter daie: and then this kingdome shall cease, as S. Paule saieth: 1. Cor. 15. Tunc tradet regnum patri: Then he shall deliuer vp the kingdome to his father, that is to saie, this spirituall kingdome, which in his church is gathered together by the outward voice of his gospell, he alwaies preseruing and defending the same. And afterward, the father, the sonne, and the Holie-ghost, visiblie shall reigne together in their saints, and that kingdome then shall be for euer without end: 1. Cor. 15. Quum Deus erit omnia in omnibus: When God shall be all in all. This [Page 96] is, that kingdome which all true christians do hope to haue, earnestlie looke for, and dailie praie for in the Lords praier, Matth. 6. saieng: Adu [...] niat regnum tuum: Thy kingdome come, which is also in this world, by promoting and setting foorth of his glorious word.
Iohn. 17.Christ said, he praied not for his disciples, that is, for his church,
And S. Paule saieth, that Christ still maketh intercession for vs,
Therefore Christ and Paule are contrarie.
This saieng of Christ is not to be vnderstanded exclusiuelie, but comprehensiuelie. Bicause he dooth not exclude himselfe, which saieth: Ego non solùm oraturus pro vobis, I will not onelie praie for you, but you also beléeuing in me, shall praie, and you shall come vnto the father, which will heare you calling on him, bicause you haue confidence and trust in mine intercession and merits.
Exod. 14.Must men praie in expresse words, or onelie in their thought, after the example of Moses?
No, but we must vse the recitall of words, bicause the Holie-ghost, and affect is stirred vp and kindled by the word, as Dauid soong his psalmes not onelie in heart and spirit, but also with voice and musicall instrument. [Page 97] And so Christ prescribed a certeine forme of praieng to his disciples and church, Matth. 6. saieng; Ye shall praie thus: Our father, &c.
Christ said to his disciples: Hitherto ye haue asked nothing in my name.
Therefore, Iohn. 16. the apostles did not truelie call on Christ, neither were they heard before this time.
Christ here speaketh of the crosses, corporall afflictions, and the necessaries of this world, which they had plentiouslie while Christ was present with them; therefore they trusting in his visible presence, did aske by Christ no corporall gifts of God, for that they thought with themselues they could lacke nothing as long as they had such a Lord & maister present with them, which gaue them all things necessarie for this life, & alwaies defended them against their Iudaicall enimies and others, & finallie would giue them eternall life.
Christ maketh intercession for vs to his father, Rom. 5.
The Holie-ghost also praieth for vs with vnspeakeable gronings,
What difference is there then, betwéene the praier of Christ and the Holie-ghost?
I doo answer: that the Holie-ghost is not the mediatour betwéene God and [Page 98] man, neither offereth he vp anie merit, or price of our redemption to the father. But the sonne is our mediatour and redéemer, bicause he hath pacified the wrath of his father. The Holie-ghosts praier is the inclining of our hearts by the voice of the gospell, with a certeine inward motion to inuocation, and calling vpon God, and helpeth all such as call vpon him. The sonne of God offereth vp [...], or the price of our redemption for vs, as Christ himselfe saieth: Iohn. 17. Ego meipsum sanctifico pro eis: I doo sanctifie my selfe for them, that is as much to saie, as I die for them, and doo pacifie the wrath of mine eternall father by the sacrifice of my death.
The rich man that wore purple and silke, and banketted delicatelie, was damned,
Luc. 16.Therefore fine clothes, as silke and purple, with delicate fare, are naught, and damned things.
I denie the consequent: bicause it is the fallacie of the accident. For the rich man was not damned for his purple and silke, neither for his delicate fare, which indéed are all the good creatures of God, and manie good and godlie men haue well vsed the same, as Dauid, Salomon, and others. But [Page 99] [...]irst he was damned, for that he did abuse the [...]ame good gifts, to wit: he put his whole trust and confidence in those things, as though they should helpe and deliuer him in the daie of wrath and vengeance. Next he was damned for his securitie, and the contempt of God and his neighbour, whom he did not succour with his riches as he ought to doo, therefore he was cast awaie from God, and damned, according as the holie apostle saieth: Iacob. 2. Iudicium absque misericordia erit ei, qui misericordiam non praestiterit: He shall haue iudgement without mercie, which sheweth no mercie. The same sinnes therefore were reigning in this rich man, which God reprooued in the Sodomites, saieng: Ezech. 6. Peccatum Sodomae, superbia, saturitas panis, prosperitas & otium, & manum pauperi non porrigebant: The sinne of Sodome, was pride, fulnesse of bread, prosperitie, and idlenesse, and they did not reach out their hands to the poore. These were the sinnes wherefore the rich glutton was damned, and not his riches, good clothes, and delicate fare, which are the great blessings of God, and are to be vsed alwaies with thankes giuing, without anie offense. For thus it is written of riches: Benedictio Domini diuites facit: Prou. 10. The blessing of the Lord maketh men rich. And out of all question, if men would followe Christes [Page 100] proposition and rule, touching riches, where he saieth: Primùm quaerite regnum Dei, & iustici [...] eius: First séeke ye the kingdome of God, and the righteousnes thereof, and then all these other things, meaning thereby riches, and worldlie blessings, shall be giuen vnto vs more easilie, and with the lesse trauell, bicause it is a small thing in the sight of the Lord, to make a poore man rich, and a rich man poore.
The Stoiks argument.That thing is good, which maketh men good,
Riches doo not make men good,
Therefore riches are not good.
First I answer by distinction to the maior. A good thing is twofold, morall and naturall: morall, which maketh good things, as vertues; and a naturall good thing, as riches, health, and honors. These doo not make things good, yet they are themselues the excellent and good gifts of God, which men oftentimes abuse to euill purpose, Luc. 16. as did the rich man in the gospell to his owne destruction.
What is ment in the scripture of God, by the bosome of Abraham?
Thereby is ment the gathering togither of them which are graffed into the promise of Abraham: into this companie (to wit) of the holie patriarchs, prophets, apostles, [Page 101] martyrs, and saints, all they are caried by the angels of God, that depart out of this life in [...]he true state of faith and saluation, bicause [...]uch cannot miscarrie, as doo commit them [...]elues in sure confidence to the mercifull tui [...]ion of Christ.
What is the chéefest thing, whereof euerie one ought to be most carefull [...]uring all his life time?
Euerie one ought to be most carefull; first, Matth. 16. how he can be saued in the daie of iudgement, before Gods tribunall seate, and so to come to euerlasting life; next, to [...]iue according to Gods holie will, during our [...]ife, 1. Pet. 5. whereby we shall receiue an vncorruptible crowne in the end, when euerie man shall go to the reaping of that fruit which he hath sowne in this world.
Are not all people discharged of their sinne, Rom. 8. seeing that Christ hath paied the punishment due for them?
None are discharged from the paines which our sinnes deserue, Iohn. 3. Colos. 2. sauing those that take hold vpon Christ and his mercies with a true faith.
Lazarus is saued,
Lazarus was a poore man, &c. Luke. 16.
Therefore pouertie dooth saue vs, and by a [Page 102] consequent, other good works also, so that we are not iustified and saued by faith onelie.
I denie the consequent, for that there is a fallacie in the word, according that it is simplie spoken. And the euangelist making mention of Lazarus pouertie, compriseth therein all his obedience, that is to saie, his repentance, his faith in the promised Messias his deliuerer, his patience, and other vertues, which were testimonies and signes of his faith. Rom. 3.4.5. For we are iustified and saued by faith onelie, therefore, bicause faith taketh handfast on Christ; not for anie merit or vertues of ours, which are too weake and beggerlie to satisfie the wrath of God expressed in his lawe.
Luke. 14.Wherefore is God the father in the parable ment to be the rich man, which had his ghests to supper?
Genesi. 2.Bicause God hath made man after his owne image. Then next, bicause God dooth loue man well being made after his image for Christes sake, which tooke vpon him the massie lumpe of our flesh. Iohn. 14. 1. Cor. 6. And thirdlie, bicause man is, Templum Dei, the temple of God.
Such things as hinder and let the studie and loue of godlines, are euill, meet to be refused and reiected,
[Page 103]Riches, power, honors, and mariage doo hinder and let the studie and loue of godlinesse, Luc. 14. as in the parable of the gospell,
Therefore they are euill, and to be refused of Christians.
I denie the consequent, bicause riches, power, honours, and mariage doo not hinder and let the studie and loue of godlines onelie of themselues, or of their owne nature, but by an accident, that is to saie, through the euill disposition of men, which preferre bodilie gifts before heauenlie and eternall gifts. The abuse therefore of these things is reprooued, and not the things themselues, which are the good gifts of God: and all the good gifts and creatures of God may be vsed, as meat, drinke, cloth, and so foorth; yet not for pleasure, and vnto riot, but for necessitie, Matth. 14. and that with thanks giuing alwaies, as Christ himselfe giueth vs in example, that he neuer brake bread, without the giuing of thanks. Ephe. 5. And the holie apostle also teacheth vs alwaies to vse Gratiarum actione: The giuing of thanks.
What is the house of God and who are they that are called into it?
The house of God, is the number of the elected people, or the church, or congregation, which is congregated or gathered together [Page 104] vnto repentance, and to the knowledge of the truth in Christ; first by the prophets, next by Iohn the baptist, thirdlie by Christ himselfe and his apostles: and there are some dailie called into that houshold, by the ministers of the church. But bicause the Iewes did not obeie the calling of God, he reiected and refused them, Act. 14. as S. Paule saieth: Vobis oportebat primùm loqui sermonem Dei: It was meet that the word of God should be first preached vnto you: but séeing you put it from you and thinke your selues vnworthie of euerlasting life; lo, we turne vnto the gentiles: S [...] enim nobis praecepit Dominus: For so the Lo [...] commanded vs. Againe the prophet saieth Posui te in lucem gentium, Esaie. 49. vt sis salus mea, vsque [...] extremum terrae: I haue made thée the light [...] the gentiles, that thou maist be my health, v [...] to to the end of the world.
Contrition, faith, and new obedience, are the thrée parts of repentance but canst thou make me a seuerall descriptio [...] of these thrée particularlie?
Contrition.I can. Contrition is therefor [...] a compunction and pricking in our conscience, rising and comming of the knowledge of the wrath of God against sinne and wickednesse, and a certeine sorrowe, for that w [...] [Page 105] haue offended God, as the prodigall sonne said to his father, when he did acknowledge his sinnes: Pater peccaui in coelum & coram te, Luke. 15. & non sum dignus vocari filius tuus: Father I haue sinned against heauen and against thée, and I am no more worthie to be called thy sonne. 1. Cor. 5. Colo. 3. Rom. 6.8. Ephe. 4. And S. Paule calleth contrition the mortification or killing of the old man, meaning thereby our fleshlie lusts, sensualitie, and carnall liuing.
Next, Faith. faith is the assenting and agréeing to euerie word of God, and to his promise of grace made vnto vs in his gospell, whereby we haue an assured knowledge of his fatherlie good will towards vs, Coloss. 2. Hebru. 10. through the bloud of Christ, and an affiance in the same fatherlie goodnesse towards vs alwaies witnessed in his said gospell, for Christes sake onelie, and not for anie merit or vertue of ours, which we vnprofitable seruants can be able to doo.
And thirdlie new obedience is described by S. Paule, where he saieth: New obedience. Milita bonam militiam, retineto fidem, & bonam conscientiam: 1. Tim. 1. Fight a good fight, kéepe the faith, and a good conscience, that is to saie: when we obeie our vocation or calling, and commit nothing wickedlie and contrarie to the testimonie of a pure and a good conscience, then we shew that new obedience. [Page 106] For the performance whereof we haue néed of the presence and aid of the Holie-ghost, Iohn. 15. in the infirmitie and weakenes of our nature, as it is said: Sine me nihil potestis facere: Without me ye can doo nothing. Rom. 8. Phil. 2. Againe, Spiritus opem fert infirmitati nostrae: The Holie-ghost helpeth our infirmitie. Therefore it is God which worketh in vs both the will and also the déed, euen of good will, whereby we are able to doo such things as may be acceptable in his sight. And then this obedience is the fruit and testimonie of a true faith, and of our conuersion to God, which hath coupled with it alwaies an endeuour of godlie life.
How manie errors doo the papists vse and teach, touching the doctrine of repentance?
1 They doo vse six errors. The first is, they hold an opinion, and teach, that we must haue sufficient contrition. Although it be necessarie, that we haue some contrition or sorow for the sinnes which we haue committed against God, Ioel. 1. as the prophet saith, Scindite corda vestra, Rent your hearts and not your garments; againe, Tristitia quae ad poenitentiam est, vtilis est, The sorrow that causeth repentance is profitable: yet contrition is not sufficient to merit or deserue anie goodnesse at [Page 107] Gods hand.
Their second is, they saie that contrition is 2 the merit of reconciliation and forgiuenesse of our sins. Which is an horrible contumelie and a reproch against God, and a snare of conscience; bicause we can neuer know when our contrition is sufficient. Therefore we cannot be certeine of the remission of our sinnes, and reconciliation with God. And this false opinion is a derogation, and as it were a diminishing of the death and passion of Christ, which is a full, equiualent, and sufficient price and ransome for the sinnes of all true and faithfull beléeuers. [...],
Their third errour is, that they make no 3 mention of faith in the definition of their repentance. For thus they describe their repen [...]ance: Repentance is, to lament our sinnes [...]hat be past, and not to commit & doo againe [...]he same lamented sinnes. This is an insuffi [...]ient and false definition; bicause it is not suf [...]cient to acknowledge our sinnes, and to be [...]orie for the committing of them, Genesi. 4. Matt. 10.26. as Caine, A [...]hitophel, and Iudas was; but it is requisite [...]hat we flie vnto faith, which resteth in the promises of God, and susteineth hir selfe therein, [...]hat she should not despaire in the terrours of [...]nne, as Peter and the théefe on the crosse did, Iohn. 21. [Page 108] through their faith, rid themselues from the dread and feare of sinne and death.
4 Their fourth error is, they saie, that the numbering of all the offenses which a man dooth knowe and remember is verie necessarie, which is the torment of conscience, and vnpossible to be doone, as the prophet saieth: De licta quis intelligit? Psalm. 18. Who knoweth his sinnes▪ And, Ab occultis meis munda me: Clense m [...] from my secret sinnes. Yet priuate confession is to be reteined; first, for the vtilitie and profit of priuate communication; next, [...] the reteining of absolution and concord of the church.
5 Their fift error is, of satisfactions, which th [...] haue taught to be works, not of dutie, or commanded of God. And they feine falselie, tha [...] satisfactions are the merit of our reconciliat [...] on with God, or that God dooth forgiue vs o [...] sinnes for these externall rites and outwar [...] workes sake, and that eternall punishment are fullie recompensed and satisfied in the [...] Which is a most detestable and wicked opin [...] on. For the passion and death of Christ onl [...] is the merit of our reconciliation with Go [...] and is the full debt and price of mans redem [...] tion. And Christ saieth: Frustrame colunt ma [...] datis hominum: They worship me in vaine aft [...] [Page 109] mens traditions.
Their sixt error is, they teach men, that although 6 they be sufficient repentant for their sinnes, confessing them vnto almightie God, and vse satisfaction or restitution; yet they cannot, nor ought (saie they) to be certeine, whether they be in the grace and fauour of God or no, haue remission of their sinnes, and so to become heires of eternall life; contrarie to the manifest words of the scripture, which requireth faith in vs, and then certeinlie promiseth to such as be truelie repentant, and beléeue in Christ, the reconciliation with God, forgiuenesse of sinnes, righteousnesse, and eternall life, according to this saieng: Iohn. 3. Sic Deus dilexit mundum, vt filium suum vnigenitum daret, vt omnis qui credit in eum, non pereat, sed vitam habeat aeternam: So God loued the world, that he gaue his onelie begotten sonne, to the end that all that beleeue in him should not perish, but haue life euerlasting.
¶Touching canonicall satisfactions.
The restitution of theft is necessarie; bicause (as it is said) The sinne is not forgiuen, except the thing taken awaie be restored,
The restitution of theft, is a satisfaction,
[Page 110]Therefore a canonicall satisfaction is necessarie.
I denie the consequent. For in the minor, satisfaction dooth signifie a worke of dutie, and commanded of God, perteining to contrition and new obedience, according to this saieng: Ephes. 4. Qui furatus est, non furetur amplius: Let him that stole, steale no more. And in the conclusion, satisfaction is taken for a worke, not of dutie, or commanded of God, whereby the papists signifie, that God is pacified thereby, and that the paines of hell and purgatorie are recompensed and taken awaie therein. And the maior is vniuersallie true; bicause it is requisite in our conuersion to GOD, that we cast from vs the purpose of perseuering and continuing in wickednesse, contrarie to our conscience, as we are taught thus: Milita bonam militiam, 1. Tim. 1. retinens fidem, & bonam conscientiam: Fight a good fight, kéeping the faith, and a good conscience. And if it may be, and possible to be doone, the thing that is taken awaie, must be restored againe.
What dooth the parable of the prodigall sonne in the gospell teach vs?
It teacheth vs that God receiueth into grace and fauor for Christ [Page 111] his sake, all them that conuert and turne vnto him after their fall; as the louing father receiued his prodigall sonne that came vnto him, and asked pardon for his sinnes, Luc. 15. which he forgaue him, and tooke him into his continuall fauour againe: contrarie to the hereticall opinion of Nouatianus, which was a priest of Rome, and sometime chapleine to S. Cyprian, and afterward began an heresie called Catharon, which was, that they that had renounced the faith by sinne after baptisme, should not be receiued to repentance againe.
Saint Paule saith, 1. Cor. 11. If we iudge our selues, we shall not be punished of the Lord,
We iudge our selues, that is, we punish our selues by satisfactions,
Therefore eternall paines are recompensed and taken awaie by canonicall satisfactions.
I denie the minor; bicause we iudge not our selues by canonicall satisfactions deuised by man, according to that saieng: Frustra me colunt mandatis hominum: They worship me in vaine after the traditions of men. Againe, I answer to the saieng of S. Paule, which he speaketh not of the externall and feined rites, but of the true and perfect repentance or turning vnto God, whereby eternall [Page 112] punishment is vtterlie taken awaie. Moreouer, corporall punishments are appointed vs, to put vs in remembrance of the greatnesse of sinne, and of the wrath of God, which he beareth against sinners; 2 Reg. 11. 4. Reg. 21. Zachar 1. as Dauid, Manasses, and the Niniuits were punished for their amendment. When men doo earnestlie repent, God withdraweth his punishments, as it is written: Conuertimini ad me, & ego conuertar ad v [...] Turne ye vnto me, and I will turne me vnto you, saith the Lord.
When we consider the afflictions, perils and death of Iohn Baptist, Esaie was Manasses father in lawe, who commanded him to be cut in sunder with a sawe. Esaie, Ieremie slaine of his owne people. Ieremie, Paule beheaded [...]nder Nero. Paule, and such other doctors of the church, which were murthered of tyrants, what ought we thereby to learne?
We ought to learne thereby, that there remaineth a life after this world, wherein God will glorifie Iohn the baptist, Esaie, Ieremie, Paule, and such others, which receiued testimonie that they pleased God in their life time: and that there is a iudgement also, wherein God will take vengeance of all tyrants, as of Herod, Nero, Dioclesian, and such others. Againe, it is necessarie that we be made like vnto the image of the sonne of God in afflictions, that we may be made partakers also of his glorie, according to this saieng: [Page 113] Quòdsi mortui sumus cum Christo, Rom. 6. credimus quòd viuemus cum illo: If so be that we be dead with Christ, we beléeue that we also shall liue with him. Further: Si sufferimus, 2. Tim. 2. & conregnabimus: If we suffer with him, we shall also reigne together with him.
Christ saith: Iudge not, Luke. 6. and you shall not be iudged,
Therefore the iudgement of the magistrate and of the church are forbidden thereby.
I denie the consequent; bicause Christ forbiddeth priuate iudgements, which are doone of priuate affections, without vocation or order appointed of God. Also rash iudgements, as false accusations, suspicions, and slanders. Therefore this generall saieng of Christ is to be restrained into a certeine species or kind of iudgements. And he addeth a promise: Et non iudicabimini: Luke. 6. And you shall not be iudged, that is to saie, God also will couer your sinnes, and will mitigate the punishment due for them. For looke how we shew our selues to our neighbours, so God will shew himselfe to vs. As Christ saieth: Qua mensura mensi fueritis, remetietur vobis: Matth. 18. Looke what measure ye mete, you shall haue the like measure againe. And moreouer: Si non remiseritus quisque fratrisuo, neque pater vester remittet vobis: [Page 114] If euerie one forgiue not his brother, neither shall your heauenlie father forgiue you.
Luke. 6.Christ saieth: Iudge not, and ye shall not be iudged; forgiue, and ye shall be forgiuen; giue and it shall be giuen you,
Therefore our courtesie, equitie, and the forgiuing of our neighbours offenses, and our almesdéeds doo merit and deserue the forgiuenesse of our sinnes.
I denie the consequent; bicause the promises of God are double, and of two sorts: the one promise is of grace, of the forgiuenesse of our sinnes, and of eternall life, which spirituall gifts are fréelie giuen vs for our mediators sake the sonne of God, to the end they should be certeine, and that Christ thereby might haue his due honor. Other of his promises are bodilie gifts, whereby God dooth garnish and recompense good works in this life, Pro. 19. as it is said of almesdéeds and liberalitie towards the poore: Qui dat pauperi foeneratur Domino: He that giueth to the poore lendeth vnto the Lord; that is as much to saie: God dooth the more increase his substance with gaines, that he shall not be brought vnto pouertie.
How can our good works, or our obedience towards the lawe of God, be acceptable [Page 115] or pleasant vnto him?
When our person is righteous or accepted vnto God by faith in Christ, then our works please him, as it is said of Abel: Respexit Deus ad Abel & sacrificia eius: Genesi. 4. The Lord regarded Abel and his sacrifices, bicause the person of Abel was righteous, through his faith in the promised séed: therefore his sacrifices and workes were plesant vnto GOD. But Caines sacrifices pleased not God, bicause his person was not righteous, that is, he was not accepted with God, through his incredulitie and vnbeléefe. For whatsoeuer is not done of faith, is sinne, and displeaseth God, although it shine neuer so much in outward shew, and séemeth to be good in the sight and iudgement of man.
What difference is there (I praie you shew me) betweene the spirit and the soule?
The spirit representeth in vs the nature of God, and worketh in vs a spirituall life, or the renewing of our mind, which is brought to passe by the Holie-ghost, and the externall voice of the gospell: and the spirit is one substance with the soule. But in the soule there are manie powers, as wit, will, and memorie: yet the spirit is the most pure and furthest [Page 116] from corruption, the most high and diuine portion of our soule. Our soule is the cause of our naturall life, & of all the powers and actions thereof: yet in vs she dooth neither good nor euill, though she taketh part of the sensible wits and naturall motions, but she maketh vs indifferent, so that if she take part with the spirit, then she is hir selfe become spirituall also, and maketh vs vertuous and obedient to God; but if she take part with the flesh, she shall growe out of kind into the maner of the flesh, and so to become disobedient and rebellious to God and his lawes. The spirit desireth nothing, but supernaturall and heauenlie things; the flesh delighteth in worldlie pleasures, and desireth to haue delicate things. But our soule desireth to haue nothing but necessarie things. Esai. 26. Esaie maketh mention of the soule and spirit, saieng: My soule shall desire and long for thée in the night, and in my spirit and my heart strings I will wake in the morning to please thée. Daniel saieth also: In cant. 3. puerorum. Spiritus & animae iustorum laudent Dominum: Let the spirits and soules of the iust men praise the Lord. Luke. 1. The blessed virgine Marie in hir canticle reciteth the soule and the spirit. In libro primo. Saint Origen writing vpon the Epistle to the Romanes diuideth man into thrée [Page 117] parts, to wit, the spirit, the soule, and the flesh; happilie following the opinion of S. Paule, who writeth thus: Vt integer spiritus vester, 1. Thes. 5. & anima, & corpus, sine querela in aduentu Domini nostri Iesu Christi conseruetur: That your spirit, your soule, and your bodie, may be kept cleane and vncorrupt, that ye be not blamed or accused at the comming of our Lord Iesus Christ. This (I hope) is sufficient to prooue the three parts of man, and also sufficeth for the description of the spirit and the soule of man.
Againe, what difference is there betwéene Animus and Anima: for I haue heard schoolemen saie there is a difference betwéene them?
In déed the schoolemen doo saie, that Animus is the mind, the will of man, affection, delectation, wrath: and sometime they take it for the soule it selfe. But Anima is life, breath, and the verie soule, which is a substance created, inuisible, most like vnto our immortall God, hauing none image or figure, but onelie of hir immortall creator. And they saie that Anima viuimus, we liue by the soule; Ac animo sapimus, and are wise by the mind.
Are all men receiued of God into grace, and so saued, or no?
All men are not receiued in the grace of God, and so saued, but onelie [...] as doo acknowledge their sinnes and infirm [...] ties, and doo flie for succour in all afflictions both of bodie and of mind, vnto Christ our onlie mediatour. Esaie. 57. For the prophet dooth saie: V [...] habitat Dominus? Where dwelleth the Lord? H [...] maketh answer himselfe, and saieth: In spirit contrito & corde humiliato: In a contrite spir [...] and an humble heart.
How manie sorts or degrées [...] men are there, touching acceptance wi [...] God?
1 There are thrée kinds of sorts First prophane persons and Epicures, whic [...] perseuere and continue in their wickednes contrarie to their owne conscience, against whom the holie apostle speaketh: 1. Cor. 6. Nolite errar [...] Be not deceiued; Scortatores & adulteri non possunt intrare in regnum Dei; Whoremongers and adulterers, cannot enter into the kingdome of God. Rom. 5. Againe: Si secundum carnem vixeritie, moriemini: If ye liue after the flesh, ye shall die. For carnall liuers cannot (without true repentance) receiue a spirituall reward after this life.
2 The second sort are proud persons and hypocrits, which doo trust in their owne holinesse [Page 119] and wisedome, and haue good opinion of themselues, despising all others in respect of themselues, perceiuing a moth in other mens eies, that is, Matt. 7. finding a small fault in an other mans life, and yet not willing to sée the beame that is in their owne eies. These two sorts of people, carnall epicures, and proud hypocrits, as long as they be such and so continue, they are not receiued of God, and so saued in the end.
The third sort are conuerts, such as turne 3 vnto God, acknowledging their owne infirmities, and flie vnto him for succour, in a sure confidence and trust of our mediatour Christ, and such are they that Christ dooth call to him, where he saieth: Matth. 11. Venite ad me omnes qui laboratis, & onerati estis, & ego reficiam vos: Come vnto me all ye that labour and are heauie laden, and I will refresh you.
How manie things are requisite and necessarie for such as truelie repent and turne vnto God?
They must haue two things: first contrition, or the acknowledging of their vnworthines, as S. Peter acknowledged himselfe not to be worthie of the presence of Christ, saieng: Exi a me Domine: Luke. 5. Lord depart awaie from me: and then he [Page 120] setteth downe a reason, whie he would haue him depart: Quia homo peccator sum: Bicause I am (saieth he) a sinfull man. Next, they must haue faith, whereby we are out of all doubt, that God receiueth vs freelie, for and by his sonne Christ, and by confidence in him we come vnto God the father, desiring his grace and aid, as the apostle saieth: Per hunc filium habemus accessum ad patrem: Rom. 5. We haue accesse to God the father by his sonne, and by faith in him we drawe nigh vnto God with a sure confidence, Ephe. 2.3. knowing that God the father dooth heare vs for his Christes sake. Contrition and faith are ioined together in the psalme, Psalm. 146. where it is said: Beneplacitum est Domino super timentes eum, & in eis quisperant super misericordiam eius: The Lord is well pleased with them that doo feare him, and in all them that put their trust in his mercie. All the scripture dooth preach of the feare of God, of contrition, and of faith, wherevnto are referred (as to the chéefe causes of our saluation) all the saiengs and examples of the holie scripture.
Bicause such doo beare Aesops wallet vpon their shoulders, into the former part whereof they put other mens faults, and be euer tooting and prieng vpon them, being [Page 121] still before their eies: and into the hinder part they put their owne faults, and cast them behind them: whereby it commeth to passe, that they quicklie forget their owne lewdnesse, and yet haue an hundred eies as Argos had, to looke vpon other mens actions, but are as blind as wants in consideration of their owne dooings.
Christ saith: Matth. 5. It was said vnto men of the old time, Thou shalt not kill,
Therefore it was not spoken vnto vs.
The fallacie lieth in equiuocation; that is, in diuerse significations to one word or matter. Christ dooth not signifie here anie certeine time or age of men, but the order, course, or sequele of time; to wit, the morall lawe was published or recited by Moses vnto the Israelites, by the expresse voice of God: which lawe was first graffed in the minds of men, and afterwards obscured againe, wherefore it was often repeated. Therefore the morall lawe, Exod. 20. or the lawe of the ten commandements, dooth obligate and bind all men, of what time or estate so euer they be, either to obedience, or to abide the punishment that is due for their disobedience. Bicause that law is the eternall and the vnmooueable rule of [Page 122] the wisedome and righteousnesse of God, wherevnto he will haue all men to be conformable and obedient.
Rom. 6. Paule saieth: Ye are not vnder the lawe, but vnder grace,
Therefore we are not bound to the lawe.
I denie the consequent, bicause the fallacie lieth in the figure of his Species. For the apostle signifieth by (not to be vnder the lawe) not to be vnder the condemnation of the lawe; but to be deliuered by Christ from the cursse of the lawe, vnto the obedience whereof, or to the punishment all people are bound, according to this saieng: Deut. 37. Maledictus omnis, qui non manserit in omnibus his, quae scripta sunt in libro legis, vt faciat ea: Curssed be euerie one that abideth not in all those things that be written in the booke of the lawe, to doo them.
It is a rule among the lawyers: that no man ought to be punished for his thoughts, Affections are naturall motions, as gladnesse, sorrowe, desire, wrath, hope and feare.
Therefore wrath and such other affections are no sinnes, and ought not to be punished.
I answer by distinction. The lawyers meane as touching politicall or worldlie iudgements, which doo onelie punish [Page 123] externall and outward offenses; but God dooth punish also our inward thoughts, for it is written: Deus est scrutator cordium: Psalm. 7. God is the searcher of our hearts. And S. Paule saieth: Non solùm morte digni sunt, Rom. 1. qui faciunt peccata, sed etiam qui facientibus consentiunt: They are not onelie worthie of death which doo euill, but they also which doo agrée and consent to them that doo euill. Againe, Rom. 7. Nesciuissem concupiscentiam esse peccatum, nisi lex dixisset, Non concupisces: I had not knowne that concupiscence was sinne, except that the lawe had said vnto me; Thou shalt not couet nor vse concupiscence.
Wherefore and to what vse doo we receiue the Lords supper?
Bicause Christ commandeth vs so to doo, Luc. 22. 1. Cor. 11. and also for a thankefull and continuall remembrance of Christes death, and of the diuerse benefits that all mankind receiueth thereby: and the faithfull doo take, eate, and drinke the Lords supper after a heauenlie and spirituall sort, but yet verelie and indéed, therefore we are therewith fed to euerlasting life. It is enough once to be baptised, as once to be borne into this world. But as we néed in this world often times to be fed and nourished: so the [Page 124] Lords supper must be often times receiued.
The Stoiks opinion of putting awaie of affections is foolish and vnpossible,
Matth. 5.Christ willeth vs to put awaie affections, as wrath, and such other like,
Therefore the opinion of Christ, of putting awaie wrath, agréeth with the Stoiks, and is vnpossible.
I answer by distinction: The Stoiks, which affirme that no gréefe or affection can happen vnto a wise man, doo command vs vtterlie to take awaie from mans nature all affections, yea though they be ordinarie and good, as naturall loue towards our wiues, children and freends, Matt. 22. Luke. 10. which is not onelie vnpossible, but also wicked; bicause God saieth: Diliges proximum tuum sicut te ipsum: Thou shalt loue thy neighbour as thy selfe. And the apostle saith: Ephe. 5. Vni diligite vxores vestras: Ye husbands loue your wiues. And Christ dooth not bid vs vtterlie to take awaie out of our nature all affections, but onelie those which be inordinate, as priuate wrath or hatred. But Christ commandeth vs to guide and augment our ordinarie affections, as our loue towards our wiues and children, that they [Page 125] may be also conformable vnto the lawe of God. So then all wrath is not forbidden, for that it is said: Irascimini & nolite peccare: Be angrie and sinne not.
Of how manie sorts are the promises of God?
They are of two sorts, the promise of grace, and the promise of corporall benefits and goodnesse. The promise of grace is the reconciliation, forgiuenesse of sinnes, righteousnesse, and eternall life, which is promised and giuen fréelie to all them that truelie repent, gladlie heare the voice of the gospell, and beleeue on the sonne of God our mediator and redéemer, as it is witnessed in the first promise made in paradise: Semen mulieris conteret caput serpentis: Gene. 3. The séed of the woman shall bruse the head of the serpent. And Christ saieth: Num. 21. As Moses lifted vp the serpent in the wildernesse, so must the sonne of man be lifted vp: Iohn. 3. Vt omnis qui credit in eum non pereat, sed vitam habeat aeternam: To the end that all that beleeue in him should not perish, but haue life euerlasting. And his promises of corporall goodnesse are the collecting and gathering together of his church out of mankind, and the preseruing of the same, in the which he would [Page 126] be knowne and glorified; howbeit, it is oftentimes a small companie: as it is said, Grex meus pusillus grex: My flocke is a little flocke, oppressed diuers times in diuers places by sorrowes and persecutions. Yet God notwithstanding defendeth it, and preserueth it maruelouslie, so that all the tyrants in the world are not able to destroie the least members of Christes mysticall bodie, before they haue finished the course of their liues and ministeries: Matth. 10. for Christ saith: Capilli capitis vestri numerati sunt omnes: All the haires of your heads be numbred, meaning all those that be his seruants, vpon whom nothing commeth, but by the sufferance and visitation of GOD their heauenlie father.
S. Hierom saieth: Let him be accurssed, which saith, The lawe is impossible, or that God commandeth things vnpossible,
Therefore men may fulfill the lawe, and by fulfilling of the lawe they are righteous before God, and doo obteine by their obedience towards the lawe, remission of their sinnes, and eternall life.
I answer first by distinction. The lawe is possible to be fulfilled by the [Page 127] grace of God, chéeflie bicause we are reputed and taken to be righteous fréelie, through faith in the sonne of God. Next, the obedience of the lawe beginneth in vs through the Holie-ghost, the which obedience though it be vnperfect and vncleane; yet it pleaseth God for the person which is reconciled to him by faith in his sonne our mediatour: by this waie the lawe is possible. But it is vnpossible touching perfect obedience, which man can neither doo nor beginne in this life, for the corruption of our nature which letteth vs so to doo, without the aid of the Holie-ghost: for it is written: Animalis homo non percipit ea quae spiritus sancti sunt: 1. Cor. 2. The naturall man perceiueth not the things which belong vnto the Holie-ghost. Againe: Affectus carnis est inimicitia aduersus Deum: The desire or lust of the flesh is an enimie against God. For the flesh is not subiect to the lawe of God, neither truelie will it be so willinglie. Therefore God commandeth that which is vnpossible to be doone by the onelie power of the flesh; first, bicause we should acknowledge our owne infirmities; next, bicause we should aske forgiuenesse of him for Christ his sake; thirdlie, for that we should alwaies endeuour to [Page 128] amend our liues here in this world. Howbeit, the papists in no case will haue it thus to be. But we that truelie professe this gospell, doo acknowledge and confesse, that we cannot absolutelie obserue the law, bicause God dooth not onelie require of vs an outward obseruing of the same, but also an inward obseruing: for not onelie he is guiltie of whoredome that committeth the act, but he also that lusteth after an other mans wife. Matth. 5. He is not onelie a murtherer that killeth a man: but he also that hateth his brother in his heart. 1. Ioh. 3. And who can saie he lusteth not, &c. Let the papists find such a one among the children of men, and then we will grant that the lawe is not vnpossible to be kept of vs which be fraile miserable, earth, Luc. 17. ashes, and all of vs vnprofitable seruants.
How manie vses and finall ends be there of miracles?
1 There be chéefelie thrée. First, that miracles should be a testimonie of the doctrine and vocation of Christ, Iohn. 5. as it is written; The works that my father gaue me to finish, the same works that I doo: Testificantur de me, quòd pater miserit me: Beare witnesse of me, that the father hath sent me.
[Page 129]Secondlie, that miracles should be examples, 2 and as it were visible words, testifieng that the promises be true which God hath made vnto his church; namelie, that he will giue his people food and defensement, as the psalmist saieth: Psalm. 33. Non est inopia timentibus eum: They feele no scarsitie that feare him, and the eie of the Lord is vpon them that feare him, and vpon them that put their trust in his mercie, to deliuer their soules from death, and to féed them in the time of dearth. Further, Christes rule is immoueable, saieng: Matth. 6. Primùm quaerite regnum Dei: First séeke ye the kingdome of God, and the righteousnesse thereof, and all these things necessarie for vs shall be ministred vnto vs. Christ confirmed these and such other his promises, by féeding the people miraculouslie in the wildernesse, and the children of Israell with Manna: Marc. 8. also by sustaining and defending of Elias the prophet, whom God fed by the ministerie of a rauen: and by the increasing of the poore widowes meale in hir barrell, 3. Reg. 17. This widow was the prophet Ionas his mother. and hir oile in hir cruse, which poore woman dwelt in the citie of Sarepta in the countrie of Sydon, where Elias raised vp hir dead sonne to life againe.
[Page 130]3 Thirdlie, that his miracles should be causes of application and applieng his benefit [...] vnto vs, that as he hath alwaies and in al [...] places defended his seruants, and preserue [...] them, Dani. 1.3. as Daniel from the lions téeth, the thrée children from the burning ouen; an [...] Ionas from drowning, and hath fed them: so he will likewise euer defend his church, and féed vs, if we will be diligent hearers, faithfull beléeuers, obedient folowers, and gladsome dooers of his holie gospell, so fa [...] forth as our fraile weakenesse will giue vs leaue so to doo.
We must serue God fréelie, and without looking for anie reward,
Therefore we must not desire nor look [...] for corporall benefits.
I denie the consequent. We must first and principallie serue God fréelie, without respect or looking for anie commoditie or reward, but onlie therfore, bicause the reasonable creature oweth obedience to GOD his creator. Also we must desire and looke for corporall benefits, both for the conseruation of our selues and the church, which haue néed of corporall benefits in this life, as Christ saith himselfe: [Page 131] Nouit pater vester coelestis, Matth. 6. quòd opus habetis his om [...]ibus: Your heauenlie father knoweth that you haue néed of all these things. Therefore [...]e commandeth vs to aske for dailie bread, and not for monethlie or yearelie bread, bicause we haue néed dailie to depend of his heauenlie goodnesse, and bicause he would haue vs dailie and alwaies to praie vnto him. It is written: Psal. 49. Inuoca me in die tribulationis, & ego eripiam te, & glorificabis me: Thou shalt call vpon me in the daie of trouble, and I will deliuer thée, and thou shalt glorifie me.
What is repentance, which is so often mentioned in the scriptures?
It is the conuersion or the returning of a sinner vnto God, acknowledging his sinnes, and desiring pardon and forgiuenesse of them at Gods hands, Luke. 7. for Christes sake, and is the beginning of a new obedience towards God and his holie laws, 2. Reg. 11. 2. Par. 33. Luc. 19. Iohn. 18. as we haue examples of Marie Magdalen, Dauid, Manasses, Zache, Peter, the theefe, S. Paule, and such others, which truelie repented, and receiued therefore the fruit and benefit of their repentance.
Christ saith, Matt. 20. To sit at my right hand or at my left, is not mine to giue,
[Page 132]Therefore Christ is not omnipotent.
The fallacie lieth in the consequent, and we must answer herein by distinction. First, it is not Christes to giue this, according to the time of his ministerie and humilitie. Next, it was not his to giue vnto Iames the lesse, and his brother Iohn, for the prerogatiue of their kindred, supposing themselues to be Christes cousens, bicause their mother Solome was Iosephs sister, and therefore they were high-minded, and would haue a principalitie before the rest of the apostles in the kingdome of Christ. Further, Christ speaketh not in this place of his diuine power, wherein he is equall with his father, and worketh all things as his father dooth; for the euangelist saith: Iohn. 5. Pater meus ad hoc vsque tempus operatur, & ego operor: My father worketh euen vnto this time, and I worke also. And as the father raiseth vp the dead, and quickeneth them: Sic & filius quos vult viuificat: So the sonne also quickeneth such as listeth him; Iohn. 10. saieng: Ego do eis vitam aeternam: I giue them eternall life: Neque rapiet eos quisquam de manu mea: And no man shall take them out of my hand.
Luke. 7.Christ said to Marie Magdalen, [Page 133] that hir sinnes were forgiuen hir, bicause she loued much,
Therefore hir sinnes were forgiuen hir for hir loues sake.
I denie the consequent, bicause the figure Synecdoche is here vsed, which is as much to saie as a part for the whole, or the whole for a part; for vnder the name of loue, is conteined our whole conuersion and turning to God. And Christ saieth afterward: Fides tua saluam te fecit: Thy faith hath made thée safe. Also there is a double absolution, the first is of our owne conscience before God, which commeth onelie by our stedfast faith in Christ our mediatour. The other absolution must be doone before the congregation, where there must be declared the testimonies of true conuersion or repentance: as Christ alledged and commended before the Pharisie and other his ghests, the works of this conuertant Marie. Luke. 7. Therefore loue is the effect or the fruit of the remission of our sinnes, and not the merit or the cause efficient.
Christ commended the false steward, Luk. 16.
The same steward was a théefe,
Therefore he commended a theefe.
I denie the consequent: bicause the fallacie lieth in the accident. For he dooth not commend the Species, that is, the theft, but the Genus, that is the prouidence of the steward which he would haue euerie man to followe, but in a contrarie matter; to wit, in the procuring and getting of eternall aids and helps vnto euerlasting life, which men in the church that are called to the knowledge of the gospell doo more neglect, than worldlie men which are out of the church doo these temporall goods. For worldlie goods and temporall blessings, which are séene, tasted, and perceiued with our outward senses, bicause they are externall, doo more mightilie mooue vs than heauenlie things, which are onelie seene with the eie of faith, being verie blind and dimme in carnall and worldlie minded men, as the scripture saith: [...]. Cor. 2. Animalis homo non percipit ea quae spiritus Dei sunt: A worldlie man perceiueth not the things which belong vnto the spirit of God.
Luke. 16.Christ saith, that the poore doo receiue their benefactors into euerlasting tabernacles,
Therefore saints shall receiue vs into euerlasting life, and not Christ.
[Page 135]Also, almesdéeds and good works shall merit and deserue eternall life.
I denie the consequent, bicause Christ in this spéech vseth the figure Synecdoche (which is a part for the whole, or the whole for a part) and therein he compriseth both himselfe and his saints. Iohn. 14.1. Coloss. 3. For Christ receiueth them, as the true authour and onelie giuer of eternall life. But the saints, or the congregation of Christ, are as witnesses of our beneficence, or liberalitie towards them, whereby we haue declared our liuelie faith: and they also praie together with vs in this world; for vs, for our parents, for the politike gouernance, and for all such as giue enterteinment to the afflicted members of Christ. And God doth blesse and prosper both priuatlie and publikelie for the liberalitie extended to his church: as the kingdome of Assyria fared the better, Dan. 1. for that Daniel was well vsed there. And all the land of Aegypt sped the better likewise for the fauour and courtesie that king Pharao shewed vnto Ioseph the sonne of Iacob and Rachael, Ge. 3. &, 41. when he was in his countrie. Therefore both Christ and his saints must néeds be comprised in both members of this sentence: as, Facite vobis amicos: [Page 136] Make you fréends, that is, Christ and his congregation: Vt recipiant vos: That they receiue you (that is; that Christ, both the authour and giuer, and his saints, the witnesses of your good works) into euerlasting habitations. And the apostle dooth sufficientlie testifie, that good works cannot merit or deserue eternall life, where he saith: Vita aeterna est donum Dei: Rom. 6. Eternall life is the gift of God, so that there can be no deseruing in vs. We are saued by grace through faith, and that not of our selues: bicause, Dei donum est, Ephes. 2. non ex operibus, ne quis glorietur▪ It is the gift of God, and not of works, least anie should boast of their works. Thus now we plainelie sée, how much the iusticiarie papists or rather Sadduces mistake this place, which draw the words of Christ euen as it were by the haire of the head, to prooue the valor of their works, which they saie they haue of supererogation, to wit, such works as doo not onelie suffice to saue themselues, but also their freends, and such other as it shall please them to saue. But note euer by the waie, that they saue none without monie, receiuing mens gold, and returning them chaffe backe againe: a verie bad exchange.
Againe, the aduersarie reasoneth thus:
Christ said vnto the lawyer reciting the summe of the lawe, Luke. 10. consisting in the loue of God and of our neighbour: Hoc fac & viues: Doo this and thou shalt liue,
Therefore eternall life is giuen vs for our works sake, or for the fulfilling of the lawe.
I denie the consequent; bicause there is no man liuing (for the corruption of our nature) able perfectlie to fulfill the lawe of God, which requireth of vs the full, whole, and perfect obedience of all our power & strength. And Christ saieng to the lawyer: Hoc fac & viues: Doo this and thou shalt liue, beateth downe his pride, which had not fulfilled the lawe, though he affirmed the contrarie: for he was guiltie of transgressing both the tables of Gods commandements (as all men are) and therefore he had néed of the Messias to be his mediatour, for whose sake God forgiueth vs our sinnes, and reckoneth vs to be righteous fréelie through his mercie, which when it commeth to passe, afterward our new obedience toward the lawe pleaseth God. And this obedience is necessarie in them that are new-borne, and come to the knowledge [Page 138] of God, and yet not to obteine thereby eternall life, which is the onelie gift of God, and is giuen vs through Christ fréelie by faith in him, Rom. 6. Ephe. 2. but to declare the present righteousnesse or faith in Christ, which worketh and is effectuall by the loue of God and of our neighbour.
Luke. 10.The Samaritane (that is Christ) said, that he would repaie his hoste whatsoeuer he laid out, more than the two pence he tooke him,
Therefore we may teach more and other things than are deliuered to the church in the old and new testament: and man also may doo more than God requireth, which are called the works of supererogation.
I denie the consequent. First Christ speaketh of no new or other doctrine, beside the same which is alreadie of God by inspiration manifested; but he meaneth it of a more large and fruitfull exposition of the heauenlie doctrine, which ought to be doone according to the proportion of faith, as the holie apostle saieth. Rom. 15. Therefore the aduersarie dooth lewdlie expound that place touching works more than due. Againe, Christ speaketh not of the merit of eternall life, but of the good successe which we haue in [Page 139] our vocation and counselles, whereof S. Paule speaketh thus: Labor vester non erit inanis in Domino: Your labour shall not be vaine in the Lord. And Christ saieth: Ero vobiscum vsque ad consummationem saeculi: I will be with you vnto the end of the world. And: Non relinquam vos orphanos, sed veniam ad vos: I will not leaue you comfortlesse, but I will come againe vnto you.
How shall we assure our selues that we must desire and looke for all goodnesse at Gods hands, touching the necessities of this life?
First, euerie man must endeuour 1 himselfe to be a member of the church of God, a disciple of Christ, and an hearer of his doctrine; that is, he must imbrace, learn, and diligentlie thinke vpon the heauenlie doctrine, and assent thervnto. Next, he must 2 doo all the offices and labours of his vocation, honestlie, faithfullie, and diligentlie: referring all his actions to the glorie of the name of God, to the vtilitie and profit of the church and his neighbour. Thirdlie, he 3 must desire in his praier, and looke for of God to haue prosperous successe and euent, for our mediatours sake Christ the sonne of God. Fourthlie, he must put himselfe in 4 [Page 140] subiection in his crosse, and afflictions to the will of God, humblie desiring and looking for deliuerance and mitigation of his sorrowes, according to the good pleasure of God, patientlie abiding his leasure, & not appointing him either the time or meanes of his deliuerance; which being so doone, God certeinlie dooth heare vs, helpe vs, and deliuer vs maruellouslie, yea although we be destitute of all worldlie helpe and succour. For God is almightie, and the most frée agent, not tied to anie second causes, as the philosophers of the Stoiks sect wickedlie dreamed. Therefore, the Christians haue a most sure consolation and comfort in all afflictions and sorrowes, in scarsitie, in contagious diseases, in pestilence, in wars, and spoiling of the church, in the furies of tyrants, yea in death it selfe; that God is euer omnipotent, & that he is our susteiner and defense, and as it were our pleasant shadow place, so that no discommoditie can happen vnto vs by anie creature, contrarie to the fatherlie pleasure of our God, as the apostle saith: Rom. 8. Si Deus nobiscum, quis contra nos? If God be on our side, who can be against vs? And the Lord himselfe saith: Matth. 10. Vestri etiam capilli capitis omnes numerati sunt: All the haires of [Page 141] your heads are numbred, feare not therfore.
Christ saith; Matt. 6 Be not carefull for to morrowe, for to morrowe daie shall care for it selfe,
Therefore Christ forbiddeth vs to be carefull of our liuing.
I denie the consequent, and doo answer by distinction. For there is a double kind of carefulnesse. There is one kind of carefulnesse about our labour and art, which is not forbidden but commanded of God, as S. Paule saith: Rom. 12. Qui praesit cum solicitudine in diligentia, non ignauia: Let him that ruleth doo it with diligence, and not with sluggishnes. And the care of our labour or art is the diligence of vnderstanding what thing is good in our art, and which is the way to doo the worke of our calling in the feare and inuocation of God. The other carefulnesse is heathenish, as though we could prouide for our selues by our carefulnes, with a diffidence also in God, Matth. 6. which is denied of Christ, as in Matthew, so in manie other places. For it is a torment of mind, which riseth either for the feare of discommoditie, or for the hope of some commoditie, without the true notice and knowledge of the will of God. This carefulnesse doubleth our [Page 142] sorrowes and harme, for the present gréefe and torment of the imminent danger which by our owne wisdome and strength we are not able to eschue. The effect of this carefulnesse is a fretting and a repining against God, working wofulnesse in vs, and manie other errors.
Luke. 7.Whie dooth the euangelist saie, that Christ deliuered the widowe hir sonne at Naim, when he was raised vp from death?
Bicause the yoongman now being raised vp from death, was Christes, and not his mothers, which had lost all hir right and interest in him, for that he was naturallie dead. Children belong not vnto their parents againe after they are dead, for if we die in the Lord, we are euer afterward the Lords, & not our parents children.
Christes miracles are the tokens that he is the true Messias,
The diuell also did miracles among the Gentiles sometimes,
Therefore miracles are doubtfull signes sometimes of the Messias.
I denie the consequent, and doo answer by distinction; bicause the diuell is not able to imitate or followe the miracles [Page 143] of Christ or of his church, as to raise vp the dead, to stop the course of the sunne, to make the drie and barren fertill and fruitfull. And whereas we doo read, that the dead were raised vp among the gentiles, and miracles were shewed; they were onelie the meere illusions of the diuels, which are not able to make anie thing of nothing, neither to corrupt or destroie the good creatures of God without his sufferance. For as the herdsman holdeth backe his cur in the chaine: Iude. so the Lord hath in subiection reserued the diuels in euerlasting chaines vnder darkenesse, vnto the iudgement of the great daie.
Séeing angels be good and euill, what is the office of good angels?
The office of good angels, is to preserue and defend Gods people, namelie the church, the politicall gouernance and commons; as the prophet saith: Psalm. 33. Circumuallat angelus domini timentes eum, & eripiet eos; The angell of the Lord tarrieth round about them that feare him, and will deliuer them. Againe: Angelis suis mandauit de te, Psalm. 91. vt custodiant te in omnibus vijs tuis: He hath giuen his angels charge ouer thée, that they shall kéep thée in all thy waies. And Christ himselfe [Page 144] speaketh most comfortablie of children: Amen dico vobis, quòd angeli puerorum semper vident faciem patru mei, Matth. 18. qui in coelis est: Verelie I saie vnto you, that the angels of children behold the face of my father which is in heauen. Such is the great humilitie of these most excellent spirits, that they be the kéepers of children, they sit about their cradels, they walke with vs, they be with vs in our beds, at the fire, at the table, and euerie where, alwaies resisting the wicked angels, that they should not hurt vs in bodie or in goods: which they alwaies diligentlie endeuour to doo, according to this saieng: Diabolus circuit nos, 1. Pet. 5. tanquam leo rugiens, quarens quem deuoret: The diuell goeth round about vs like a roring lion séeking whom he may deuoure. Thus he dooth, not mooued therevnto by anie pleasure or commoditie that he hath thereby; but onelie for the insatiable hatred that he beareth against God, & his sonne Christ, whom he would not haue to be glorified in mankind, but that all men shuld blaspheme God, as he dooth himselfe, bicause he knoweth to be still in a damnable state.
Matth. 18.Christ biddeth vs cut off our hands and féet, also to plucke out our eies, if they be a let vnto vs,
[Page 145]Therefore these members must be destroied and cast awaie.
I denie the consequent, bicause it is a metaphoricall spéech. For our hands and féet doo signifie our fellowes and fréends, our eies doo signifie our admonishers and counsell-giuers, which would abduce vs and lead vs awaie from God, his doctrine, true religion, or from a godlie life. Therefore we must cut off, relinquish, and auoid their companies and counsels. And it is not onelie our outward parts, that be lets and hinderances vnto vs, to trauell toward the celestiall Hierusalem; but also euen our hearts, Matth. 12. out of the which doo come euill thoughts and offenses.
If sinne be the cause of sickenesse and death, Matth. 9. whie are christians subiect to death, sorrowes, and other infirmities incident to mankind, séeing their sinnes are forgiuen them?
First, bicause the remnant of sinnes hangeth and cleaueth fast yet in the nature of those that are regenerate and new-borne, which must be mortified and abolished by death and other calamities, as the apostle saith: Rom. 7. Corpus mortificatur propter peccatum: The bodie must be mortified [Page 146] for sinne, which sticketh fast in our flesh or nature. Next, that God might shew his power infinite in the deliuering of the good, contrarie to the power, furie, and tyrannie of the diuell and his members, according as it is written: Psalm. 5. Mirificauit Dominus sanctum suum: The Lord hath maruellouslie wrought with his saints; that is, he hath wonderfullie deliuered his seruant. Thirdlie, bicause the faith & praier of the godlie might shine, and be exercised in calamities, as it is said: Vexatio dat intellectum: Vexation giueth vnderstanding. Esai. 29.26. Againe: Domine in tribulatione visitant te: Lord the people in their trouble will visit thée. The miserie wherin mankind make their praiers vnto God, is a discipline and correction to them, to wake them out of their securitie & carelesse slumbering in sin.
Their sinnes must be forgiuen them, which doo acknowledge the same, and doo promise amendment of life, according to this saieng: Quorumcunque peccata remiseritis, remittentur eis: Whose sinnes so euer ye shall forgiue, they shall be forgiuen them. Againe; Luke. 24. Preach repentance and forgiuenesse of sinnes in my name. Therefore there ought to be no excommunication in the church, or punishment to be executed vpon [Page 147] the wicked by the magistrate.
I denie the consequent. First, bicause there is a double ministerie of the gospell: the one is the declaration of the gospell, by the which the sinnes knowne and the sinnes vnknowne are forgiuen to all them that doo truelie repent, according to the former saieng: Whose sinnes so euer ye forgiue, they are forgiuen them. But such as doo manifestlie offend, and be often admonished, yet will not repent and amend, they are to be excommunicated; that is, they are to be cast out of the societie of the church, vntill they doo amend their liues, and shew publike signes and tokens of their amendment. So Christ commandeth him that falleth, first to be admonished, that he may of his owne accord returne into the waie; if he returne, he commandeth him to be receiued; if not, to be excommunicated: as the Corinthians excommunicated the incestuous person at the commandement of S. Paule, and as Ambrose excommunicated Stilicons scribe. Next, the magistrate hath a commandement to punish the wicked, for it is written: Qui gladium accipit gladio perilit: He that taketh the sword shall perish with the sword. Also, Rom. 13. Magistratus Dei minister [Page 148] est, vltor ad iram ei, qui quod malum est fecerit: The magistrate is Gods minister to take vengeance of him that dooth euill.
How shall the iudgement be in the end of the world?
Matth. 24.In the end of the world, Christ shall come in the clouds of heauen, accompanied with the holie angels of his power and flaming fire: and at the horrible sound and dreadfull blast of the trumpet, which shall then sound as it were these words: Surgite mortui, 2. Thes. 1. venite ad iudicium omnes: Arise you dead, and come all vnto iudgement. All mankind that haue liued from the creation of the world to that time, shall rise againe whole and perfect, with their bodies & soules before the iudgement seat of God, and shall go to reaping of the fruits that they haue sowne in this world: namelie, they that haue sowne in the flesh, Galar. 6. shall reape corruption of the flesh; and those that haue sowne in the spirit, shall reape life euerlasting.
1. Cor. 15.We shall all rise againe at the last daie, The wicked shall not stand in the iudgement, Psal. 1. Therefore all shall not rise againe.
The consequent truelie, is in this place nothing true. Psal. 1. For the prophet [Page 149] speaketh not héere of the generall iudgement that shall be at the end of the world, when Christ shall appeare in the maiestie of his glorie, to iudge the quicke and the dead; for then all without exception, both good and euill, shall rise againe to receiue the reward of the works of their bodies. Of this resurrection S. Paule speaketh abundantlie, 1. Thes. 4. 1. Cor. 15. and Dauid compareth in this scripture the good with the wicked, praising the vertues of the good: saieng; His leafe shall not fall awaie. And in the same place a little after by a pretie antithesis he describeth the wicked, Antitheton: a figure, when contraries be compared. recording: Non sic impij, non sic: The wicked shall be nothing so, nor shall prosper in anie their dooings and studies like the godlie, but they shall be scattered as most vaine, like dust vpon the face of the earth, and shall not continue in the function of iudgement, and ministerie of office, as other men doo: but they shall be cut off, 1. Reg. 31. 3. Reg. 12. as Saule and Ieroboam were, with their posteritie; and Dauid continued in his séed, and reigned continuallie. Againe, the wicked shall not arise in iudgement, when they shall be giuen to be iudged by the word of God, & yet will not amend their liues, but will flie from the face of the earth with a troubled conscience; they will [Page 150] not be reprooued, but hate correction, & when Gods word condemneth them, they will growe into the furie of madnesse, they will not heare wholsome doctrine, but blaspheme it and persecute it euen to the death, like swine and mad dogs. As for example. The Phariseis stirred against the Lord and his Christ, they came together, they consulted, they practised althings to kéepe the pompe of their owne glorie & lucre: and to destroie Christ and his gospell. This is the meaning of the psalmograph. The wicked doo not arise and ascend into iudgement, to iudge themselues to amendment of life, but lie in blindnesse, and harden themselues in wickednes, not suffering the iudgement of the spirit: whereas euerie good man will gladlie haue all his owne righteousnes (which is like a defiled cloth) to be condemned, Esaie. 64. and to appeale to the righteousnesse which we haue in Christ Iesus, to whom with the father and the Holie-ghost be all power, honor and glorie, now and for euer and euer, Amen.
Imprinted at London by H. Denham.